I am also not so sure about this transfer. Actually he is a good wide player, but the question is 'is he good enough for United'? I am worried that even at 25, he can be some kind of smashed in the shadow of the big guns in PSG for a few years - Ibra, Cavani, Pastore, Di Maria, Neymar, Mbappe. He's rarely playing and what I wonder is if he is going to show his real talent or he completely lost it. It's a bit risky transfer, but actually for that money (20-25m) he's not gonna have a big weight on his shoulders and for sure United will still have at least 1 or 2 marquee signings in the summer. He's a clear Right Winger so ok, let's give him a chance.
Lucas Moura - (Caf decides he’s naff again) Spurs bound?
- Thread starter Bastian
- Start date
- Status
Moura good performance against Chelsea away.
Gelson Martis is fast and agile but Sporting would not sell him for less than 50M which is a gamble as the player still needs to grow before playing in a team like Man United.Aren't there any upcoming 18 yr old winger-gems in Portugal, e.g. at sporting?
Think this guy will surprise many fans here, if the deal goes through. He's not just a speed merchant like Walcott. Surely not as fancy as Mbappe and Dimaria but don't underestimate the power of Jose of bring the best of a player, that still has much to prove.
He's also 22 so 4 years off.
It's not a risky transfer:
- Never injured
- 25 years: experienced but not very old.
- Some credentials at the European stage
- Physically suited for the Premier League: he's more robust than players like Mata or Herrera
Acquisition scenario: acquisition for 25 millions.
Worst-case scenario: you sell him for 15 millions in 2020, a loss of 10 millions.
That's a bullshit explanation.I wasn't aware of either of the stereotypes that you mention. Bear in mind that I'm not British.
In fact I wasn't trying to be racist at all. It did occur to me that all the players I'd listed were black, but I didn't want to self-censor my post because others are a little too eager to take offense where none is meant.
I probably would have if I'd anticipated the furore though.
I think it's fair to think that United will acquire only one marquee signing in 2018.
I have the feeling that there is a great chance to see Griezmann at United next season, which would be the perfect required upgrade IMO. Simeone said he was ready to see the player leaving the club next summer. The competition would be limited: maybe Real Madrid or City even if unlikely.
Bale is really a risky acquisition: high price, a lot of injuries in the previous seasons...
I have the feeling that there is a great chance to see Griezmann at United next season, which would be the perfect required upgrade IMO. Simeone said he was ready to see the player leaving the club next summer. The competition would be limited: maybe Real Madrid or City even if unlikely.
Bale is really a risky acquisition: high price, a lot of injuries in the previous seasons...
He isn't a Sub for PSG. 79mins this season for PSG in potential 28 games. That's a player that's been completely phased out. That means he's played a total of 3.13% of the season for PSG this year in all Comps.
You'd ideally hope a Jan attacking signing would automatically come in and give your team a lift. Is this lad even fit enough to do that. He's basically had no football, no way is he match fit. I know he's available cut price due to PSG needing to sell, and in this super inflated market he represents great value. Could be 4-5 weeks before he is even ready for 90 mins, plus there's always that adjusting to a new league settling in period as well. If he comes I'd welcome it, he's an upgrade on what we have, long term is he the answer, I have my concerns on that, but price wise he's worth the risk.
It seems you like figures so let's go.
PSG spent more than 400 millions last summer and was about to sell him: Liverpool and Arsenal were interested IIRC. PSG do need to sell players before the 30th June for accounting considerations in order to limit the UEFA sanctions (yeah Financial Fair Play is a reality). Without the FFP, the club wouldn't have tried to sell him now in case there are future injuries.
What happened last summer? Neymar said 'Hey! I don't want my friend Lucas to move' so the club didn't sell him...
The strategy was to make Lucas extremely unhappy to ensure that the player wants to move in winter and a deal before the 30th June. The same strategy was applied to a player like Ben Arfa who played his last game for PSG 12 months ago.
UEFA only look at financial accounts. He was aquired for 42 millions in 2013. His book value (accounting) is around 10 millions (end of contract 2019 so 42*5/6=10). If sold for 25 millions, it would generate an accounting added value of 15 millions (25-10). If he leaves now, there will be savings on wages (say 5 millions gross amount) in the next months too.
If Lucas leaves now for 25, all things being equal, the PSG net income (end of june) will increase by 15+5 = +20 millions at least.
The UEFA sanctions are based on their understanding of the club's business plan and some accounting indicators net income.
Yeah, Lucas Moura is fully blacklisted to make a deal happen.
#Management #Rumours #Transfers #United2018 #FFP
Last edited:
This must be the go to thread this window. With the usual result
As usual, people just talking out their arse, probably saw one person say he can't cross so now they are running with that idea. I've seen him whip in wonderful crosses to the likes of ibra and cavani, plus yes when he was playing he was often on corners and freekicks. People have no idea what they're talking about.
I wasn't aware of either of the stereotypes that you mention. Bear in mind that I'm not British.
In fact I wasn't trying to be racist at all. It did occur to me that all the players I'd listed were black, but I didn't want to self-censor my post because others are a little too eager to take offense where none is meant.
I probably would have if I'd anticipated the furore though.
saying you're not British when your location says Ireland isn't much of an excuse considering the cross pollination of media and stereotypes isn't much of an excuse.Jonathan Johnson probably watches more Ligue 1 than most, If he is saying this, we must hope this transfer has no legs. I have nothing but bad feelings about it!
We should be looking at Pulisic or Mahrez.
We should be looking at Pulisic or Mahrez.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Anyone think he might actually be bought for RWB?
How hungry will he be though? Chose money in the first place, didn't peak as he was supposed to.
This is the exact signing we wouldn't do under Fergie - a possible burnout when we could go after a rising talent with lots of hunger.
This is the exact signing we wouldn't do under Fergie - a possible burnout when we could go after a rising talent with lots of hunger.
The guy was a big fan of Krychowiak last summer and advised Liverpool to acquire him. On the bench at West Bromwich nowadays...
Amongst PSG fans, mixed feelings about Lucas Moura while there is a consensus to say Krychowiak never had the required level to play for a club like PSG.
No way that's going to happen or he will agree to move to ManUtd to play as RWB.
Money always matter but I think he chose a project: Leonardo was the Brazilian sporting director, some Brazilian players in the squad (Thiago Silva, Alex, Maxwell...)...
A burnout may occur when you play 60 games per season during several consecutive seasons.
World Cup at the end of the season too...
In all honesty, big clubs should not do business with PSG right now. Wait to see what happens with FFP. If they get banned from europe, there's a chance some of the bigger names might look for a way out, and PSG might have to let them go
And would you rather sign Lucas now, or Verratti in the summer?
And would you rather sign Lucas now, or Verratti in the summer?
https://www.reddit.com/r/psg/comments/7p7rlr/lucas_moura/
Says it all really. Hard working, but one dimensional. Not first team quality. Maybe our reported annual budget of £150m a year is constraining Mourinho into making budget deals for inferior players.
Says it all really. Hard working, but one dimensional. Not first team quality. Maybe our reported annual budget of £150m a year is constraining Mourinho into making budget deals for inferior players.
Messi would struggle at West Brom. You seen the way they play? - Pulis was sacked no too long ago. Bigger issues at West Brom than just player not playing well.
I don't know them but I can imagine the team profile.
Anyway, Krychowiak is a defensive midfielder and I thought he would be successful there given his good performances in Spain with Sevilla.
Yet he has had between 30-40 games a season without going that extra step up as expected. World Cup is always an excuse, but what is the excuse for motivation between those 4 years then? He was a huge talent before joining PSG - I personally thought we had missed out on the next new super-star.
On the contrary: I can only think of how Moyes would have managed him too
Btw: I'm saying he's a possible burnout - not that he's burned out already. What I really mean is that he lacks consistent focus to be what he could be (was a huge talent)
I would rather have the Brazilian Walcott than the Spanish Cleverley and the Armenian Bebe.
And the problem is that you were wrong, Lucas was overrated and overhyped coming out of Brazil, he wasn't a huge talent and he improved massively, now he is a decent player.Yet he has had between 30-40 games a season without going that extra step up as expected. World Cup is always an excuse, but what is the excuse for motivation between those 4 years then? He was a huge talent before joining PSG - I personally thought we had missed out on the next new super-star.
On the contrary: I can only think of how Moyes would have managed him too
Btw: I'm saying he's a possible burnout - not that he's burned out already. What I really mean is that he lacks consistent focus to be what he could be (was a huge talent)
I do remember some debates in 2012 on a PSG forum 'Who is the most talented player: Lucas or Neymar?'
You are underestimating Lucas if you think he is in the same region as Walcot.
Lucas has technically ability that Walcot is sorely lacking.
If we do get Lucas I know he would do well. He at certain games win the game on his own, but what he would give us is balance and won't allow the team to double or triple mark Martial or Rashford. Furthermore, I believe he would actually complement Lukaku.
We need a winger and Lucas would be our best winger by a margin!
Still nothing concrete on this.
I see a lot of people have talked themselves into this where it becomes an obvious, must have player but it still seems to based on very little.
I see a lot of people have talked themselves into this where it becomes an obvious, must have player but it still seems to based on very little.
Same people that are moaning that we overspent on Lukaku and Pogba and telling us that we should aim for a cheap player like Salah.
Well no, I wasnt - he was a huge talent. If you've seen a 19 year old fella do these sort of things you would be thinking he had a real talent. This is from 2012 when we were all drooling over Lucas Moura. The whole RedCafe had jizzy pants for him. Neither Nani or Ronaldo would be able to pull off a highlight reel like this at that age.
Just take a look at this video and check out some of his screamers, insane dribbles, etc. It was very legit back then to have a Neymar vs Moura debate. Captain hindsight strikes again.
There's something wrong with people who make these vids...
Can't watch it with the volume on, horrible music, and too loud!
Was joking dude. I know Moura is better than Walcott and I think we should buy him.
I don't care about the whole RedCafe, his first games with PSG told the all story, he was overrated and wasn't fit to lace Neymar's boots.
And you can do without your captain hindsight because I'm not telling you that I knew how he was but when you realize that a player is overrated, you can just admit it.
Although I'm by no means as optimistic in regards to Lucas as you, you make a fair point here. Particularly in bigger game, whoever ends up playing on the left is effectively taken out of the game due to the opposition's defence/midfield being able to double up on them. Having real pace and direction either side of Lukaku would certainly go some way in nullifying this. That said, he better be good at tracking back otherwise he won't be playing in those matches.
Yeah, the debate existed but the difference between them was obvious during their first minutes out of Brazil, also Neymar was grossly underrated with people thinking that he was a youtube player.I do remember some debates in 2012 on a PSG forum 'Who is the most talented player: Lucas or Neymar?'
It took you about 20 seconds to reply. Can't possibly have watched the highlights to see that he was touted as a huge talent with same dribbles as Ronaldo or better. Can't have a normal debate with such an auto-replier. You instantly just called me wrong without even having any other argument than he sucked when he entered PSG - That doesn't take away his huge talent when in Brazil - everyone thought he was going to be the next big thing. You simply just scrape away his years in Brazil and base his talent on his PSG career.
Everyone? Being a bit dramatic aren't you?
Can't have a normal debate with such an auto-replier. You instantly just called me wrong without even having any other argument than he sucked when he entered PSG - That doesn't take away his huge talent when in Brazil - everyone thought he was going to be the next big thing. You simply just scrape away his years in Brazil and base his talent on his PSG career.
- Status