syrian_scholes
Honorary Straw Hat
Wait, all the anger here is about the little blm?
Wait, all the anger here is about the little blm?
Fully Automated Deluxe GammonismAh ok. So two wrongs make a right then? Excellent argument
I said it in another thread but it takes less effort for some folk to understand a symbol like the cenotaph than it does hundreds of years of oppression and murder at the hands of exploitative overlords and the many intricacies that come with it. Which is why they probably care about it / notice it more.So wait... you're more angry over a statue being defaced than centuries of racism, oppression, genocide, etc....
He needs to go back to page one and start calling out all of it.no I am not. To suggest that you challenge everyone all of the time is absurd.
Can you honestly tell me that you challenge every opinion or action that you have ever come across that’s wrong?
It shows.I used to watch The Black and White Minstrel Show and laughed at Jim Davidson.
Wait. And go where?Burning the cenotaph flags. If you hate this country so much then fecking leave!
No, if you have an argument to make then make it.Do some research about treatment of black soldiers when they returned from the war.
Where you stop is when you don't care enough about the act being undertaken.Of course I would in most situations.
but where do you stop? Do I report a gardener, who I know is not fully declaring his taxes? I cannot be expected to challenge everything, and every opinion, and every action that is wrong.
it’s the other chap who believes that you have to be actively anti something, otherwise you are complicit in that viewpoint which is beyond absurd.
feck me it's hard to keep track of all the racists now. Luckily we have plenty of self-righteous experts to point them out.
Mum said about this earlier we come from near Bristol and I've lived there. I guessed it was to do with the slave trade. Apparently they threw the statue in the river as a show of what colston did with black people. We both agreed that protests that damage property was bad but this was an exception.Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Gammon are pissed.
so because of a small minority, people shouldn’t protest racial injustice?There are videos out there of black police being attacked. I guess those black lives don’t count?
We can't - since we took back control of our country we're locked-down, have no flights, no money, no country and no control.If you hate this country so much then fecking leave!
We've had a few of those in this thread.This argument is the equivalent of saying that black lives don’t matter because black people kill each other too.
Yeah I think I’m going to try and stick to the football forum because even though it’s a minority of posters, it’s depressing seeing some of the nonsense spewed in this thread.We've had a few of those in this thread.
Yeah threads like this always turn out quite depressing, though them going off the deep end and getting banned is somewhat entertaining.Yeah I think I’m going to try and stick to the football forum because even though it’s a minority of posters, it’s depressing seeing some of the nonsense spewed in this thread.
....?Before now the only things I associated BLM UK with were blocking ambulances on motorways and shutting down student libraries.
And the 'mass protests amid a pandemic for a virus that hits black people the hardest' strategy isn't doing much to change my general view of their approach to things.
Good. Not the first time he's had some slightly off views. Can't remember them offhand but seeing his name and that post didn't surprise me.He's gone.
Yeah and it helps me to put the ignore feature to use too!Yeah threads like this always turn out quite depressing, though them going off the deep end and getting banned is somewhat entertaining.
There are people that are smashing shit up and saying it's in the name of anti racism so it expunges them apparently from being viewed as complete and utter cnuts. Are they going to be viewed as noble in years from now as they are today?People often use this as a justification for the acts of the past, but is that really the case? It’s not difficult to imagine that you would still feel empathy for your fellow human and view their oppression as wrong, even if you were born 100 years ago.
I mean, even in those times there were people that viewed slavery etc as wrong. Even if it wasn’t the dominant mindset, it does show that it was not impossible, people simply didn’t want to.
Having a conscience and empathy is universal and timeless, regardless of what era you’re born in or what the dominant mindset is at the time.
As angry as I am about people trying to literally set the Cenotaph and all that it represents on fire - and those who think it's an irrelevance. This is also a brutal reaction, dunno if your upset, trolling, or just wrong but wise up.Burning the cenotaph flags. If you hate this country so much then fecking leave!
I don't think it's my place to speak on behalf of black people, it's on you to educate yourself on history and racism not on me.No, if you have an argument to make then make it.
If so why are you so attracted to right wing nonsense and conspiracy theory bullshit?I consider myself fairly left on most things and a liberal person.. but how society has shaped into one that's extremely far left, and extremely far right, I'm kind of in a situation where if I say anything out of the popular consensus, I will be labeled by both groups.
It is nothing to do with any status quo. You just seem to think that You Tube is primary literature and believe any old rubbish you find there. Then bring it here to distract and disrupt threads. That is why you get threadbanned.God forbid there are people who question the status quo.
The overly PC "regressive left" are alienating him, that's why we got Trump™ etc etc.If so why are you so attracted to right wing nonsense and conspiracy theory bullshit?
Yes. Lets deport citizens we don't agree with. Good idea.Burning the cenotaph flags. If you hate this country so much then fecking leave!
It will be viewed as a necessary step, yes. Peaceful protests have gone on deaf ears for decades. What do you suggest? Another century of taking the moral high ground and hoping that something changes from peaceful words alone?There are people that are smashing shit up and saying it's in the name of anti racism so it expunges them apparently from being viewed as complete and utter cnuts. Are they going to be viewed as noble in years from now as they are today?
One has nothing to do with the other. It's not like a Confederate monument or a statue of a slave owner. It's a monument to soldiers who died. It's vandalism and has feck all to do with race or racism.Few defaced memorials are nothing compared to centuries of racism, genocide, systemic injustices and inequality.
It's got them losing public support very quickly. This is easy as feck for Sun, Mail, Telegraph and the rest to spin.It's got people talking tbf, more than if they spray painted a wall round the back of Sainsburys.
Do you have a list of recommended books? I would like to educate myself a bit on the subjectI don't think it's my place to speak on behalf of black people, it's on you to educate yourself on history and racism not on me.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bu...s-racism-antiracism-black-scholars-2020-6?ampDo you have a list of recommended books? I would like to educate myself a bit on the subject
There were several recommendations recently in the History thread that might be useful.Do you have a list of recommended books? I would like to educate myself a bit on the subject
One thing to understand is how the media is biased towards sensationalism and only viewing things on edited TV news distorts reality. The reality is hundreds of thousands/millions around the world are peacefully protesting but if you look at unedited footage, well that's a bit boring. If you only watch the edited nightly news you are getting a very skewed impression of what's happening. 50,000 people are peacefully protesting but 50-100 of them start breaking a few windows what do you think the sensationalist media is going to show? 45 minutes of airtime from looting that makes up a minuscule fraction of the overall protest. The only people I see questioning the "legitimacy of the protests" are heavily biased, to begin with. A few looters among millions of protesters does absolutely nothing to de-legitimize the protests, although of course, that's what the neo-fascists want people to think.All racism is wrong. Let me get out of the way right away. To protest around the world to show support that poor mans family and to show every racist that its not acceptable is also a good thing.
To vandalise and riot, to attack police is also not on. Some of the things we are seeing on tv are without doubt damaging the legitimacy of the protests.
I dont know enough about the guy whose statue was torn down but if he was a slave trader then he was an arsehole by all our standards. Does that give a mob any right to tear it down without due discussion? Absolutely not. What kind of message does this send out? Any time we disagree with something we just do as we please because we are morally in the right? Ive seen police being assaulted on tv, by thugs protesting about police brutality. How fecked up is that?
@PepsiCola do you think these protesters are going about things in the right way, and is the way they are behaving justified?
Yeah you wont see Sky News The Sun posting about these sort of thingsOne thing to understand is how the media is biased towards sensationalism and only viewing things on edited TV news distorts reality. The reality is hundreds of thousands/millions around the world are peacefully protesting but if you look at unedited footage, well that's a bit boring. If you only watch the edited nightly news you are getting a very skewed impression of what's happening. 50,000 people are peacefully protesting but 50-100 of them start breaking a few windows what do you think the sensationalist media is going to show? 45 minutes of airtime from looting that makes up a minuscule fraction of the overall protest. The only people I see questioning the "legitimacy of the protests" are heavily biased, to begin with. A few looters among millions of protesters does absolutely nothing to de-legitimize the protests, although of course, that's what the neo-fascists want people to think.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
There were several recommendations recently in the History thread that might be useful.
Thank you! I will take a lookhttps://www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.com/books-white-privilege-novels-racism-antiracism-black-scholars-2020-6?amp
Here's a list of good books on the subject to read.
What the absolute feck is this?They are arguably as heinous as Hitler's
Most of these protests are organized by folks who’ve been doing this decades. The insinuation that they don’t care about covid or public health is so willfully ignorant. Especially when you know that doctors are at the front of this movement supporting the cause. Instead of acknowledging they know what they’re doing, we see reactionary BS that does nothing to help the cause.One thing to understand is how the media is biased towards sensationalism and only viewing things on edited TV news distorts reality. The reality is hundreds of thousands/millions around the world are peacefully protesting but if you look at unedited footage, well that's a bit boring. If you only watch the edited nightly news you are getting a very skewed impression of what's happening. 50,000 people are peacefully protesting but 50-100 of them start breaking a few windows what do you think the sensationalist media is going to show? 45 minutes of airtime from looting that makes up a minuscule fraction of the overall protest. The only people I see questioning the "legitimacy of the protests" are heavily biased, to begin with. A few looters among millions of protesters does absolutely nothing to de-legitimize the protests, although of course, that's what the neo-fascists want people to think.
Another thing to understand is that there is some legitimate document evidence that it was police/right-wing nutjobs that started breaking windows to make the protesters look bad. For every video of a looter, there is also a video of militarized police going way beyond legitimate use of force.
Well said mate.Most of these protests are organized by folks who’ve been doing this decades. The insinuation that they don’t care about covid or public health is so willfully ignorant. Especially when you know that doctors are at the front of this movement supporting the cause. Instead of acknowledging they know what they’re doing, we see reactionary BS that does nothing to help the cause.
Eh? They know what they're doing?Most of these protests are organized by folks who’ve been doing this decades. The insinuation that they don’t care about covid or public health is so willfully ignorant. Especially when you know that doctors are at the front of this movement supporting the cause. Instead of acknowledging they know what they’re doing, we see reactionary BS that does nothing to help the cause.