Txiki was key to City getting Pep, so I don't think it's a matter of luck. It's the sort of long term plan the Glazers would never dream of
Absolutely, Txiki was key for Man City to bring in Guardiola. And that was due to City being a low profile club. United sells itself. And I wouldn't say their thinking was long-term but rather tunnel visioned in the quest to bring in Guardiola. Because a lot of Txiki's signings prior to Guardiola's arrival didn't fit into Guardiola's methods.
Below is a article from James Ducker dated December, 2016. And Ducker calls out Txiki for his poor work in the transfer market and goes on to say that, Txiki wouldn't have lasted in his role, if it wasn't for bringing in Guardiola.
James Ducker: "They are making an unfortunate and costly habit of it. Picture the kid playing hook-a-duck at the fairground who keeps going back to his exasperated dad to ask for more money in the hope of finally landing the prize he craves and that gives you some idea of the game Txiki Begiristain, City’s director of football, has been playing with Sheikh Mansour’s cheque book."
Begiristain is a curious case. He flies almost entirely under the radar and yet it is hard to escape the feeling that, but for a close friendship with Pep Guardiola that enabled him to deliver on his promise of luring the world’s most revered manager to east Manchester, he might have struggled to hold on to his job for so long.
"His strike rate in the transfer market would, in cricketing terms, be enough to make any bowler shudder although there seems to be a particular blind spot when it comes to committing significant funds to sign defenders, a failing that pre-dates his arrival at City more than four years ago."
"Any Barcelona supporter who witnessed the succession of expensive defensive flops that came and went at the Nou Camp over the seven years Begiristain was sporting director is unlikely to register much surprise at the pattern unfolding at City."
"For Eliaquim Mangala, a £42 million recruit from Porto in 2014 since shipped out on loan to a Valencia side toiling near the foot of the La Liga table, read Dmytro Chygrynskiy at Barcelona. The Ukrainian centre-half cost £22 million from Shakhtar Donetsk in 2009 but made just 14 appearances before being sold at a £9 million loss 12 months later."
"Or for Nicolas Otamendi, signed for £32 million from Valencia last year but whose very name evoke images of Rio Ferdinand imploring the Argentinian via Twitter to “stay on his feet” after another brainless lunge, think Martin Caceres. Begiristain had Barcelona pay £15 million to bring him in from Villarreal. He managed only 13 games, spent the next year two years on loan and was jettisoned for just £2.5 million."
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/footbal...egiristain-man-citys-habit-signing-expensive/
https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...man-city-txiki-begiristain-transfers-22778739
They only became a well run club since Guardiola joined.