johnmufc
New Member
- Joined
- May 10, 2009
- Messages
- 4,521
For me, he's surpassed Evra as our best fullback. Evra has had a very poor 2010.
Ridiculous.For me, he's surpassed Evra as our best fullback. Evra has had a very poor 2010.
Comparatively poor is I think what he means. He did look a bit down at times last season.Ridiculous.
His second yellow was a bit soft. His first one though was stupid and unnecessary.I still don't blame him for the Bayern thing. The referee was absolutely fecking shocking in that game.
Correct.I still don't blame him for the Bayern thing. The referee was absolutely fecking shocking in that game.
That goes without saying.True, but if he wasn't up for it, then we'd be seeing O'Shea every week and United would be shopping for a fullback.
Evra's lapse of concentration allowed Olic to score the winner for Bayern in the first leg.He suggested Rafael is now our best full back, which is an over statement to say the least.
Evra hasn't been exceptional this season, he's been very consistently good for a long period since he's been at the club. A great asset and one of the best in his position.
Rafael is still young but showing promising signs. He made a few major mistakes which cost us last season, most noticeably getting sent off against Bayern. I have no doubt he'll turn into a great player, but by no means is he better than Evra.
His first one was pure frustration at a shite referee who should have blown up for the foul on him. It was daft and pointless of him to retaliate but with a better ref it would never have happened in the first place.His second yellow was a bit soft. His first one though was stupid and unnecessary.
For me, he's surpassed Evra as our best fullback. Evra has had a very poor 2010.
Evra's lapse of concentration allowed Olic to score the winner for Bayern in the first leg.
His defensive play has been alarmingly bad compared to what it was in 2008 and 2009./QUOTE]
You've picked out one of the very rare lapses we've seen from Evra there. To describe his defensive play as "alarmingly bad" is ludicrous for me. The guy is still an absolutely outstanding player.
Back on topic re Rafael though, yes he was terrific tonight. He's made unbelievable progress in his defensive appreciation over the last 12 months.
I don't blame him because two goals we conceded were because of very poor intelligence showed by the players on the pitch.I still don't blame him for the Bayern thing. The referee was absolutely fecking shocking in that game.
he's very good but... what?For me, he's surpassed Evra as our best fullback. Evra has had a very poor 2010.
There were quite a couple of RB's who have kept Bale quiet or you can say Bale just didn't perform well...Quality player. Only RB i've watched this year who could keep Bale quiet.
The #1 RB is now his to lose.
To be fair someone on this forum implied Smalling was better than Rio.Ridiculous.
He's the only one who didn't think Anderson played great against Valencia. A bit of a spazzer basically.johnmufc, you must be high on something...
Better this way than having to play the old guard all the time because there is no young player to take overWith every passing game that Rafael excels in, Gary Neville gets closer and closer to retirement sadly.