I don’t think that’s proof he wasn’t positionally suspect. He had the pace and stamina to recover, and he was just a lot better going forward imo. He was a very good defender, no question about it. Was he one of the best in the world? Not imo, and not nearly as good as Irwin. That’s not a slight on Evra by the way, more a homage to Irwin.Evra was only suspect defensively towards the end. He was a beast defensively in his prime.