Not his fault for the loss but I think the problem is, a lot of the goals we concede we are not thinking ‘yeah, nothing he could have done to prevent that’. Many of the goals he lets in are always on the edge of being questionable.
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 47
- Clean sheets
- 12
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 6
Think this is pretty accurate. First goal I don't fault at all. Second one there's just something about it where you watch and can't quite pin it down but something just looks wrong with how he tries to save it
Reminds me of what Southall would look like at 45 with a leg in plaster.
I'm used to players coming here and fading quickly but Onana seems pre-prepared coming to OT, like he put on the weight, had a summer bender and now finds it difficult to move.
We're facing too many shots and half of it is not his fault but ever since he arrived I sense little application.
I'm used to players coming here and fading quickly but Onana seems pre-prepared coming to OT, like he put on the weight, had a summer bender and now finds it difficult to move.
We're facing too many shots and half of it is not his fault but ever since he arrived I sense little application.
Technique, handling and footwork.
Good lord the Dutch system is so crap, it's so overhyped and arrogant. Any manager that comes here gets found out so quicky.
All this crap about angles and positions is all footballing homeopathy, sounds good, on paper is good but in reality it's crao. They can't set teams up, they struggle if another team actually tries against them, they can't motivate players, and they focus so much on their own hot air about how football should be played that they end up creating nothing.
A keeper like Onana should be playing for Utrecht. He's wonderfully under par.
He's been utterly shambolic. How the feck has Altay Bayindir not started a game yet for us? How many more shite performances can Onana get away with? Fecking ridiculous. Maybe Ten Hag wants the sack.
It’s not easy to defend “good keeper only bad defense” if we concede 3 goals out of 4 shots on target (could’ve been 4 goals, he deflected badly for the disallowed goal too)
For the 2nd he jumps up and almost backwards rather than towards where he can intercept the ball. His feet are rooted and he just dives rather than taking a step to get his motion going in that direction and as a result he doesn't get far enough across in time.
His performances are comedic at this point. Would’ve looked even worse for him if that 4th goal had have counted.
How did this guy get to the Champions League Final last season? Has he been kidnapped and replaced by a body double?
I’m critical, but hard to blame him today?
I haven't seen today's goals but this is a good summary of how I feel about it. We conceed plenty of goals where it's not obviously his fault, yet you're left feeling like something wasn't right somehow.
Carried by the Inter defensive vs easiest ever route...
he will let plenty of goals in that De Gea or any other better keeper would save without ever being at fault for anything except not being a miracle worker. it's up to fans to decide whether the rest of his game is worth having such keeper.
Inter defended like bastards. Check through the CL stats on Uefa.
Before we signed Onana people brought up the stats that while De Gea was at the lower end, Onana was worse. So what we're seeing is coming to fruition, a keeper worse at saving shots and no protection.
Yeah. The second goal it’s almost like the force/velocity he uses for the dive doesn’t match the shot if that makes sense. Best analogy I can give is someone trying to throw a haymaker punch and completely missing
I already wrote this few pages ago.
He looks unfit for GK.
He looks unfit for GK.
Agree. A goalkeeper stopping that second goal would be praised for making a very good save at a strong header from very close to him. I dont think it is a blunder but it would be nice to have a goalkeeper who makes a very good save a bit more often.
Today is not the day to criticise Onana, plenty of other times where it's worthy, but not today.
Was anyone else baffled how the second goal went in. I was watching it live and it seemed to be a header you never see hit the back of the net. Even the replay it's like he has no reflexes. He's genuinely not a natural goalkeeper his technique is all over the place. I think if the team magically become more solid he will look more solid but he will never be an excellent keeper. Why in God's name did we buy him. His limitations are absolutely blatant.
His arms seem to get shorter the more he stretches for a save. Like Weghorst last season used to get smaller as he jumped for a header.
They beat nobody to get to the final. All the decent teams were on the other side of the draw. If they got Real,Bayern,city etc in the earlier rounds they would have been stuffed.
Would be harsh to blame today's result on him, but he did nothing out of the ordinary to help us.
He won’t. He’s just not a great shot stopper.
Even the 1st disallowed goal, he parried the first header straight back into the danger area. He has no control over his saves, if he saves them
ETH must believe that Biyinder is even worse than Onana not to get a game. That takes some doing by our recruitment department but not a surprise!
We have for a long many years been a leaky and error prone team at back. Members on this forum need to reevaluate the value of a cat like shotstopper. Bringing in Onana before we are 'fixed' was gross mismanagement on all parties involved. It's wishful thinking unhinged from reality. He is what he is, not his fault really. He is the worst fit for us.
What an average player. I'm amazed there are still people defending this guy.
Martinez is an awesome goalkeeper.
We paid a premium for Onana, but he doesn’t do more to justify the price. We are awful in transfer business.
We paid a premium for Onana, but he doesn’t do more to justify the price. We are awful in transfer business.
Horrific. I thought he'd be really good for us. I was wrong. There's quite a few this season that our Sunday league keeper would have saved, and he's rubbish.
He needs to be dropped.
He needs to be dropped.
People saying « it’s hard blaming it on him » but what use is a goalkeeper if he doesn’t make the difference between a 1-0 loss at the 60th minute while you‘re clearly dominating and a 3-0 loss because the team got lost chasing a goal after being down to 2-0?
That’s my biggest grief against him. You can say players capitulate but the keeper helps them very little in weathering the storms. And today the storm was just 2 shots on target in 60minutes.
The same scenario has been played a lot already this season. He basically lets in cheap shots when the team at the worst possible moments
He basically doesn’t help keep the team afloat when the team needs him to stay afloat.
That’s my biggest grief against him. You can say players capitulate but the keeper helps them very little in weathering the storms. And today the storm was just 2 shots on target in 60minutes.
The same scenario has been played a lot already this season. He basically lets in cheap shots when the team at the worst possible moments
He basically doesn’t help keep the team afloat when the team needs him to stay afloat.
TBF, City’s keeper is not a very good shot stopper. So if we limit opposition chances and Onana does the creative ball playing keeper stuff I can see it working. But realistically we’re not going to become as dominant as City any time soon.
I had hopes he would integrate into the team and we'd unleash a new creative style of play. I was wrong. Even Barthez was a better keeper, in hindsight.
I'm convinced he'll wind up being investigated for match fixing.
He's awful. John O'Shea is a better goalkeeper!
He's awful. John O'Shea is a better goalkeeper!
We need a new keeper.
He was crap, needed to be replaced and giving him a new contract would have been beyond stupid. Get over it.
Recent performances have resurrected @iKeano
Finally saw the highlights. Anyone who blames Onana for any of the goals today hasn’t got a fecking clue.
Onana can’t even dream of ever reaching De Gea’s level. But what’s done is done and we must live with the shambolic management of the club.
He was crap, needed to be replaced and giving him a new contract would have been beyond stupid. Get over it.
One billion quid shoveled straight into the furnace.
No one has said that Onana is near De Gea at his peak. But he was dreadful last season and needed to go, the fact he still hasn’t got a club speaks volumes.