Cal?
CR7 fan
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2002
- Messages
- 34,977
It's an award for the calendar year.Everyone keeps saying Lewandowski had it won, but what about Salah...? Won the previous CL, won the PL - surely would've been in with a shout.
It's an award for the calendar year.Everyone keeps saying Lewandowski had it won, but what about Salah...? Won the previous CL, won the PL - surely would've been in with a shout.
Sorry, yeah. But still think a Salah or VVD could've been in contention.It's an award for the calendar year.
Last year was their chance with the CL winning season, more often than not the star player of the CL winning side win this.Sorry, yeah. But still think a Salah or VVD could've been in contention.
Overrated?Why?
He is so overrated.
Just watch him bottle it in the champions next round.
Not too shabby, 217 goals in 5 seasons. Numbers aren't everything but I think there's a point where you just can't argue with them. Some legitimately good strikers score around that in their career. Les Ferdinand (215), Nicolas Anelka (210), Dwight Yorke (198), Michael Owen (222) etc. Alright, the ones I mentioned were playing in a different country but still.Overrated?
Let's look at his goalscoring stats in past couple of years:
15-16: 42 goals
16-17: 43 goals
17-18: 41 goals
18-19: 40 goals
19-20: 51 goals (including 11 goals in CL)
I would say he is underrrated.
Salah isnt even the best attacker in Liverpool, Mane should be mentioned first.Everyone keeps saying Lewandowski had it won, but what about Salah...? Won the previous CL, won the PL - surely would've been in with a shout.
Overrated?
Let's look at his goalscoring stats in past couple of years:
15-16: 42 goals
16-17: 43 goals
17-18: 41 goals
18-19: 40 goals
19-20: 51 goals (including 11 goals in CL)
I would say he is underrrated.
You may also argue Messi is bottler in CL recent years and in all international tournaments, does that make him overrated though?For the highest level, he doesn't cut it. He is a bottler. Bayern would have won the champions league with a better striker for sure in the last 5 years, just like they did with the lesser player, but way more clinical, Mandzukic. (defeating Lewandoski in the final, ironically)
He bottled it season after season in the champions league KO stages.
For the league he is ok. Bayern creates so many chances he is bound to score shitload. Even Lukaku would have a similar record.
Fair enough.You may also argue Messi is bottler in CL recent years and in all international tournaments, does that make him overrated though?
Lewandowski scores 51 goals in 43 games this season, this includes 11 goals in 6 CL games. Just be fair, this is beyond amazing, and even comparable to Messi/Ronaldo peak years.
No one gave a shit for FIFA award, while Ballon D’Or was always the highest honor in football. It is a bit like comparing the Nobel price (given from Swedish parliament) with some price given by UN. Sure, someone might think that the official UN price (or in this case FIFA award) is the more important one, but really it is not the case.I think Fifa best is more important. Balon d’or was never taken as seriously before it merged with FIFA world player of the year. The fact that it’s decided exclusively by a select group of journalists resulted in some strange picks for winners like Owen and Nedved.
Really? I guess the history gives Balon d’or it’s prestige but in the early 2000s me and my mates took the Fifa awards as the standard. Also think it was the case for the media, for eg in 2004 Ronaldinho was given the label of best player in the world rather than Sheva.No one gave a shit for FIFA award, while Ballon D’Or was always the highest honor in football. It is a bit like comparing the Nobel price (given from Swedish parliament) with some price given by UN. Sure, someone might think that the official UN price (or in this case FIFA award) is the more important one, but really it is not the case.
Nobody had it won given the CL often decided it.Everyone keeps saying Lewandowski had it won, but what about Salah...? Won the previous CL, won the PL - surely would've been in with a shout.
FIFA bestI think Fifa best is more important. Balon d’or was never taken as seriously before it merged with FIFA world player of the year. The fact that it’s decided exclusively by a select group of journalists resulted in some strange picks for winners like Owen and Nedved.
No lets go there. I'm not a Ronaldo GOAT guy at all.... but your argument could be quite good if you are going to argue Ramos or Bale being more important to 4 CL Titles than he was... when you are talking actually collective season and not odd games.Lets not go there.
All the players, clubs and agents whose add-on clause will not be getting triggered now.Ah well. Ultimately, who cares
Ronaldo would certainly be in the top 3 at the moment, but the way Juve are playing, I don't think they can go much further in the CLSo, it seems neither Messi nor Ronaldo were even in the top three then? Makes sense to cancel their award if that's the case.