In the 145 years since the formation of Utd., there has been only 3 really successful managers. Mangnall, Busby ( His first period ) and Ferguson, who have won league titles and cups during their years of tenure. I believe that is because they had the ability to harness the strengths of the players they managed and off set their weakness by astute what we now call systems of play.
It would appear that our present manager is one of the many past managers who have not found that balance. The balance of strengths, weaknesses and then introducing a method of play which the players can adopt consistently is missing in this present squad. For example playing Rashford as a ( Former term ) center forward is wrong as he does not have the ability to play in that position which has been proved numerous times.
His coaches must also take responsibility, either they are failing to implement his tactics to the players successfully or they are not informing the manager that
the players are not capable of carrying out his plan. There is also the possibility that he is not taking in the coaches comments.
We also have too many players who are incapable of playing a ball with both feet, now this is a coaching issue, they should be made to focus everyday on becoming proficient with both feet, it is only a matter of practice.
My other point is that our present manager continues to state that injuries and illness has disrupted his team selection and changes had to be made. However, both Busby in his time and Ferguson put in place a system whereby these problems were reduced. They both implemented a coaching system whereby every footballing level at the club played to the same system, so a player from the youth side progressing to the reserves and a player from the reserves could slot into the next level knowing how it would play and it worked.
Sadly until as a club it once again focuses on the restructuring the footballing side of the club and implementing a footballing system/style from the most junior sides to the the senior team we will remain as we have been been for the majority of our history a middle level club with the occasional cup winning season.
I know that a many of you on this forum will disagree with this post, but it is my thoughts and observations having supported this club since 1956.