My thoughts exactly. I think they're just defending their cash cow. If they were guaranteed broadcasting rights for the new league, I suspect they'd change their tune.
Gary Neville - Pundit
- Thread starter Jamie Shawcross
- Start date
Spot on from Gary. 100% agree with all of what he said. I won't step foot inside Old Trafford again if this comes to pass.
Theyre spending to fly up the leagues and increase the value of the club for an eventual sale.
Bit like saying any United fans complaining about the super league are hypocritical given part of the global success of Manchester United is based around the rebranding of the Premier League.
Let's forget about who or what is hypocritical as you can make loose links and just focus on the messaging here. Clearly Neville is quite passionate about this and I don't think he is motivated by a supposed bottom line from a Salford perspective.
How is he a hypocrite? he acknowledged how he has invested and put money into a club but to take away competition by creating a 1 tier system where you can’t be relegated and have other teams unable to enter this “cashcow” competition is bollocks. He’s a football fan at the heart of things, that much is obvious and I would have commented in another thread if it hadn’t been locked but I stand by what I said.
Spot on, especially for a dead guy.
No but to say it’s all about greed is just ignoring the fact it’s always been about money. Why does he think he got paid so much money to kick a ball about? The PL is all about tv rights and making money. Someone has now realised that you could take that money and double it if instead of playing Burnley the top European sides were playing each other. It’s the exact same concept just turned up to 11. I’m against it - I’d prefer it to be done under the CL banner but with positions being earned and the domestic pyramid not undermined - but acting like it’s some great moral outage is just hypocritical. Ask football league clubs what they think of the premier league.
Really? feck me that’s unreal
So you're agreeing with him pretty much.
No. I don’t agree with him saying clubs should be relegated for not toeing the corporate uefa line.
Did he say clubs should be relegated? I thought he said deduct points? Think both are too much so I wouldn't agree with him on all matters that's for sure.
It is hilarious when you think about it.
Sky going apesh!t at the idea of a big money breakaway league
Love those comments from him. Well spoken.
Spot on. It's a disgusting idea and Gary Neville - and Roy Keane and Micah Richards in the studio - are right. And you don't have to be Jesus in order to criticise a rubbish greedy scam.
There is a difference though, although the EPL was a breakaway of sorts it is still very entwined with the football league and has relegation to the football league and accepts promotion from.It is hilarious when you think about it.
Sky going apesh!t at the idea of a big money breakaway league
The idea of a new European super league being a closed book is shameful and goes against everything football is about Sky are no saints by any stretch, but this is on a whole level of greed and power over everything.
I dont think it will happen and I suspect it's a power move by the clubs and nothing more than a hollow threat.
If this super league goes ahead, will you stop going to OT, when it is allowed again ? Will you stop watching on telly ?
I think that would be the end of it for me.
I think that would be the end of it for me.
Thumbs up emojis ad finitum
Well said!
100 % agree with his analysis.
Neville is the biggest hypocrite going. Joker.
“Chelsea, Man City and others are funded. My point is it was done on the pitch, the Super league would be a closed shop, invitation only access, no hope for clubs like Burnley to play the likes of United and Liverpool, taking away the hope and ambition of fans”
The world badly needs better messengers.
Billionaires with the biggest of carbon footprints lecturing us about global warming. Royals speaking about anything. Now Sky employees telling us greed is corrupting football.
Billionaires with the biggest of carbon footprints lecturing us about global warming. Royals speaking about anything. Now Sky employees telling us greed is corrupting football.
I fecking have a love hate relationship with Nev. He's mostly a twat but surely this would benefit his club?
Well fecking said Gary. Bunch of cnuts -- the lot of them.
Well fecking said Gary. Bunch of cnuts -- the lot of them.
Neville is 100% spot on.
It's unusual for sky presenters to be so bold in their opinions on matters like this. It does stink of them protecting their interests.
So they want to create a super league in which only certain clubs are in. Why does that sound familiar? Oh right, American Football. Where all the clubs are actually franchises and can be moved if a better deal comes up. I cant believe anyone is looking at this and thinking its good for football or its fans. We could end up not being 'Manchester' United anymore. Moving to some other place that gives the owners a better deal or incentives. feck that.
Neville is spot on. Dock points to the five clubs including us.
Just tell anyone club that wants to break away that their titles will be taken off them and awarded to the next best, I for one wouldn't want to watch utd getting beat by Barcelona or Real Madrid every week,
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
You are only pushing it to a head if you do that.
We're kicking you out of the PL.
That's okay we'll leave. Now get people to watch your league without us.
Exactly. He also isn’t talking about the crux of the matter: state funded clubs can spend what they want whilst clubs such as Liverpool/United who would earn hundreds of millions more if they controlled their own media revenue have to share it. They tried dealing with that with project restart which was rejected so now they’ve decided to support the European super league.
Why? Almost all of them will comfortably get work for any channel covering any other breakaway league for probably, more money, since bigger money = more money for all except the fans paying for that.... except oddly, the non ex-footballing presenters who aren't going in too passionately on it.
Not sure i follow you. Are we happier with Neville supporting the idea, thus cementing the money and greed link between evil capitalist media outlet and evil capitalist football bosses? Or is it possible for Nev or Keane or whoever to say something sensible in a Sky Sports studio? Having the discussion is still better than not having the discussion, isn't it? Or can we only have the discussion in a Working men's club in Sheffield.?It is hilarious when you think about it.
Sky going apesh!t at the idea of a big money breakaway league
I dunno about that. If it happens, no doubt Sky will buy the rights. Nev would then have to resign. Its like Turkey's voting for Christmas. If Sky buy the rights I shall just get rid of Sky sports
Good from Gary, however it does seem whenever there's a chance he feels he can gain in popularity he really goes into try hard mode. Saw it in politics as well from him, I'm not saying I don't agree with what he is saying it's just something irks me about the way he goes about it.
Back in 1992, Sky were behind a breakaway league.
In 2021, Sky are suddenly against a breakaway league.
Agree with every word. I will never watch United in a Super League. A sub-system that has promotion and relegation... maybe. But probably not.
39. Old Trafford attending Supporter since I was 8.
39. Old Trafford attending Supporter since I was 8.