I'm not worried we wont challenge for the title.....i'm worried we wont make top 4!

lysglimt

Full Member
Scout
Joined
Jun 1, 2008
Messages
15,450
We have still not lost one player who performed well last season - not one! We have signed 2 central midfielders, a very good right-back, Shaw looks fitter and better than last season - and we have signed a very talented winger/striker.

Add to that - there are 4 weeks left of the transfer window (Pedro looks likely to enter) - and our net spend is very low so there should be tons of Money left.

we will be better than last season
 

KM

I’m afraid I just blue myself
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
49,788
In fairness, we have to look objectively at what is currently happening and, while it might seem negative, the OP isn't too far wrong.

At present, we're in the process of selling Di Maria and we know that De Gea wants out. We're hearing that Pedro might be a target but nothing concrete there so far.

We also know that Van Gaal has spent the entirety of preseason practising this new formation and bedding Blind in as a CB as well as Memphis as a number 10.

It's reasonable then, to assume that our team will be without Di Maria and probably De Gea and that the team we've been practising with will be more or less our first team to start the season. A team with Jones over Smalling, Mata as a winger, Memphis as a #10 and Herrera on the bench.

Of course we should be strengthening our team and surely we'll abandon this formation and selection weirdness when it doesn't work, but after how long? And will we make the right signings (or be able to). If not then after Di Maria and DDG leave, we'll be in profit for the summer and potentially unimproved too. It's a worry at the least.
Yes apart from every newspaper in Spain and England, there's been nothing concrete on Pedro. I'm not even sure that AdM is that big of a loss based on what we saw at United. Let's not forget that Ashley fecking Young was twice the player as AdM last season, and our best run of form came when Di Maria was relegated to the bench.
 

BringNaniBack

Leaves a bullshit trail behind him
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,530
In fairness, we have to look objectively at what is currently happening and, while it might seem negative, the OP isn't too far wrong.

At present, we're in the process of selling Di Maria and we know that De Gea wants out. We're hearing that Pedro might be a target but nothing concrete there so far.

We also know that Van Gaal has spent the entirety of preseason practising this new formation and bedding Blind in as a CB as well as Memphis as a number 10.

It's reasonable then, to assume that our team will be without Di Maria and probably De Gea and that the team we've been practising with will be more or less our first team to start the season. A team with Jones over Smalling, Mata as a winger, Memphis as a #10 and Herrera on the bench.

Of course we should be strengthening our team and surely we'll abandon this formation and selection weirdness when it doesn't work, but after how long? And will we make the right signings (or be able to). If not then after Di Maria and DDG leave, we'll be in profit for the summer and potentially unimproved too. It's a worry at the least.
At least there's someone who half agrees, thank you lol.
 

Ish

Lights on for Luke
Joined
Mar 10, 2010
Messages
32,602
Location
Voted the best city in the world
If we fail to make top 4, especially after the money we've spent, LvG will definitely be fired.

Can't see it happening though. Unless Brenton has another "Suarez like" season. :nervous:
 

prath92

Full Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2015
Messages
12,322
Location
India
What ? At this rate we will have a 'will we manage to stay up' thread. LvG took a sub standard Holland team to the SF of a WC. It isn't tougher to get top 4 with this squad even if you don't think he is good, his recent success can prove he wins when it matters
 

NoLogo

Full Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2009
Messages
19,944
Location
I can't remember why I joined this war.
Pre-season is never a real indicator at how a team is going to do during the season imo.

The only thing I'm worried about is that the team can't gel quick enough to get up to a good start and will be out of the title race early on.
 

Ekeke

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
53,515
Location
Hope, We Lose
I think we'll do a bit better than this season, but a legit push to compete for the title is still out of the question unless something bizarre happens and City are awful again or something
 

The Red Thinker

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
4,151
Location
Knowhere
Some of you worry warts are either at the cusp of some pubic hair growth or you're completely off your heads.

Out

RVP = Lost his spark. Age is against him. Was a liability at times last season.

Falcao = Just didn't work for the both of us. He's past it and the injury has made him half the player he was.

Nani = He was inconsistent as inconsistent could be. Hell, he didn't tear up the Portuguese league exexactly. Never a Van Gaal player.

Angel Di Maria = Didn't have the will to stay in the country after that burglary. His wife has been adamant about a move and once a player's family wants out, there's not much you can do.

IN

Bastian fecking Schweinsteiger = Has done and won it all. Even if he doesn't dominate the league, his experience and leadership is huge.

Morgan Schneiderlin = The Prem's best CM last season. Nuff saI'd.

Memphis = Collosal potential. Will play behind the striker looks like. At the start of his career development, he may turn good. Van Gaal has groomed the boy for two years with Netherlands. Let's trust LVG.

Darmian = SOLID. SOLID. SOLID full back. He looks phenomenal and a welcome addition.

As far as I can see... We've made significant improvements and with Do Maria likely to be replaced by Pedro we'll be in great position to move forward.

So stop the mindless pessimism and get behind the team boys.
 

Sunny Jim

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
29,464
Location
Warsaw...that's too far away from Edinburgh...
Some of you worry warts are either at the cusp of some pubic hair growth or you're completely off your heads.

Out

RVP = Lost his spark. Age is against him. Was a liability at times last season.

Falcao = Just didn't work for the both of us. He's past it and the injury has made him half the player he was.

Nani = He was inconsistent as inconsistent could be. Hell, he didn't tear up the Portuguese league exexactly. Never a Van Gaal player.

Angel Di Maria = Didn't have the will to stay in the country after that burglary. His wife has been adamant about a move and once a player's family wants out, there's not much you can do.

IN

Bastian fecking Schweinsteiger = Has done and won it all. Even if he doesn't dominate the league, his experience and leadership is huge.

Morgan Schneiderlin = The Prem's best CM last season. Nuff saI'd.

Memphis = Collosal potential. Will play behind the striker looks like. At the start of his career development, he may turn good. Van Gaal has groomed the boy for two years with Netherlands. Let's trust LVG.

Darmian = SOLID. SOLID. SOLID full back. He looks phenomenal and a welcome addition.

As far as I can see... We've made significant improvements and with Do Maria likely to be replaced by Pedro we'll be in great position to move forward.

So stop the mindless pessimism and get behind the team boys.

Valencia will still play RB ;)
 

Raw

Full Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2013
Messages
25,473
Location
Manchester, UK
Some of you worry warts are either at the cusp of some pubic hair growth or you're completely off your heads.

Out

RVP = Lost his spark. Age is against him. Was a liability at times last season.

Falcao = Just didn't work for the both of us. He's past it and the injury has made him half the player he was.

Nani = He was inconsistent as inconsistent could be. Hell, he didn't tear up the Portuguese league exexactly. Never a Van Gaal player.

Angel Di Maria = Didn't have the will to stay in the country after that burglary. His wife has been adamant about a move and once a player's family wants out, there's not much you can do.

IN

Bastian fecking Schweinsteiger = Has done and won it all. Even if he doesn't dominate the league, his experience and leadership is huge.

Morgan Schneiderlin = The Prem's best CM last season. Nuff saI'd.

Memphis = Collosal potential. Will play behind the striker looks like. At the start of his career development, he may turn good. Van Gaal has groomed the boy for two years with Netherlands. Let's trust LVG.

Darmian = SOLID. SOLID. SOLID full back. He looks phenomenal and a welcome addition.

As far as I can see... We've made significant improvements and with Do Maria likely to be replaced by Pedro we'll be in great position to move forward.

So stop the mindless pessimism and get behind the team boys.
But what about Romero?!
 

Von Mistelroum

Full Member
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
4,190
Yes apart from every newspaper in Spain and England, there's been nothing concrete on Pedro. I'm not even sure that AdM is that big of a loss based on what we saw at United. Let's not forget that Ashley fecking Young was twice the player as AdM last season, and our best run of form came when Di Maria was relegated to the bench.
I agree with you in that he was poor much of last season, but he helped us out a fair bit earlier on and it all counts. Ashley Young has done well but he's not the standard we need I'm afraid and over a season he won't give us enough to compete for the title (and I think he's a top guy). Of course there's been a lot of speculation on Pedro and I'd like him here as I think he has quality and a cool head but even if he arrives, we're not going to compete for top 2 with the current setup.

Edit: I should mention that I am very happy with our signings, it's just that it is happening at the same time as some losses which need addressing. If we look at City or Chelsea they have stronger players in key positions in both attack and defense, to improve we need to keep our world class players and sign more on top.
 

OutOfTowner

JCL Daytripping WUM
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
3,527
Well on the plus side, at least we may fare better in the Isthmian Leagues.

Right?
 

Lawman

Correctly predicted Portugal to win Euro 2016
Joined
Dec 21, 2006
Messages
10,639
Location
Scotland
If we fail to sign a CB, lose DDG and we do sign Cillessen then we 100% won't make top 4. I just hope United are smarter than that.

Ddg stays, worthy CB & Pedro, then we challenge.
Don't understand why you think this. If we lose DDG we will be weakened but we have strengthened massively in other areas and will be more settled up top.
 

dannyrhinos89

OMG socks and sandals lol!
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
14,496
We will finish top 4 but that'll be it, the top 4 will be chelsea, arsenal, city then us.

Having spent near enough to £200 million over the last 2 seasons and not actually being in any better of a position than we are is the more worrying thing. How can we spend so much but still not have a one world class player or the game changing player every top team has. If rooney gers injured our back up is hernandez and wilson. If we lose smalling our back up is blind or rojo. Hardly championship winning quality.

Next season will be exactly the same as last season was for us, we will blow hot and cold again.

we will win matches against the big teams put in a fantastic performance then we will go and lose to west brom and those sort of teams and put in dire perfromances.
 

Ryan7

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
3,213
I fear the same as well, OP. Our defence isn't from good enough and Smalling, Jones and Evans never stay fit. Jones and Blind as a centre back partnership will be atrocious. And we may even still lose De Gea.
 

Pyroblazer

That's a hot jacket, man
Joined
Dec 4, 2013
Messages
3,410
That place is horrible in the last few days, don't know how people can make fun about RAWK or Bluemoon and then post threads like that every minute. We haven't played a single game so far, give it a break. We finished Top4 last year and have improved the most from the PL teams at least on paper. We adressed every weakness bar CB and maybe striker. De Gea is still here and I doubt we will sell him now this window.
Next week we will smash Spurs and everyone will be in celebration mode and will make threads how brilliant van Gaal is and that we will win the treble.
 

RedPnutz

Full Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2009
Messages
1,512
We need a whole slew of positive threads this week to balance the negativity.
 

LawCharltonBest

Enjoys watching fox porn
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
15,747
Location
Salford
Don't understand why you think this. If we lose DDG we will be weakened but we have strengthened massively in other areas and will be more settled up top.
With a defense consisting of two of Jones/Blind/Smalling/Evans/Rojo with Cillessen (who people on here don't seem to realize how terrible he is) we would concede far far too many goals.
 

That'sHernandez

Ominously close to getting banned
Joined
Oct 30, 2010
Messages
24,594
Liverpool.
Liverpool haven't improved to the extent of knocking us from fourth, you might have had a point if we hadn't improved in the midfield. Liverpool have lost their best player and replaced him with an unknown quantity (Fermino) in the Premier League, Sturridge is out until October and Benteke is a beast for maybe 6 games a season. Milner is a worker but he's not a player who will take the game by the scruff of the neck and lead the team to victory. Despite signing Clyne, their defence isn't much better than it was last season. In short, my point remains: No club that finished below us has improved their squad enough to be better than ours and finish above us in the coming season.
 

Hernandez - BFA

The Way to Fly
Joined
Jan 5, 2011
Messages
17,352
To not get into top 4, Spurs or Liverpool would have to overtake us.

No I'm not worried.
 

100

binary bot
Joined
Jul 14, 2010
Messages
11,054
Location
HELLO
The Spurs/Liverpool/City run last season makes me more confident for next season. We went to shit after that but the system will excel over individuals IMO. I've liked our window so far, we've signed midfield dominant players for a midfield dominant system, the only thing I'm worried about is the goalkeeping situation. The complaints that people have about pre-season seem to be the typical complaints aimed at LVG teams, the dominance at OT will negate the problems with creativity.

Don't care much for the sale of Di Maria as he had very little impact on our struggles last season.

We're in a good position to sign the next superstar IMO due to the talent at Madrid, Barca and Bayern, but we've been unlucky that nobody has really come through in the last year or two.
 

WyoManU

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
1,610
Far to early to be saying we can't get top 4. However, I will be honest and say that LVG has not inspired any confidence in me. Transfers have been good, but we still are lacking in a few positions which are well listed in many of threads. DDG was primarily responsible for our top 4 finish last year and he looks certain to be gone. I think our options to replace him are all at least a level below him so that is worrying. Need a top central defense leader as well. I think we still have a fair bit of business in this transfer window so we will see who else comes in. We've just gotta get top players in their best positions. Last season was a bit harder but after this transfer window if Mata is still playing out wide right then it's all on LVG.
 

legball

Full Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2013
Messages
2,889
OP comes across as a typical drama queen. No mention of our GK who is the best in the country or the midfield which has witnessed a significant upgrade, just our CB who won't get into other teams, atleast if you want to go down this route, do it very well. We have a very good team, and a very good manager too, he'll make mistakes, and will do silly things [like other managers] but ultimately, we have a team capable and good enough to be up there.
 

BringNaniBack

Leaves a bullshit trail behind him
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,530
OP comes across as a typical drama queen. No mention of our GK who is the best in the country or the midfield which has witnessed a significant upgrade, just our CB who won't get into other teams, atleast if you want to go down this route, do it very well. We have a very good team, and a very good manager too, he'll make mistakes, and will do silly things [like other managers] but ultimately, we have a team capable and good enough to be up there.
I didn't mention the GK or Midfield because I was pointing out our weaknesses. In these 2 areas we are strong but even so we don't know if we are going to keep DDG, if he goes and we don't sign anyone we are again the weakest out of the top 4 in that position. The the midfield yes it looks good but without Herrera in there it is a lot weaker and that's another problem being created by the manager.
 

royboy16

Full Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
8,204
Location
The moon gave me flowers for funerals to come.
Liverpool haven't improved to the extent of knocking us from fourth, you might have had a point if we hadn't improved in the midfield. Liverpool have lost their best player and replaced him with an unknown quantity (Fermino) in the Premier League, Sturridge is out until October and Benteke is a beast for maybe 6 games a season. Milner is a worker but he's not a player who will take the game by the scruff of the neck and lead the team to victory. Despite signing Clyne, their defence isn't much better than it was last season. In short, my point remains: No club that finished below us has improved their squad enough to be better than ours and finish above us in the coming season.
While we have improved, Liverpool have bought well and have a better team this season than the Liverpool team of last season,they will be challenging for top 4.
They are a threat and shouldn't be underestimated,I think they might surprise a few people this season as some of the the players they have bought have EPL experience and might settle a bit quicker(Hope I'm wrong).
 

BennyBlanco

fixated with Shaw's bum
Joined
Jul 21, 2011
Messages
5,803
I'm not that concerned as it stands, though I think Liverpool will have a slightly better season, what worries me is the possibility -if we sell DDG and start the season with 2 keepers who've not had a preseason for United or played one PL game.
 

finneh

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
7,318
The only reason we'd struggle to get top 4 is because of the sheer upheaval in our squad over the last 13 months, not the actual quality of the squad.

We always underestimate our own players and overestimate our rivals'.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,932
Location
Barrow In Furness
I didn't mention the GK or Midfield because I was pointing out our weaknesses. In these 2 areas we are strong but even so we don't know if we are going to keep DDG, if he goes and we don't sign anyone we are again the weakest out of the top 4 in that position. The the midfield yes it looks good but without Herrera in there it is a lot weaker and that's another problem being created by the manager.

It will look a lot stronger defensively, but weaker attacking wise. Depends what LvG wants. The fact that he hasn't signed a new CB. Maybe it's this seasons 3-5-2? Protect the defence at all costs.
 

legball

Full Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2013
Messages
2,889
I didn't mention the GK or Midfield because I was pointing out our weaknesses. In these 2 areas we are strong but even so we don't know if we are going to keep DDG, if he goes and we don't sign anyone we are again the weakest out of the top 4 in that position. The the midfield yes it looks good but without Herrera in there it is a lot weaker and that's another problem being created by the manager.
That's what am talking about, you can also point at the weak points of our opponents but you chose not to. We might not be good enough to win the league but not making top four? Come on now.