Also this sums up how out of touch football fans are these days.
https://m.dreamteamfc.com/c/england...acho-wasnt-selected-ahead-of-marcus-rashford/
https://m.dreamteamfc.com/c/england...acho-wasnt-selected-ahead-of-marcus-rashford/
Rashford vs Iheanacho
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Januzaj vs Sterling, Anderson vs Fabregas. The list is endless.From what I remember, we've had a Depay v Firmino thread, Welbeck (Man Utd) v Sturridge thread and Falcao v Welbeck (Arsenal) thread.
They really don't end well do they
@BobbyManc uses a good debating tactic, if you can't win the debate attack the legitimacy of the debate itself.
Please point out the bit in my post where I claimed Iheanacho to be better than Rashford. I did not criticise anybody for saying Rashford was better, I criticised someone for saying Rashford was substantially better.
Which is fair, I feel they're at roughly the same level but Rashford has had the opportunity to showcase it more.
Has there been one that we've come out on top?
Did we do a Ronaldo vs. Le Tallec thread?
Wilshere vs Cleve... oh wait.
Not really. He wasn't given 10 games to find his feet. He took his chance and held on to it. He produced in big games and made his exclusion impossible.
Now Mourinho signed one of the best players in the world in his position so Rashford has had only two chances this season for club and country, what does he do, last minute winner against Hull and a hat trick for the U21s.
He is making it happen, period.
I am starting to think you are a closet Bertie or something!
Yep, not sure why two people have decided to bump an old post I made in which I said nothing other than it's silly to say either is substantially better than the other at this stage of their careers. I'd like to think Iheanacho is better but I'd be lying if I said Rashford hasn't impressed me pretty much every time I've seen him.
Iheanacho is very physically developed especially considering he's supposed to be a teenager.
I didnt say you did I just meant a city fan is going to back a city player and likewise for us. Stop taking things personally lad.
He is probably 25.
I agree. He reminds me of Henry in how dangerous he is as goal threat starting on flanks and moving in.
I can remember the last Nigerian great young centre forward Obafemi Martins who burst on to the scene as an 18 year old. From wiki he had a great season apparently 'aged 20' but he quickly went downhill from there.
I think that was over on RAWK and it provided some glorious nuggets for the RAWK goes into meltdown thread a couple of years on!
Well, after all he's a Nigerian.
So who has the better attributes over who?
Finishing:
Movement:
Passing:
Dribbling:
Pace:
Strength:
Aerial ability:
Team work:
Finishing:
Movement:
Passing:
Dribbling:
Pace:
Strength:
Aerial ability:
Team work:
Can't see how this is up for debate to be fair. I would take Rashford any day of the week. He's already shown that he can perform at ALL levels having scored in each debut. He's just better all round for me. I wouldn't be too bothered if Iheanacho was starting for City on Saturday. But whether they admit it or not (and they most likely wouldn't), if Rashford was starting, the City fans would be very concerned.
We also had a Welbeck v Balotelli thread long back when he was playing for City and many opposition fans laughed that the two could even be compared. That one didn't turn out so badFrom what I remember, we've had a Depay v Firmino thread, Welbeck (Man Utd) v Sturridge thread and Falcao v Welbeck (Arsenal) thread.
They really don't end well do they
.That was RAWK
Racist
Well, after all he's a Nigerian.
No city had him on trial when he was very young and let him go because they didn't think he was technically good enough. He subsequently went on to sign for United and has developed into a top player.
To be fair Kelechi won the golden ball at his under 17 world cup. So Rashford"s rise was the true surprise
Both have risen from nowhere this season. Who is currently the better player? Who is more talented? Who will do better in the next couple of seasons?
What do you mean no?
Rashford was the main incident that triggered United, along with Liverpool and Everton, into threatening to boycott any underage match v City.
You're also (rumoured) to be stalking Angel Gomes with promises of all the wealth in the middle east if he jumped ship.
Also the rumour goes about Rashford being turned away for his height. Not lack of technical ability.
Rashford has made the most of his opportunities and I'm glad we have him but there's just something a bit special about Ihenacho, for me he could go on to be a Balon d'Or contender, that's how good I think he can become.
Januzaj won that debate comfortably
I thought it was because he was too small?
It was. They spent the last 3 years tapping him up trying to get him to move over
It's no contest at the minute. Rashford priced Iheanacho out of the market for the time being.
From what I remember, we've had a Depay v Firmino thread, Welbeck (Man Utd) v Sturridge thread and Falcao v Welbeck (Arsenal) thread.
They really don't end well do they
There was the Ronaldo vs Robben thread. That one didn't turn out too bad for us, in the end.
Finishing: Same
Movement: Same
Passing: Iheanacho slightly ahead
Dribbling: Rashford
Pace: Rashford
Strength: Iheanacho
Aerial ability: not sure but Iheanacho is bigger so he must be better
Team work: Rashford
Definitely hold Rashford higher right now but Iheanacho is pretty damn good too. Rashford's a full year younger though which at their age is kind of a big deal.
So, pretty much a tie in terms of attributes then? I think, however, that most would have Ronaldo down on more attributes in a comparison with Messi, yet most would probably argue is better still. RvN wasn't the fastest, the best dribbler, the best this or that, but his ability to be in the right place at the right time and just score any time made him one of the very best.
wtf
Since when being bigger means better in the air ?Both are exceptional talents but I'd take rashford just because he's a United boy, no need to change what ain't broke.
Obsessed with comparisons.
Both are talents, let's watch them develop first.
Both are talents, let's watch them develop first.