Withnail
Full Member
FfsTurns out I haven't seen Con Air then
FfsTurns out I haven't seen Con Air then
Westerns are definitely niche but I was going to use that category to take the load off others. You can have neo-westerns like No Country for Old Men and Hell or High Water, comedy-westerns like City Slickers and drama-westerns like Brokeback MountainAlso, if we're removing musicals then surely westerns should go too? They're both pretty niche genres...
Can replace them with Crime and War.
Exactly. I'll be hard pressed to even think of 5.But musicals are shit
For me, that list makes way more sense.I'll have a think about it and decide once the poll is completed tomorrow. I would rather iron this stuff out now rather than be messing about once we go beyond this round.
I'm thinking:
Round 1 - Action & Adventure
Round 2 - War & Western
Round 3 - Fantasy & Superhero
Round 4 - Crime & Noir
Round 5 - Comedy & Romance
Round 6 - Drama
Round 7 - Horror
Round 8 - Sci Fi
Round 9 - Thriller
Round 10 - Animation
All of mine were going to be animated, which is why I suggested combining them.Exactly. I'll be hard pressed to even think of 5.
I think that's what I will go with it genres wins the poll.For me, that list makes way more sense.
I concur.For me, that list makes way more sense.
I concur.
Musicals can get fecked. Cats would've won anyway.
That works pretty well for me, thanks. I do think western could be in there though. Maybe combined with something. How about Sci-fi? It's a similar kind of relationship as between fantasy and superhero. (And they got a great middle ground in Firefly. Even if that's a series and Serenity won't make any lists.)I'll have a think about it and decide once the poll is completed tomorrow. I would rather iron this stuff out now rather than be messing about once we go beyond this round.
I'm thinking:
Round 1 - Action & Adventure
Round 2 - War & Western
Round 3 - Fantasy & Superhero
Round 4 - Crime & Noir
Round 5 - Comedy & Romance
Round 6 - Drama
Round 7 - Horror
Round 8 - Sci Fi
Round 9 - Thriller
Round 10 - Animation
Nah I think there are a lot more similarities in war and Western? It even rolls off the tongue!That works pretty well for me, thanks. I do think western could be in there though. Maybe combined with something. How about Sci-fi? It's a similar kind of relationship as between fantasy and superhero. (And they got a great middle ground in Firefly. Even if that's a series and Serenity won't make any lists.)
Surely Alien is a bad fit for this round, considering we have separate rounds for Sci-fi and Horror.1. Alien
2. Predator
3. Grouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
4. Gladiator
5. Sin City
Agreed, although Alien could clean house on all vaguely relevant categories if it was up to meSurely Alien is a bad fit for this round, considering we have separate rounds for Sci-fi and Horror.
I genuinely can't remember con air except the fact that I've seen it and it has Nick Cage in it.The lack of Con Air votes is infuriating. Literally the reason I'm in the career path I'm in... Come on people, stop being dickheads.
What else do you need to know?I genuinely can't remember con air except the fact that I've seen it and it has Nick Cage in it.
OH I dont know .I concur.
Musicals can get fecked. Cats would've won anyway.
your 1 is more of a war film for me also your 5
- Apocalypse Now
- Raiders of the Lost Ark
- T2: Judgement Day
- Die Hard
- Saving Pvt Ryan
Is it possible to block a user but only when they post about movies? Asking for a friendOH I dont know .
Grease
The Greatest Showman
Mamma Mia (I am a massive ABBA fan) are all very good
You also have West Side Story, Oliver, Tommy, Singing in the Rain, Cabaret, Oklahoma, Paint Your Waggon.
Could also add Saturday Night Fever at a push.
I agree but there's no category for war film thoughyour 1 is more of a war film for me also your 5
T2 could be also in Sci-Fi.
Forgot about Die Hard
I though they were changing to include War.I agree but there's no category for war film though
They're will be. I will change the categories. It will be in the next round.I agree but there's no category for war film though
with respect tell you friend to Go feck HimselfIs it possible to block a user but only when they post about movies? Asking for a friend
Cheers! Will revise the list then.They're will be. I will change the categories. It will be in the next round.
In fact I'll do the update on an hour or so.
Would Heat be considered action or crime?
My list-
Mad Max
Raid
Raid 2
Dark Knight
Dune
Use your own judgement. As long as you can justify it then it's all good.Would Shichinin no Samurai fall under the 'Western' category or under this category?
It's Nic Cage you jobber.I genuinely can't remember con air except the fact that I've seen it and it has Nick Cage in it.
There are some decent musicals like Greatest Showman, La La Land, Mamma Mia, Grease, Singin' In The Rain etc but I don't think this forum is ready for itOH I dont know .
Grease
The Greatest Showman
Mamma Mia (I am a massive ABBA fan) are all very good
You also have West Side Story, Oliver, Tommy, Singing in the Rain, Cabaret, Oklahoma, Paint Your Waggon.
Could also add Saturday Night Fever at a push.
Ffs Dirty, why group comedy and romance?I can't see Decades beating Genre in the poll at this stage so I have updated the rounds. If you have any issues with the new genre listings, speak up now or shut the feck up.
And yet you remembered Top Gun Maverick? Blooming heck chap!Forgot about Die Hard
Romantic comedies are/were a thingFfs Dirty, why group comedy and romance?
It has been a while since I watched Die Hard and I watched TG Maverick only a few days ago, but yeah you are right.And yet you remembered Top Gun Maverick? Blooming heck chap!
The Wedding Singer is OKRomantic comedies are/were a thing
Nice choice. Was my number 6 pick.Round 1 - Action & Adventure
- Oldboy
- Alien
- Goldfinger
- Mad Max: Fury Road
- Apocalypto
Regrettably, yes.Romantic comedies are/were a thing