Horrendous - this league is too much for him.
Sofyan Amrabat | 2023/24 Performances
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
As we already know, he's unfortunately not the required level, but he at least has a little bit of fight about him and did his share of the scrapping for a creditable result.
Is he?
He is too weak and just feel the league is too quick for him.
Goodbye in January please. Send him back to Italy via RyanAir.
Too slow on the ground and too poor in the air. I thought AWB had the worst timing when challenging aerially, then I saw this guy. He's so bad, sometimes he misses the ball completely.
Terminate the loan please
Dreadful player. Nowhere near the level required
Don't extend that loan or make the future fee. Dreadful
He was so bad today. Gave the ball away countless times. I thought he had turned a corner with the performance against Chelsea but I think that was down to just how bad Chelsea were. Get rid.
57% pass accuracy today .. for the way he plays that's horrific
You were right. He clearly isn't United level and you did warn us. World cup performances did flatter to deceive. The Oleg Salenko of the midfield. You probably right about the Phil Jones comment, I'd go as far as current Phil Jones.
Thought he was poor, but with Casemiro injured or suspended. We need him unless we sign a replacement.
Mainoo is streets ahead of him.
Mainoo is streets ahead of him.
Mainoo / Hannibal / Gore can take his minutes in January plus a few returning midfielders
I actually would say he chases at decent times, it's definitely not headless chicken stuff.
When case is back I'd give all his minutes to gore and Hannibal
This guy is barely Championship level let alone being a PL midfielder. I really think he’d be out of place in teams like Palace or Bournemouth. He has no business in PL.
Didn’t do one single positive thing in 97+ minutes and gave the ball away constantly. Puts the team under unnecessary pressure most of the times. What was the manager thinking when selling Fred for peanuts and loaning Amrabat for a bigger money? He’s definitely a downgrade on Fred.
I hope ten Hag is not stupid or stubborn enough to make this loan permanent. That 10m fee is already a waste of money; dont waste futher 25 m.
Didn’t do one single positive thing in 97+ minutes and gave the ball away constantly. Puts the team under unnecessary pressure most of the times. What was the manager thinking when selling Fred for peanuts and loaning Amrabat for a bigger money? He’s definitely a downgrade on Fred.
I hope ten Hag is not stupid or stubborn enough to make this loan permanent. That 10m fee is already a waste of money; dont waste futher 25 m.
He tries hard but he’s just not good enough. He doesn’t have the physical gifts to make up for his average technical ability. I prefer him in central midfield to McTominay but we need to upgrade.
He keeps trying at least but he’s just not good enough and another midfielder who just isn’t mobile enough.
Phil Neville was a far better midfielder let alone Jones.
The gif about sometimes good sometimes shit applies here. But I'm glad we have him while Cas is injured.
Been a huge disappointment, was so poor again. There must be better options out there if we don’t have anything else in the squad, looks worse than Sabitzer.
This purchase alone means Ineos better clean house immediately upon arrival.
A fecking disgrace.
A fecking disgrace.
Made an absolutely sensational last ditch tackle at one point. I was convinced that was a penalty.
If we do end up signing him, Ten Hag has to go immediately.
It’s also VERY out of character. He’s been consistently getting the highest pass completion % in the team over the last few weeks. 90%+ most games.
Yep. Think he just shat himself out there really. He's typically better than that, easily his worst performance for us, but generally I don't think he's really cut out for this league.
Not for me....
He started terribly but improved. He's not slow but he takes about 15 minutes to get up to speed and then can't stop himself quickly.
Despite not being great individually, he is going to be
crucial to us and is the only midfielder who actually plays normally and does midfieldery things. Other than Mainoo who is still young
Despite not being great individually, he is going to be
crucial to us and is the only midfielder who actually plays normally and does midfieldery things. Other than Mainoo who is still young
I'm hoping it's just the result of not having a pre-season, but he doesn't seem to have the legs to play in the PL. Far too slow and immobile again.
This doesn't matter today. We made zero effort to play through midfield at all
He is, especially on the turn.
I mean in a straight line. He has no agility and no acceleration agreed
It's not his fault he's playing this much.
Tbh, despite the lack of quality, he did what was necessary today. Took up good defensive positions, broke up attacks. Can't fault his effort.
Maybe I'm just shell shocked that we actually lined up with two CMs.
Maybe I'm just shell shocked that we actually lined up with two CMs.
Bless him, I hate to criticise but his limitations are glaringly obvious, and he is playing in the middle of the pitch with nowhere to hide.
I don't know why everyone is being so hard on him. Against a very good team he kept his concentration and was always in position for the full 90 mins +. His and Mainoo's tenacious shielding really helped Evans and Varane keep the clean sheet.
It's true he didn't provide much going forward. But, without him we don't get the draw today.
It's true he didn't provide much going forward. But, without him we don't get the draw today.
Still very inconsistent with the ball but unlike McTominay, you can actually 'praise' (even if it's very faint) his work rate and general mentality.
Not a great performance by any means and just about about okay, all things considered.
Not a great performance by any means and just about about okay, all things considered.
He's a tryer which is commendable but some of that passing today was X rated 
get him the feck out of here. Fiorentina don't even miss him