Did Trump say that
The Mourinho Thread: Should he stay or go? | Sacked
- Thread starter Livewire1974
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
He’s a strange one Mou, he’s had a couple of spells at United where he seems to have ”taken off the handbrake” so to speak, and that’s been apparent again since the story of his imminent sacking broke.
Martial & Pogba now purring, Lukaku dropped and decent enough football. The worry is what happens if we get a few more good results on the bounce and then he returns to type.
Lots of reports that Conte hopes for the United job after Mourinho. Can't wait for him to go ballistic when Woodward leaks that he would have signed Varane for 100 million.
What's with the connection between us and Chelsea all the time, always getting their players and now manager(s)...
What's with the connection between us and Chelsea all the time, always getting their players and now manager(s)...
Please. No Conte.
I think he should stay at least until the end of the season, a director of football must now be brought in and given time to put a plan in place and review which manager and players would be the best way forward. This will take time to be done properly, we need to stop reacting to disasters and follow a plan to put us back to the top, IMO Mourinho staying until the end of the season gives us time to develop that plan.
His first year was good, we finished almost same place at City but the football was horrendous but it was his first season and we all felt we would improve from there.Next season we didn't even mount a title challenge. Since then we've gotten more players and have been getting progressively worse till date while everybody else have kept on improving, some with less resources and new managers. We don't look like we'll be challenging for shit this season either, so yeah he needs to go. Not to mention the constant moaning and digs at players at the club
So apparently the papers are saying a dof won’t be brought in unless Jose agrees with the selection. If true, it’s just more damning evidence that the problem goes beyond the manager.
If we hire Conte I'll attack Woody so hard on here it'll make @CA1 will look like a Woody fanboy
Never heard of Johan Cruyft so pass on that one.
You don’t look for the next Gill/SaF you just work out a way to adequately replace them, which we haven’t done so far and in all likelihood it will probably involve recruiting additional staff and having some form of plan other than appoint a new manager and expect everything to work out.
We have to run our DOF appointment by the man who we'll very likely be firing soon
. So if Jose doesn't like our selection Manchester fecking United won't hire a dof?! You are really delusional. And you were telling off someone earlier for posting stuff from 'not confirmed' sourcesSky reporting the club and Jose have today been discussing transfer targets for the next 2 windows - with the club willing to back him in the market, allegedly. If true it doesn’t look like he’s going anywhere soon.
Text Speak
you need to take it up with the guy who felt it was worth it to pay him that much
Last edited:
I've addressed this. Conte was no more successful than Jose was during his tenure there so your argument just collapses on itself.
And you expected a title challenge? City spent way more than anyone despite having a better squad than most the league to begin with. They were always going to run away with it.
As for how we've been since, its fecking October so chill out. We've had Fred as a first team joiner whilst City, Chelsea and Liverpool have introduced more.
We should blame Woody for giving Jose good wages now? Soon you lot will suggest we fire Woody for hiring Jose and keep Jose
Yes, we finished in almost similar places in his first season, bought similar number of players so yes I expected a challenge. So did everyone else till we collapsed and the excuses started coming out
Yeah if you think a couple of tin cups and zero challenges for major trophies while playing shite football is good enough for a club like United, sure.
"Got us back on the map", please. We were a laughing stock then and we're a laughing stock now.
People saying the football was horrendous during the first season?
We played some great stuff at times with Zlatan up front. The problem was we couldn't finish our chances.
I remember a fair few games in 16/17 where we reigned on opponents goals at OT like we've not done since Fergie.
Zlatan made a massive difference for me, his finishing was actually average but the way he would conduct the front line by actually controlling the ball and getting others into play.
The Europa League we went more conservative but it was a means to end which ended successfully.
We played some great stuff at times with Zlatan up front. The problem was we couldn't finish our chances.
I remember a fair few games in 16/17 where we reigned on opponents goals at OT like we've not done since Fergie.
Zlatan made a massive difference for me, his finishing was actually average but the way he would conduct the front line by actually controlling the ball and getting others into play.
The Europa League we went more conservative but it was a means to end which ended successfully.
if you feel jose is overpaid then the fault lies with the guy who decided to overpay. Afterall the implication is that we could have either got same quality quality at lower price or better manager for same price
He wasn't talking about Jose being overpaid was he?
Conte and Mourinho are not who I want managing this club. So I don’t get where my arguement collapses.
Our games against Celta Vigo was one of the worst football matches I've ever seen. The final was brutal too. But yeah we had some good games too
Pep came in with a world class striker, and world class midfielders to his disposal. Jose walked in with no striker, no proper midfield, daely blind at centre back. Sure enough they made a similar number of transfers but there was a gulf in quality between the personelle at the two clubs already existing.
Then don't try and demean Jose at Chelsea by pointing to Conte's Chelsea career afterwards. It collapses because Conte failed at pretty much the exact point Jose did in their relative careers with the club.
We finished what, 7th, 4th and 5th before he came. He won the Europa Cup to get us back in the Champions league before bringing us to 2nd with the best points tally since SAF and the best goal difference since him too. Yeah, that's pretty much back on the fecking map. I know you might hate him, but it's undeniable that under him we became relevant again.
Away leg was a well played 1-0. Second leg yeah we let them onto us far too much especially considering we got an early goal. But they were do or die games for us at the time, it wasn't just a trophy, it was for CL football. Our players were very nervy. The final was well executed, simple as that.
I come back to it time and time again but people on here overestimate our players both in their mental and techincal qualities. I think a lot of the time we say they didn't work hard or try etc is usually because they're anxious. If we do get a new manager, his first call would be to try and resolve that. Our players have been a nervous wreck since Fergie left, it has transferred to the supporters and now it's almost expected that things will be made difficult. The expectancy vs the quality of the player at our club is not even in my very honest opinion.
if the players are not performing
and my initial response which he quoted was for someone who seemed to think we are
The narrative of last season being shit is just bizarre. We've not even been close to 2nd in the 4 seasons previous. The media got to our fans. Liverpool will have an identical season this year in my opinion because they can't keep up with the ridiculous City pace just like we couldn't. Lets see the reaction they get.
A gulf in quality which was not that evident in Peps first season? Plus we've still given Jose the resources to bridge that gap in quality, spending record fees on a striker and midfielder. Pep bought Ederson, Silva, Mendy, Walker, Danilo in his second season, Mendy and Danilo barely featuring in their season . We got Lukaku, Matic, Lindelof and later Sanchez. One team has gone on to win the EPL with record points total while one is still playing hoofball to Fellaini. Other teams who finished below us are now competing with City despite this 'gulf in quality' while we are looking worse off
They're not. We were where they are last season.
City will finish miles ahead in front of all of them.
Yeah, because we were managed by a clueless clown and a past-it lunatic, they hardly set the standards high.
Zero title challenges and went out with a whimper against Sevilla in the CL. And we're all but out of the title race this season and could easily get eliminated from the CL in the group stage as well. And to top it off we play shite football. Not nearly good enough for Manchester United.
It's very deniable. I know you might love him, but we aren't any more relevant than we've been at any point since SAF retired.
And if they don't? Cos Liverpool are looking very good for the title imo
We'll see.
Bottom line is progress. Last season could certainly be spun as progress. This season, not so much. He lives or dies by that narrative. If we're going backwards, he'll be gone.
Again, you're putting the entirety of transfer blame on Jose when there is an evidently shit scouting set up and lack of DoF at the club, but even noting your point, Pep was able to spunk £50m a pop on each of his defenders. His goalkeeper was more than Lindelof/Bailey IIRC. The level that Pep can afford to spend is far more than what Jose has, which is clear as day. Do you really think if Jose had City's resources he'd go in for Lindelof? Get out.
As for the bit in bold, as CA1 has already mentioned, City will likely run away with it again. It's fecking October, stop acting like you know who is and isn't in the title race because its far too early for that yet. The only side that's tipped to win the title ahead of City spent more than us anyway.
I didn't ask why we finished there did I? The fact is, we did. We were pretty much lost side outside of Champions League and a terribly disjointed squad. Ageing, no striker, no proper defense and resting all hopes on a 20year old Frenchman and an 18 year old academy kid. Jose made some changes and took us back on the map, whether you like it or not.
Again, I don't really give a shit about Sevilla anymore. It was terrible and Jose is responsible, but it's 180 mins that doesn't outdo his managerial pedigree. This is another season and there's a lot yet to salvage so I'd rather back the manager and the team than act like a spoilt brat wanting change for the sake of change.
And it is still quite early in the third. BUT. There are so many people who have absolutely made up their minds that Jose is 'not good enough' that I don't think anything will change their minds.
For some people things are very simple. Sack Jose and everything will be ok. Oh wait. What if the replacement doesn't improve things. Well, sack him as well and everything will be ok won't it.
They're either millennial fans with zero patience in the sport, or they just don't understand the sport.
In before "I bet you wanted to give Moyes more time" comment.
Moyes isn't comparable to Mourinho. Odd post.
Tell that to those who asked me this when i asked some patience with Jose.
- Status