That's always a booking. Refs get into trouble if they don't book players for it. Can't blame the ref really.Booking Mata for that celebrationMarriner is a wanker
The Referee Decisions Thread
- Thread starter VanGaalEra
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
Not all do it. And Marriner was forgetting to book Jenkinson, Ramsey and Elneny it seems. But he wont get into trouble for that obviously
Only took 3 hacks from Ramsey to get booked.
Mariner's been appalling today.
Point gained despite Marriner's best efforts, I would suggest.
Quit blaming the fecking ref every time we drop points. It's pathetic.
You think he did ok today?
This. He had quite a few poor decisions both ways but he didn't cost us the game.
Ramsey needs 3 bookable fouls to get a yellow.
Penalty denied.
Fouls called as dives.
Refs are really out for us. It's getting beyond ridiculous now.
Penalty denied.
Fouls called as dives.
Refs are really out for us. It's getting beyond ridiculous now.
He did fine. A few poor decisions but they're not robots. It's noticeable that when we're in a bad patch threads like these get bumped daily. People want to blame the refs for EVERYTHING, and you're one of the very worst for it.
Anyone have a replay of the Jones header off the corner, where he was appealling for a handball? They didn't show any replay on the broadcast.
Ramsay should have been booked on two different occasions before he actually bothered to do so. Yet Darmian gets booked when an Arsenal player dives.
That's not even mentioning the penalty we should have had like. This is happening all the time this season.
That's not even mentioning the penalty we should have had like. This is happening all the time this season.
Almost everyone is moaning about how us sitting back at 1-0 cost us the game.
Almost everyone is saying the Marriner was fecking garbage today.
Both are right. The two aren't mutual.
Robbed today. Same old Arsenal, always cheating.
Shame Fellaini wasn't there to elbow his smug face. Can't stand the guy and he gets away with everything.
Every fecking game, absolute joke.
Awful refereeing today, shambolic really lacking all kinds of consistency. Disgraceful
He was absolutely shocking, he got a crazy number of things completely wrong and it was being mentioned repeatedly in the match thread when we were winning so the idea that it's only mentioned when we lose is bollocks. I don't blame him for the result, but he was spectacularly bad as his job today.
I rarely complain about the refs but Arsenal got all help they could in this game.
The push on Jones freeing up Giroud for the header needs to be discussed.
Pathetic ref. We would have won if it was a 50-50 ref, no doubt.
The ref was horrendous today. It's our fault we didn't win, but that doesn't negate his incompetence.
Glad someone else spotted this because it seems no one else did
Is there any other sport were referee decisions are as awful and influential?
It is getting a bit silly now. Every fecking match something decisive goes against us.
They should be been walking on eggshells for most of the second half with half of them in the book. Marriner was pitiful.
Utd deserved the three points as arsenal were just dreadful.
Utd definitely getting better under mourinho so that's a positive.
People blaming mariner are taking the easy way out imo. Don't think he did much wrong. A 1-0 lead is always risky to shut up shop against.
Utd definitely getting better under mourinho so that's a positive.
People blaming mariner are taking the easy way out imo. Don't think he did much wrong. A 1-0 lead is always risky to shut up shop against.
Darmian was lucky not to get sent off in the first half. Blaming the ref every time is such a defeatist thing to do. He was poor but he did not decide the game. Stop crying.
I don't remember a game this season where the referee hasn't made a mistake
He made a massive difference. Should have had a penalty, refused to book their players, refusing to give us freekicks where there was no obvious advantage. Horrendous display from him. No one likes to make excuses, but we played very well even though it was clearly 11v12.
I'm lost for words.
All I can say is that if I was this incompetent at my job I'd be fired.
All I can say is that if I was this incompetent at my job I'd be fired.
Sometimes it felt like Arsenal sent one of their men to referee the game. Such biased refereeing
How did Mustafi get away without so much as a yellow card for that Pogba grab? They also got away with a lot of fouls which were called off or simply played on under the advantage rule when there was a clear disadvantage for us.
Apparently bad refereeing can't be discussed unless we win anyway. Or something.
This stupid attitude of defending them regardless of how bad they are in the reason there is no improvement.
What?
We were clearly the better team.
That was terrible refereeing today. Ok, fair enough if he doesn't give the penalty (though it was one obviously). But all the little fouls and yellow cards they didn't get that he would give us. Or non calls. Just a shit game from him
As long we have people out there care more for fecking flow of the game then for right calls,nothing will change. This has nothing to do with todays game but lets be real,them making mistakes isnt biggest issue for me,more like feeling that they are freaking untouchable. All that shit,shady system behind motto "Respect for refs".Put them in front of mic to explain their decisions,their inconsistency and implement video tech. They would melt so fast.
That tackle he did when he was on a yellow could have easily seen him sent off.
- Status