Titanic tourist submersible missing | Sub's debris found - crew "have been lost"
- Thread starter Solius
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Pogue, manDo we know how long it took the sub to reach the ocean floor during its descent ? All I can see is that the whole trip took ~8 hrs..
2 hours I think. And they lost contact an hour 45 in. So they were pretty close to the ocean bed.
I don't know how it works but can't they reduce the oxygen supply to extend its use?
Absolutely loved this. Thanks for posting it.
Just a few hours of the originally reported oxygen left now.
Someone made a tweet that said they had switched to their auxiliary navigation controls, with a picture of donkey konga bongos from the GameCube. Absolutely neutral response from me when I saw that.
That last sentence shows how he views it all. Take risks, rules can be broken.
I keep checking the news for a positive update. Looking very bleak at this stage.
If still alive, their only hope is that the oxygen lasts longer than expected, the ex navy submariner will likely have everybody well drilled on slow breathing techniques.
If still alive, their only hope is that the oxygen lasts longer than expected, the ex navy submariner will likely have everybody well drilled on slow breathing techniques.
I guess he means ‘thin the air mixture’ so there’s less breathable oxygen, but still enough to survive - a bit like at high altitude. I doubt this is possible as from what I’ve seen, the tanks are stowed in a sealed off compartment.
yeah sorry I realised that but deleted my post as I was too lazy to edit it
To be fair I think you were right anyway, I don’t really know what I’m talking about
A bit late to be sliding into his DMs now that he's banned.
Have any of the remote subs been down to the wreck yet to see if they are down there entangled in it? That's probably a likely scenario considering they lost contact when they were virtually at the bottom.
How many of them are at the site?
If they are still deep under the water you would have to think this is now going to be too late to have a successful outcome. By the time they locate them, and then actually bring them to the surface it is probably beyond the point of a successful outcome.
If the are bobbing along on the surface then obviously they have a better chance.
If the are bobbing along on the surface then obviously they have a better chance.
fecking hell, I was already scared to go to the sea because of small fish and sharks (imaginary as they are very very rarely in the Mediterranean) but this just means I will never go the sea again
Yes he's totally "disrupted" himself and others into a Titanium and Carbon Fibre coffin. Maybe he should have concentrated more on practical safety equipment that could save lives rather than listening to motivational podcasts!
I think if they weren't already dead this is done now. 3 hours of oxygen left and they've not even found them yet. Would take longer than that to get them up.
How accurate is the hours of oxygen? Surely stress levels could bring it down somewhat too?
It's been destroyed, no other reason for the complete silence. They died days ago.
Does anyone know if/why something like this wouldn’t work under the sea? Seems insane not to bring one down with them if it might have helped? Maybe the signal wouldn’t transmit well through water and the distances are too big to make it useful?
I'd agreed. Unless they are floating on the surface somewhere undetected then it would seem that even if they could extend their oxygen supplies a few hours, it is too late.
I work in Quality in a research environment and some of the wording from the company I'll be using for training courses in the future (once it isn't as fresh). Their talk of certification slowing down innovation etc, and then the outcome.
From my limited knowledge, it's just really difficult to get any sort of signal to travel underwater, particularly at the depths involved here.
But I'd prefer to start from Pogue's viewpoint and be proved wrong.
Sharks are very common in the Mediterraneanfecking hell, I was already scared to go to the sea because of small fish and sharks (imaginary as they are very very rarely in the Mediterranean) but this just means I will never go the sea again
Those kind of things are very limited or don't work at all under water.
From what Ive seen on the news etc the most effective way of communicating underwater is acoustically.
Alternatively, it can also be increased if they're calm, limit physical activity and engage in breathing exercises etc. There's no real fixed number here really. There could be lesser or more than the officially stated hours. And of course, the morbid but unlikely scenario where they kill some passengers and have increased oxygen supply?!
The wavelength of the signal doesn't travel through water at all well.
Apparently the best way to have handled this was to immediately pile on and hope that eventually someone would dig up enough dirt to justify your behaviour. Go figure.
the banging sounds are actually kinda bad. Implies they didn’t die early on and instead have had a rather horrific ending to their lives.
Aha. So sound travels well through water but radio waves don’t? Could there not be some sort of special audio distress beacon? Seems like it would be a fairly cheap/simple device.
They’re probably sat watching the oxygen meter slowly tick down.
I thought the whataboutery was strong. He says going down 4km into the sea is a risk, but so is driving a car and even getting out of bed. I don't quite see those risks as the same as the one these guys have taken.
There are maritime versions where they will travel upto the surface and then start broadcasting a signal. It obviously will drift on the ocean but can dramatically reduce the area you need to search.
Just saw something very alarming on the BBC website of a previous passenger talking about when they lost comms on a previous mission. He says that they lost comms at 1000 feet down and had made the decision to abort and so dropped their weights / ballast. The comms then returned so they didn't abort and continued on down to the Titanic site.
https://www.bbc.com/news/live/world...93a9e0f2e5745fd8a781a7&pinned_post_type=share
if so that doesn't make any sense at all - the ballast being dropped should put you in a slow ascent and you shouldn't be able to counteract that. Also if you have already jettisoned your ballast what do you do if you THEN have a problem? Every single journey seems to have involved a near miss where the skipper has ridden roughshod over basic safety rules!
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Id guess the expense of oxygen used in the actual act of doing that wouldn't even produce a net gain anyway.
Grim to even think about it in any case.
But the more dangerous ones are very rare.