1) Van Dijk - He’s been the best since Ramos started getting injuries. Pains me to say considering the club he plays for but he is literally world class at everything. Aerial ability, speed, positioning, scoring from corners. He hasn’t lost a step after 10 months out which is freakishly good.
2) Marquinhos - Phenomenal defender. Utterly world class. It says a lot that he’s played for PSG since 2013 and they haven’t once thought about replacing him, and he’s instead progressed to become captain. One of the only players in the PSG team who aren’t bottlers that wilt in big games. Watch his performances in the CL final against Bayern or against City in the semis last season. Best player on the park.
3) Varane - Still delighted that we signed him. 1 clean sheet in his first 6 games is no reflection on him whatsoever. It is a commonly peddled phrase but he is the definition of a Rolls Royce defender. As fast as Van Dijk and plays the game at his pace. He is Champions League Varane, but his best achievement for me isn’t his trophies, it’s the way he filled Ramos’ boots in becoming Madrid’s main defender so easily. A true winner, the type we lack in our dressing room.
4) Dias - His impact since joining City has been absolutely ridiculous. For a defender who albeit highly rated, had never played out of Portugal, I did expect him to turn out a bit like Lindelof. Nice and tidy, but not good enough to win the title. Unfortunately, I was way off with that. World class defender, although I feel Varane is still better than him due to his trophies and calmness compared to Dias’ tendency to be rash.
5) De Ligt - There are far too many lazy opinions on him flying around football at the moment imo, namely that he has flopped. Trust me, this guy has far from flopped. He has carried Juve’s defence after a tough bedding in period, and it says a lot that he starts over one of the Euro-winning Italian legends. He is a bit sluggish at times, but his positioning is excellent to counteract that, and his passing is up there with the best in the world for defenders. A generational defender who will be the best in the world in no time.
Honourable mentions:
6) Ramos - One of the best defenders to ever live but is injured too often these days.
7) Rudiger - Probably top 3, let alone top 5, based on performances in 2021. However, he was very inconsistent before Tuchel and is extremely dirty in his tackling at times. Few more months of top performances and he will be in the top 5 though.