I think it's all a question of balance. Do I think he's finished at this level? Yes, which is unforunate, because relatively, taking into consideration the longevity of Scholes and Giggs, he should still have a few good years in him. However, what I won't forget is the amount of highs and brilliant, determined, hard working performances he's given this club over the last ten years, many of which were responsible and part of our huge success. I think the vitriol he's getting, the focused hatred of the guy is unfair and unwarranted and a sad reflection of the short term memories of fans today in this social media driven society. Sure he should be out of the team and it's frustrating when he plays like shite because it affects the rest of the team so much, but it's not his fault he's selected to play, that is up to the manager.