I agree that Pogba has a beautiful touch....and that he's a joy to watch sometimes....but I don't think he's effective enough to justify the hype.
I can't help but see Veron when I watch him.
It could be argued that Veron was the most 'talented' in the midfield of 2001-2003, despite it including Giggs, Scholes, Keane and Beckham. He could do things with the ball that they couldn't, but ultimately they each contributed more relevant, decisive things in assistance to the team, and that's how I see Pogba now; a misfit.
A midfield base of an energetic ball winner and Matic offer the perfect platform for 3 attaching midfielders behind Lukaku to be destructive. Accommodating Pogba either sabotages those foundations, or sacrifices one of the creative players ahead of them; he's neither consistent enough in his passing or defensive work to justify playing deep, or productive enough to play in the final third.