Manchester City under Pep Guardiola | Pep on City v Liverpool ref: "He likes to be special"

gibers

Full Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
1,065
Location
UK
Ladies and gentlemen, the best league in the world :lol:

16 points clear.

"Pep would never walk the EPL like he did in Germany and spain"

"There are 5 teams that can challenge him"

"The EPl is the most competitive league in history"

"This isn't a one horse league like the farmers league in France and Germany"
 

FootballHQ

Full Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
18,326
Supports
Aston Villa
They were saying on the radio this afternoon it's looking very possible City could win the league in the home game against Man. United?

That game is apparently in early April so does fit as possible with their lead.
 

Shark

@NotShark
Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
26,555
Location
Ireland
Ladies and gentlemen, the best league in the world :lol:

16 points clear.

"Pep would never walk the EPL like he did in Germany and spain"

"There are 5 teams that can challenge him"

"The EPl is the most competitive league in history"

"This isn't a one horse league like the farmers league in France and Germany"
Why couldn't Pep walk the league last season too?
 

Shark

@NotShark
Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
26,555
Location
Ireland
A lot of his ex players say the same thing. The Messi of coaches.
Messi is a genius, Pep is a manager that requires the undisputed best team in the league to perform and win titles.
 
Last edited:

gibers

Full Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
1,065
Location
UK
Messi is a genius, Pep is a manager that requires the best team in the elague to perform and win titles.
Yea, City where the best team when he took over as were Barcelona.

No other coach can get their teams to play and dominate the way he does. Give Mou all the players he wants and he would never reproduce the football we are seeing atm.
 

Shark

@NotShark
Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
26,555
Location
Ireland
Yea, City where the best team when he took over as were Barcelona.

No other coach can get their teams to play and dominate the way he does. Give Mou all the players he wants and he would never reproduce the football we are seeing atm.
And yet he still couldn't win the title last season.


If Jose inherited the team City had last season, he'd have won the title.
 

gibers

Full Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
1,065
Location
UK
And yet he still couldn't win the title last season.


If Jose inherited the team City had last season, he'd have won the title.
Yea, but his team still created the most chances and conceded the 2nd least chances. The platfrm was there.

City finished 4th on goal difference before he joined and Mou took United to 6th from 5th. Mou would hate Citys squad, lol you think he would play Silva and Kdb in the middel? Or you think he would like an attacker like Aguero?

City would have finished 6th as well under Mou.

The only reason why we are second is because DDG has had a ridiculous season. making the second most saves i the leagues and has the best XG for GKs in Europe, should have conceded 13+ more goals.
 

Blue doomer

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
147
Supports
Manchester City
And yet he still couldn't win the title last season.


If Jose inherited the team City had last season, he'd have won the title.
Not with the fullbacks we had he wouldn't. It was a dropped bollock by Pep last season for not addressing it. Aswel as purchasing Bravo.
 

padr81

Full Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
12,015
Supports
Man City
And yet he still couldn't win the title last season.


If Jose inherited the team City had last season, he'd have won the title.
Do you think this because he's doing so well with a £650m team chasing them down or do you think it because he took a team who finished the season before level on points with them, bought the most expensive player in the world and went on to finish 9 points worse off? Curious...
 

GhastlyHun

Full Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2015
Messages
12,897
Location
Bavaria
Supports
Bayern München
Why couldn't Pep walk the league last season too?
I think Ederson replacing Bravo may actually be the largest single contribution. City always look a different league whenever Bravo is between the posts, so much more shaky at the back.
Comparing the xG stat from last season to this season hints at this as well.
 

Vialli_92

Full Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2014
Messages
2,681
Location
Ireland
Supports
Juventus
High praise from Henry

The demands Guardiola has are incredibly high the story about drinking water in training is quite eye opening of the standards he has for his teams
 

adexkola

Doesn't understand sportswashing.
Joined
Mar 17, 2008
Messages
48,625
Location
The CL is a glorified FA Cup set to music
Supports
orderly disembarking on planes
I think Ederson replacing Bravo may actually be the largest single contribution. City always look a different league whenever Bravo is between the posts, so much more shaky at the back.
Comparing the xG stat from last season to this season hints at this as well.
That, along with improving their finishing. City created a ton of chances last season but couldn't convert.

An xG analysis had them winning the league this season.
 

Zlaatan

Parody Account
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,789
Location
Sweden
Yea, but his team still created the most chances and conceded the 2nd least chances. The platfrm was there.

City finished 4th on goal difference before he joined and Mou took United to 6th from 5th. Mou would hate Citys squad, lol you think he would play Silva and Kdb in the middel? Or you think he would like an attacker like Aguero?

City would have finished 6th as well under Mou.

The only reason why we are second is because DDG has had a ridiculous season. making the second most saves i the leagues and has the best XG for GKs in Europe, should have conceded 13+ more goals.
What's your point? That United have a player that makes a big difference as to how many points the team have? Shocking stuff.. If you're going to make that argument you have to apply it to other teams as well because the only reason a lot of teams are where they are is because they have one player that's had a ridiculous season.

Or do you think Tottenham would be in 4th place if they didn't have Kane? Would Liverpool be in 3rd place if they had to play Sturridge instead of Salah?
 

AshRK

Full Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
12,211
Location
Canada
What's your point? That United have a player that makes a big difference as to how many points the team have? Shocking stuff.. If you're going to make that argument you have to apply it to other teams as well because the only reason a lot of teams are where they are is because they have one player that's had a ridiculous season.

Or do you think Tottenham would be in 4th place if they didn't have Kane? Would Liverpool be in 3rd place if they had to play Sturridge instead of Salah?
Exactly. We never hear how poch and klopp are lucky as they have kane and salah respectively. Or how barca are lucky to have messi or how zidane is lucky to have ronaldo bail him out. Its ironic people like us are termed blind Jose supporters when in reality its the other way. they are blind Jose haters.
 

PepG

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2016
Messages
1,202
Supports
Ajax
In an interview with South American TV station Directv Sport, Guardiola said: “I have discovered that Manchester City is a much bigger club that people outside think it is.
It does not have a history behind it at the level of titles – but it does have the desire to become winners. I do not rule out continuing to lead in 10 years. It will depend how I feel and if they want me. It also depends on my family. I am not alone. I cannot live without my family. I will not go somewhere alone.

You cannot run the race so quickly. I used to watch my next opponent’s last three of four matches on tape, but now I do not watch them all. I do less analysis. I have learned that helps the players and I am better with myself for it. I used to think that I had to watch everything because I was worried that something was going to escape me.
If, one day, I don’t have the energy to train every day with a team that loves me, then maybe I will think about international football. But I like planning and working at an extreme level with players – so that we can be very precise.”
 

Member 90887

Guest
Exactly. We never hear how poch and klopp are lucky as they have kane and salah respectively. Or how barca are lucky to have messi or how zidane is lucky to have ronaldo bail him out. Its ironic people like us are termed blind Jose supporters when in reality its the other way. they are blind Jose haters.
I usually stop discussing with people that give that argument. clueless is the word that comes to mind. if that is your argument then you have none.

People have being conditioned to think that Attack is the only way to play football when a fair few of the successful teams of the past privileged defense and solidity first. and it's not like we're not good in attack, we are 3rd best in the league in that departement. but no, Without De gea, we would be in the championship.


Re Pep and this year's premier league:
He may have walked the league this year, the reason is simple for me: when you have spent almost two times what the next team spent, you're bound to do that. you attain the top quickly, quicker than the others, the thing is, you can improve the team to a certain point , no more, when the other teams of the top 6 catch up with their transfers (mainly us and Chelsea, Liverpool to a certain point), the gap will decrease.

This is a freak season, and you can't improve upon it. the only way for them is down or at best, getting the same number of points as this year. they had one loss, it's extremely unlikely that they'll have just one loss next year. add into that the luck they had in some games, too much added times, penalties here and there. the stars aligned for them this year.

We are on course to have more than 80 points (5 wins from the last 8 would do that, and we play teams like Swansea, West brom, watford, Brighton, Bournemouth and WH), that's title challengers form and we haven't been that good, with the team gelling and the necessary improvements next year we will be even stronger.

If we splashed the cash for an LB and RB like Pep did this year, we would be way closer. i don't read that much into the league this year.

They were better, fair enough, they deserve the title, fair enough, but they spent way more than the others to do that, no one can deny it. it's not a bad thing per se, it's up to the other teams to do the same and catch up.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

RedRover

Full Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
8,974
Some blinkered views in here in my opinion.

The dominant manner in which City have dealt with the PL this year is ominous. Putting aside the arguments over what he’s spent, he’s spent it well. They look strong and have depth - more so than any other side in the league for me.

United have improved this year but aren’t the finished article by any stretch. This summer will hopefully see the few remaining pieces of the puzzle fall into place. I think it has to for Jose to have any sustained success here.

City have upped the ante this year. I think they’ll maintain those standards and potentially improve again. It’s up to the chasing pack to do likewise.
 

Bearded One

Full Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2017
Messages
1,245
I usually stop discussing with people that give that argument. clueless is the word that comes to mind. if that is your argument then you have none.

People have being conditioned to think that Attack is the only way to play football when a fair few of the successful teams of the past privileged defense and solidity first. and it's not like we're not good in attack, we are 3rd best in the league in that departement. but no, Without De gea, we would be in the championship.


Re Pep and this year's premier league:
He may have walked the league this year, the reason is simple for me: when you have spent almost two times what the next team spent, you're bound to do that. you attain the top quickly, quicker than the others, the thing is, you can improve the team to a certain point , no more, when the other teams of the top 6 catch up with their transfers (mainly us and Chelsea, Liverpool to a certain point), the gap will decrease.

This is a freak season, and you can't improve upon it. the only way for them is down or at best, getting the same number of points as this year. they had one loss, it's extremely unlikely that they'll have just one loss next year. add into that the luck they had in some games, too much added times, penalties here and there. the stars aligned for them this year.

We are on course to have more than 80 points (5 wins from the last 8 would do that, and we play teams like Swansea, West brom, watford, Brighton, Bournemouth and WH), that's title challengers form and we haven't been that good, with the team gelling and the necessary improvements next year we will be even stronger.

If we splashed the cash for an LB and RB like Pep did this year, we would be way closer. i don't read that much into the league this year.

They were better, fair enough, they deserve the title, fair enough, but they spent way more than the others to do that, no one can deny it. it's not a bad thing per se, it's up to the other teams to do the same and catch up.
I really do think we have to be ruthless in the market come summer to challenge. I'm happy we got Sanchez but I'd like us to add Mahrez and a couple of full backs and SMS (I know I'm very greedy lol). If I'm being honest I think Pep deserves the praise he's getting for the season they are having. He's spent loads but truth is any manager in the world who gets employed by a state run club desperate for success would spend crazy sums too. So I think the spending is not so much a pep thing per se as it is a man city thing.

Their numbers are mind boggling but the most expensive of their buys has not featured for most of the season and their second most expensive signing (Laporte if I'm correct) was bought in January when the league was good as done. That's over 100 million pounds that has not really impacted their position on the table.

Yes the monies spent has helped them no doubt but apart from Walker and Ederson it's being pretty much the same players as last season. When they play they intimidate teams and make them succumb to their style.

I think the gaffer has done very well and a plastic club like them do not deserve him.
 

totaalvoetbal

Full Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2015
Messages
865
Location
Netherlands
Supports
Ajax

Pep Guardiola talks about the need for possession, Width vs Depth, different marking systems and different methods of attacking in Bayern Munchen, FC Barcelona and Manchester City.
 

giorno

boob novice
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
26,852
Supports
Real Madrid
And a substandard keeper
Nah, Bravo's performances were also affected by their poor finishing, along with way too many stupid mistakes in possession leading to big chances for the opposition. Still, if the team can't finish, it will have a huge psychological impact on the defence and vice-versa. City were doing just fine while Bravo was getting shredded by the media, then they forgot how to finish, and suddenly Bravo's supposed inadeguacy was magnified(in truth Bravo wasn't even that bad, most of the goals they conceded weren't his fault, obviously)

You might have noticed Bravo hasn't been a problem at all for them this season
 

marukomu

The Gatekeeper
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
20,649
Location
gusset
Gonna have to change my opinion on this guy. I always thought he only won because he inherited great teams. Sure, he's spent shit loads but he's got them playing great. Interesting to see if he can keep it going for a few seasons. The way Liverpool are improving it may be good if he can.
 

GhastlyHun

Full Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2015
Messages
12,897
Location
Bavaria
Supports
Bayern München
Nah, Bravo's performances were also affected by their poor finishing, along with way too many stupid mistakes in possession leading to big chances for the opposition. Still, if the team can't finish, it will have a huge psychological impact on the defence and vice-versa. City were doing just fine while Bravo was getting shredded by the media, then they forgot how to finish, and suddenly Bravo's supposed inadeguacy was magnified(in truth Bravo wasn't even that bad, most of the goals they conceded weren't his fault, obviously)

You might have noticed Bravo hasn't been a problem at all for them this season
I actually think that replacing Bravo has played a huge role. Ederson does a lot more than just keeping, he is much closer to Manuel Neuer's style of sweeping dangerous balls away before the opponent actually gets to the shot.
Also his distribution from the back is a lot better than Bravo's. With Bravo you often get the impression that he'll always opt for the pass that will bring the most amount of pressure on the intended recipient, while Ederson actually manages to relieve his defense or even start counter attacks.

To be fair he also hasn't been the first goalkeeper anymore this season.
:lol:
 

Charles Miller

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2017
Messages
3,046
He really knows where to spend money tbf. There's no great team in modern football without top fullbacks.

Sometimes his fullbacks will outnumber the adversary in the middle, or the wingers are in the midfield and the full back will provide width..
 

Trizy

New Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2014
Messages
12,009
It seems Pep had a lot of freak seasons so far in his career :) After Matchday 29:


Not hugely impressed by the Bayern. He took over the best team in Europe and won a one-team league.

As for Barcelona, he had that points total with the greatest club squad of all time.

City one is very impressive, regardless of his outrageous spending.
 

amolbhatia50k

Sneaky bum time - Vaccination status: dozed off
Joined
Nov 8, 2002
Messages
95,819
Location
india
Why couldn't Pep walk the league last season too?
Takes a bit of time to adjust to a new league/team and the team/players to adjust to you. And of course it's not easy to 'walk' any top league IMO even if these factors weren't at play.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
57,967
Location
Krakow
Not hugely impressed by the Bayern. He took over the best team in Europe and won a one-team league.

As for Barcelona, he had that points total with the greatest club squad of all time.

City one is very impressive, regardless of his outrageous spending.
That team was never anywhere near the level they were at during Pep days before he came there. I don't know why people keep repeating that he walked into an easy situation at Barca when he really did not.