I'm going to go against the grain and say I don't think the list is as shocking as being made out. Clearly, there's an awful lot of posters in here much older than me but most of those matchups are fair enough to me. I cant believe RDR2 isn't there as it's a genuine masterpiece. My personal number one would have to be Skyrim just for the sheer amount of content in that game and how much I've gone back to it over the years. GOW is a great game and a 9/10 for me so no great complaints, also for the person above saying GOW brought not innovation, I think you have to look at the level of detail, graphics, motion capture and the one camera view and realise it is a very technically impressive game.