Yeah there's always a bit of hyperbole involved. I skipped ps4, so after years of hype around their library i was expecting more. I've probably over corrected a bit because all of them are somewhat flawed and merely good. Which is still good and there aren't that many great single player games around before you wind up playing Skyrim again.Everyone else was harsh on it so I just swerved it. Been enjoying must of their output for the last few years though, and come on, that's not a controversial take...
I think From Software and Nintendo with Zelda have been the real AAA of recent years though. You buy these consoles for the 3rd party library and whichever your friends are on. Gamepass and Microsofts network are generally better and it costs less so i think its at least a competitive choice.