Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,734
It helps when you get kicked out of 50% of competitions before January....
Pretty sure same number competitions as Arsenal and Villa and more than Spurs from end of Jan no?
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,734
The Bundesliga is very possible. Bayern have a bigger budget than everyone else and a better squad than everyone bar Leverkusen. They probably still shade Leverkusen even now. Alonso has turned that squad into winners quickly. A squad of potential 18 months ago.

Bayern selling off most of their squad depth to fund Kane has cost them at times this season.

As for The CL, I highly doubt it.

ten Hag has a poor record in Europe:

17/18 season: Europa League Qualifying Round - 4th round exit

18/19 season: Champions League - Semi-finals

19/20 season: Champions League/Europa League - Round of 32 exit in EL

20/21 season: Champions League/Europa League - Quarter-finals of EL

21/22 season: Champions League - Round of 16 exit

22/23 season: Europa League - Quarter-finals

23/24 season: Champions League - Group stage exit

ten Hag has only made it out of The CL group stage twice. He's only reached a semi-final in Europe just once.
With an Ajax team that had its best players taken every season. That didn’t even get to champions league group stage for many years before he got there. Of course he wasn’t going to get to UCL semi finals every season its not Bayern or City he was managjng
 

Rista

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
2,568
You have to be joking, you can be sure he’d win the CL?
People just can't let that cup run go. A decent achievement from half a decade ago and it's literally 100% of his reputation to this day. During that same time frame plenty of very promising managers and players have become nobodies in football but for Ten Hag it's still as relevant as always.
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,734
People just can't let that cup run go. A decent achievement from half a decade ago and it's literally 100% of his reputation to this day. During that same time frame plenty of very promising managers and players have become nobodies in football but for Ten Hag it's still as relevant as always.
Nothing to do with Ajax having their squad picked apart or him topping the a group of death a few years later. Unlucky to go out in the last 16 to Benfica. I think people watched Ajaxs performances in the UCL under him where they regularly beat bigger teams with class as a reason why he was a highly rated manager before he came here.

1 poor season isn’t going to change that opinion of him for a sane football fan.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
58,219
Location
Krakow
Nothing to do with Ajax having their squad picked apart or him topping the a group of death a few years later. Unlucky to go out in the last 16 to Benfica. I think people watched Ajaxs performances in the UCL under him where they regularly beat bigger teams with class as a reason why he was a highly rated manager before he came here.

1 poor season isn’t going to change that opinion of him for a sane football fan.
When did that happen?

The only group they qualified from since 18-19 was the one with Dortmund, Sporting and Besiktas and I assume you are not calling that a group of death.

They were eliminated from the other two groups they were in which were tougher.

They did not really ‘consistently beat bigger teams’. The only club with bigger resources than them that they beat after 18-19 was Dortmund in the groups and they were hardly a huge team either.
 
Last edited:

DJ_21

Evens winner of 'Odds or Evens 2022/2023'
Joined
Aug 31, 2015
Messages
13,437
Location
Manchester
Arteta's 2nd season was technically the 20/21 season. It was his 1st full season.

While Arsenal did finish 8th again that season, they went from 56 points to 61 points and tightened up defensively (48 goals conceded down to 39 goals conceded)

Arteta has had steady success.

Points:

8th (56 points)
8th (61 points)
5th (69 points)
2nd (84 points)
1st/2nd (83-89 points)

GD:

+8
+16
+13 (slight setback in terms of goals conceded)
+45
+60

In order for ten Hag to avoid having a worse season than 20/21 Arsenal, he needs to take at least 8 points from the final 12 points available. Arteta actually got to the semi-finals of The Europa League that season. ten Hag went out of Europe before Christmas.
But did he have to use 30 different combinations at CB? Did he have over 60 different injury’s in a season? And you can compare there 2nd seasons as being better but the fact is none of there first full seasons was better than ETHs. Last year you could see how Liverpool got affected by just losing VVD and a couple of other players. Why does everyone els get a free pass and can use injuries as an excuse but when it’s us it can’t be used?
 

Chumpsbechumps

Full Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2018
Messages
2,919
I agree.

The club and some fans like to call Manchester United the biggest football club in the world. But we often don't act like it.

The club were quite ruthless with both Moyes and LvG. It's been a circus act since Mourinho's 2nd season concluded.

How a club of this size ended up with Solskjaer as manager for almost 3 years and are now potentially accepting a top 6/7 finish as good enough for another chance, I'll never know.

Our record in Europe is pretty meh for a club of our size. Not enough pressure is placed on managers to deliver on that front. Most fans were happy with the bread and butter (PL title) during Fergie's reign. It's disappointing that for all of his success, we don't have a period of dominance in Europe like Real, Milan, Liverpool, Bayern, Barcelona and even Ajax have had. 3 European Cups and just 5 major European trophies overall. It's the one thing Liverpool have over us. But anyway, I'm getting off topic now. Haha.
Theres actually mitigation reasons why SAF didn’t dominate Europe.

No European football for the first few years set English clubs back so much. When we won the CL in 99, the Serie A was the strongest league comfortably and had the strongest teams. That’s why beating Inter, Juventus was so impresive.

Then Chelsea under Roman , throwing crazy money around , stealing our shopping list got a few sessons. Actually physically obducting one of our signings (Obi Mikel). Then SAF considers retiring which also set us back a season or two.

It prob wasn’t until mid to late 00s when England really started being strong or the strongest. And then the greatest ckub side of all time in Barca stopped us winning two CLs.

I’d also throw in losing ronaldo was painful. Madrid don’t lose top player
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
58,219
Location
Krakow
But did he have to use 30 different combinations at CB? Did he have over 60 different injury’s in a season? And you can compare there 2nd seasons as being better but the fact is none of there first full seasons was better than ETHs. Last year you could see how Liverpool got affected by just losing VVD and a couple of other players. Why does everyone els get a free pass and can use injuries as an excuse but when it’s us it can’t be used?
Exactly, why does Klopp have so much credit in the bank that it’s fine for him to finish on 69 points when Erik who has done so much more for us than Klopp will ever do for any club, and delivered us The Trophy last year, get crucified for this season. People just can’t be grateful and it will be their fault if we now lose this beautiful bald manager.
 

DJ_21

Evens winner of 'Odds or Evens 2022/2023'
Joined
Aug 31, 2015
Messages
13,437
Location
Manchester
Arteta's 2nd season was technically the 20/21 season. It was his 1st full season.

While Arsenal did finish 8th again that season, they went from 56 points to 61 points and tightened up defensively (48 goals conceded down to 39 goals conceded)

Arteta has had steady success.

Points:

8th (56 points)
8th (61 points)
5th (69 points)
2nd (84 points)
1st/2nd (83-89 points)

GD:

+8
+16
+13 (slight setback in terms of goals conceded)
+45
+60

In order for ten Hag to avoid having a worse season than 20/21 Arsenal, he needs to take at least 8 points from the final 12 points available. Arteta actually got to the semi-finals of The Europa League that season. ten Hag went out of Europe before Christmas.
That’s because they started of so poorly. They couldn’t get worse than 8th let’s be honest. We overachieved in ETH first season which is why everyone expected us to come like 2nd or something this year. It was never happening. He’s been here 2 years, got into 3 finals and won 1 cup. I’d say Klopps fall of was worse than ours. They came 2nd in 21/22 and then 5th the year later. Is that not a worse downfall than ours?
 

DJ_21

Evens winner of 'Odds or Evens 2022/2023'
Joined
Aug 31, 2015
Messages
13,437
Location
Manchester
Exactly, why does Klopp have so much credit in the bank that it’s fine for him to finish on 69 points when Erik who has done so much more for us than Klopp will ever do for any club, and delivered us The Trophy last year, get crucified for this season. People just can’t be grateful and it will be their fault if we now lose this beautiful bald manager.
I’m getting the feeling that everything you post is sarcastic :lol:
 

Chumpsbechumps

Full Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2018
Messages
2,919
But did he have to use 30 different combinations at CB? Did he have over 60 different injury’s in a season? And you can compare there 2nd seasons as being better but the fact is none of there first full seasons was better than ETHs. Last year you could see how Liverpool got affected by just losing VVD and a couple of other players. Why does everyone els get a free pass and can use injuries as an excuse but when it’s us it can’t be used?
This is what happens when people have made up their mind and let emotions drive the train. They don’t factor in doubt and as such approach the topic from an absolute position that doesn’t allow discussion, only conflict.

ETH hasn’t been good enough this season. It’s really be a very bad one to be fair so I don’t blame anybody or most fans for having no faith in him. If he’s sacked there can’t be any complaints. I’d be very surprised if he survives to next season TBH.
 

Leftback99

Might have a bedwetting fetish.
Joined
Jan 11, 2015
Messages
14,841
What did you back up? You simply made a statement saying he is not top 6 cbs you backed up absolutely nothing its just your opinion
I said he wouldn't even make best PL 3rd string.

You tried to make out that opinion was nonsense.

Then you agreed he wasn't in the top 3 best LCBs and shifted the goal posts to top 6 CBs. (I'd already named 6 teams that wouldn't swap their LCB for him)

This would at best mean playing him at RCB (a position he never plays) over the likes of Saliba, Stones, Dias and others.

Which opinion looks the most wrong? Me saying he wouldn't make a best PL 3rd XI or you saying he's one of the best 6 CBs in the league (they aren't the same thing).
 

DJ_21

Evens winner of 'Odds or Evens 2022/2023'
Joined
Aug 31, 2015
Messages
13,437
Location
Manchester
This is what happens when people have made up their mind and let emotions drive the train. They don’t factor in doubt and as such approach the topic from an absolute position that doesn’t allow discussion, only conflict.

ETH hasn’t been good enough this season. It’s really be a very bad one to be fair so I don’t blame anybody or most fans for having no faith in him. If he’s sacked there can’t be any complaints. I’d be very surprised if he survives to next season TBH.
I agree. But like you said people have made up their mind and won’t take into account some of the reasons this season as been so bad.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
102,075
Location
Barrow In Furness
Theres actually mitigation reasons why SAF didn’t dominate Europe.

No European football for the first few years set English clubs back so much. When we won the CL in 99, the Serie A was the strongest league comfortably and had the strongest teams. That’s why beating Inter, Juventus was so impresive.

Then Chelsea under Roman , throwing crazy money around , stealing our shopping list got a few sessons. Actually physically obducting one of our signings (Obi Mikel). Then SAF considers retiring which also set us back a season or two.

It prob wasn’t until mid to late 00s when England really started being strong or the strongest. And then the greatest ckub side of all time in Barca stopped us winning two CLs.

I’d also throw in losing ronaldo was painful. Madrid don’t lose top player
You also have to remember that early on in the CL there was a restriction on how many foreign players you could field, which meant at times we couldn't play some of our best players.
 

Chumpsbechumps

Full Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2018
Messages
2,919
I agree. But like you said people have made up their mind and won’t take into account some of the reasons this season as been so bad.
When I’m at a game and hear some of the stuff being screamed at refs, players and/or teams , I don’t think it’s informed wisdom, it’s raw anger/frustration spewing out. Imagine telling one of those lads to “calm down” when they are berating somebody, you’d end up getting it both barrels aswell.

Similar stuff in here , for a lot of people it’s more a place to vent than to discuss and there’s this misguided attack on fellow United fans trying to take a more reasonable stance on the clubs situation.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
7,065
Supports
Hannover 96
Didn't Welsh and Scottish also count as foreign back then?
Yes, as they are independent football associations and have their own national teams. So in football legislation terms they are still foreigners in England, it just doesn't matter as it used to.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,443
Fergie had similar issues when he joined, and had to have a clear out, there was no scouting system, no academy to speak of, the drinking culture, and the poor training, Clayton Blackmore was known as "Sunbed" because he spent more time on Ron Atkinsons sunbed than he did training.
He had to to change all that, I don't believe the myth that Mark Robbins saved his career, I'm more inclined to believe that it was Bobby Charlton and a few other directors being adamant he was the man for the job because they could see the changes he was making.
There is no doubt in my mind ETH is dealing with a culture problem, he's having to cope with players who were bought by different managers
We need a clear out, and we need to see what he can do with a full fit first XI before we show him the door, to my knowledge he hasn't had that in the time he's been here.
By clear out I also mean the injury prone and sulking wage thieves.
All that may or may not be true and/or needed but there's no reason we need to keep one specific manager in place to achieve that.

If, (and for me it's a big if) there's still a culture problem 2 years later and after he's turned over the squad by more than 60% then that's on Ten Hag.

Every manager ever has to work with players bought by their predecessors. That's not a valid reason for his struggles. Even with dealing with all this there's no reason we shouldn't still be seeing progress of some sort or at least the first signs of some sort of effective style of play emerging.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
102,075
Location
Barrow In Furness
All that may or may not be true and/or needed but there's no reason we need to keep one specific manager in place to achieve that.

If, (and for me it's a big if) there's still a culture problem 2 years later and after he's turned over the squad by more than 60% then that's on Ten Hag.

Every manager ever has to work with players bought by their predecessors. That's not a valid reason for his struggles. Even with dealing with all this there's no reason we shouldn't still be seeing progress of some sort or at least the first signs of some sort of effective style of play emerging.
SAF had to deal with a drink culture and got rid of it's biggest culprits. The only one he kept was Bryan Robson as it never seemed to affect him in his game performances. Then it is down to bringing better players in. With this squad it is full of perpetual injuries and players paid way beyond their actual talent.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,443
I swear you'd think Ten Hag was actually Pep with a decade of evidence of dominance in other countries with the amount of trust people are placing in him to come good
Yeah it's either a vast overestimation of his time at Ajax or blind faith.

Fundamentally, there's a reason few people in most industries make decisions and most of the rest have to listen to what they're told. Just look at this forum.

We'd be just out of the Moyes era if some of these 'opinions' were actually followed.
The people who think we should give him to Xmas to "see how he does" would only want to give him until the end of the season anyway no matter how badly we were doing by next December. Some were writing this season off back in November to give Ten Hag time.

I think some just can't ever bring themselves to saying the manager should be sacked.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,443
SAF had to deal with a drink culture and got rid of it's biggest culprits. The only one he kept was Bryan Robson as it never seemed to affect him in his game performances. Then it is down to bringing better players in. With this squad it is full of perpetual injuries and players paid way beyond their actual talent.
To be fair a lot of our injury prone players were signed in the last 2 years.

And Antony I'm sure us being paid way beyond his talent.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
58,219
Location
Krakow
Yeah it's either a vast overestimation of his time at Ajax or blind faith.



The people who think we should give him to Xmas to "see how he does" would only want to give him until the end of the season anyway no matter how badly we were doing by next December. Some were writing this season off back in November to give Ten Hag time.

I think some just can't ever bring themselves to saying the manager should be sacked.
He has basically built his entire reputation with that 2018-19 run. Winning the league with Ajax is good but they are by far the wealthiest club in Netherlands and always expected to be around the top of the table. In CL, it was that 18-19 run and to an extent the 18-point group performance in 21-22 albeit it was a relatively weak group (definitely not a group of death as it had been pitched in this very thread) and it still ended up in the very next round against Benfica. They were decent in Europe but not historically amazing.

Those who are defending him now will definitely find reasons to defend him always. If we are lingering around mid table with same performances as this year and have no shot at top 4 in Dec/Jan next season they will just move on to different excuses because let’s be realistic, they are not backtracking on something they’ve put so much stock in, and besides look at how long it took Ferguson to get us to compete.
 

Nas-JR

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 6, 2014
Messages
107
The latter, while it does appear to be chaos when looking at a match in isolation. We've been the same all season, it's just shit tactics, with players not suited to it and a naive ideology too stubborn to tweak it.

I'd describe our style of play as incorporating parts of all out attack and a low block. But the resulting in the worst of both worlds.
I wholeheartedly believe the intention is not to play with a low block. If it is then that's moronic. I think the biggest problem is the majority of our (available) defense is not suited to and therefore cannot execute a high block. This includes maguire, lindelof, Evans, awb, and current version of varane.
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,734
I said he wouldn't even make best PL 3rd string.

You tried to make out that opinion was nonsense.

Then you agreed he wasn't in the top 3 best LCBs and shifted the goal posts to top 6 CBs. (I'd already named 6 teams that wouldn't swap their LCB for him)

This would at best mean playing him at RCB (a position he never plays) over the likes of Saliba, Stones, Dias and others.

Which opinion looks the most wrong? Me saying he wouldn't make a best PL 3rd XI or you saying he's one of the best 6 CBs in the league (they aren't the same thing).
I did not agree he was not top 3 LCBs no point lying too and again you backed nothing up this is a subjective conversation and its all our opinions
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,443
I wholeheartedly believe the intention is not to play with a low block. If it is then that's moronic. I think the biggest problem is the majority of our (available) defense is not suited to and therefore cannot execute a high block. This includes maguire, lindelof, Evans, awb, and current version of varane.

Well usually in scenarios like this managers choose to either implement their style of play even if the players they currently have are not ideally suited to it. You don't necessarily need quick defenders to play a high line. Yes you'll be vulnerable in behind but it's not like we're defensively solid right now. Or another option is to play a system to suit the available players and get the best out of them.

Ten Hag has chose option 3, don't actually play with any sort of structure you plan on using long-term and implement a setup that makes us weak at the back and limp in attack. And doesn't seem to get the best out of many if any of our players.

Quite the bold strategy.
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,734
Well usually in scenarios like this managers choose to either implement their style of play even if the players they currently have are not ideally suited to it. You don't necessarily need quick defenders to play a high line. Yes you'll be vulnerable in behind but it's not like we're defensively solid right now. Or another option is to play a system to suit the available players and get the best out of them.

Ten Hag has chose option 3, don't actually play with any sort of structure you plan on using long-term and implement a setup that makes us weak at the back and limp in attack. And doesn't seem to get the best out of many if any of our players.

Quite the bold strategy.
We have not been limp in attack since Jan the defensive shape yes thats been a consistent issue but we also know what the other obvious defensive issue has been
 

Fallon d'Floor

Full Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2024
Messages
461
But did he have to use 30 different combinations at CB? Did he have over 60 different injury’s in a season? And you can compare there 2nd seasons as being better but the fact is none of there first full seasons was better than ETHs. Last year you could see how Liverpool got affected by just losing VVD and a couple of other players. Why does everyone els get a free pass and can use injuries as an excuse but when it’s us it can’t be used?
It's pretty tedious having to constantly educate you.

30 combinations is becoming the new 115 charges.

60 different injuries is pure fantasy stuff.

Liverpool had a bad season last year. It was Klopp's 8th season. You're going to have bad season eventually. The team was coming to the end of its cycle.They had a bad sesson because their midfield got old and players declined. Fabinho fell off a cliff, Henderson got older, The Ox wasn't reliable anymore, Milner was in his late 30's, etc. They sold/released all four of them last summer and replaced them with Mac Allister, Endo, Szoboszlai and Gravenberch. It rejuvenated the team and they have had a decent season. Won a trophy and are still technically in a title race if they win today.

Liverpool have had multiple injuries this season and haven't been a complete disgrace. Alisson, Matip, Robertson, TAA, Bajetic, C.Jones, Szobszlai and Jota have all missed lots of games this season.

When they had an injury crisis during the 20/21 season with van Dijk missing for almost the entire season, they still finished 3rd. They took 26 points from 30 to finish that season. They had CB combinations made up from Rhys Williams, Nat Phillips and Kabak. Fabinho even had to play a few games at CB.They rocked up to Old Trafford and beat us 4-2 with Williams and Phillips playing at CB. Phillips even assisted a goal. Look at the level these two are playing at currently. That's why Klopp is elite. He could achieve 3rd from a difficult situation.

No excuses at all. Klopp failed to achieve top 4 once from 8 full seasons as manager. He built up a bit of leeway by that stage.