I probably should have been more specific, I just feel debating Football on the internet with rival fans comes across as a bit fake and forced. I obviously like discussing things, im doing it right now for example, at 'kin 2am.
Talking 'objectively' with Liverpool fans on here just seems impossible to do when you have people like Davo, njred etc. who are, fairly understandbly, inflexible when it comes to their own team, just like many of our own posters, myself included at times. Discussion and debate only works if both side are open minded and willing to bend and conceed on certain points. Really intense rivalry is so partisan it's difficult to imagine enough people being genuinely objective and philosophical about it. Admittedly you seem one of the few people for whom that comes quite naturally on most subjects, and respect to you for that (I feel respect should have apostrophes around it!).
Take for example something Davo posted earlier. He called Dudek 'a useless cnut'. Obviously he's had this opinion a while, given Dudek has been shit for some time, but do you think Davo would have admitted this say, six months ago whilst he was still a Liverpool player? Of course not, because his instinct is to stick by his team and not lose face. If you can change that instinct in Football fans and football forums, then you'd have yourself the forum you are asking for. Otherwise I just dont see how it'll work.