He was useless in the first game. He got taken off before he got sent off.
21
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 31
- Goals
- 8
- Assists
- 5
- Yellow cards
- 6
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
It's strange when Rooney plays midfield and di Maria up top, yeah. But I do think we're overrating him a little bit more with every game he doesn't start. He started the season brilliantly then faded a bit, also we have to remember van Gaal watches them everyday in training.
Or, you know, a good young Spanish midfielder whilst we instead play strikers in midfield and idiotic formations.
But sure, Zidane, whatever you think works.
T
That's all I can think, then if they tire 2nd half, he will bring him on like last time.
Gobsmaked he's not starting today.
The same van Gaal who constantly bemuses me with his decision making, yes.
I don't overrate him, I don't think he's a Fabregas or an undroppable player or anything, I do think he at least deserves to start a game against a league two side at home, though. He's a very good player who primarily faded in form because of a bad injury and then just not playing games.
We're at OT against a fecking league 2 side. If we can't beat them tonight LVG may aswell throw in the towel and resign, regardless of what team he picked.
Speaks about inbalance yet insists on playing a striker in midfield whilst a perfectly good box to box midfielder sits on the bench..
You really do wonder why he never gets a start.
Utter nonsense isn't it. Getting more frustrating now, and Fergie was one of the worst for playing players out of position.
It's just the Rooney in midfield part that irks me. He's been very poor in the role since the turn of the year.
Just play them in their positions. I can see why Herrera hasn't started...but Mata has which I didn't expect.
Just play them in their positions. I can see why Herrera hasn't started...but Mata has which I didn't expect.
Should be starting ahead of Van Persie, with Rooney going up top.
He's way past Zidane at this stage. He'd be first name on the teamsheet for any team in the world supposedly.
You'd think we have Zidane on the bench, going by the reactions.
I don't think he will be here next season at this rateHe's a very talented player.
But anyway, I'd rather he was starting a game like this. It's a hell of a lot of money to pay for a player that you won't even make use of him in a game versus Cambridge. I hate the financial waste of it.
I think Fellaini is in ahead of him most games for his height, that and the fact he's impressed this season. I'm frustrated we haven't seen more of Herrera, but it's not as if he's set the world alight.
If you keep making up bollocks I'll just thread ban you from anything Herrera related. It's fine that you don't rate him or whatever, but don't make up nonsense to troll people, thanks.
God don't we need that height to beat the mighty cambridge at home.
You laugh, but City and Chelsea paid the price already in this round.
He's 6ft tall, it's not like he's tiny or anything.
He's not had much of a chance to be fair.
Jesus, don't tell me I'm going to have to dig up that post...
Of course I laugh, the Chelsea one was a freak occurrence and we ohad ours (drawing away). Fellaini will make all the difference (one of our worst players in the 1st game)
No, he's not tiny, but he's also not dominant in the air or strong from set pieces. Which is an important factor of the English game.
I know, people have this stupid idea he is about 5ft 6 or something.
I could understand if other people were coming in and playing well...but our midfield has been atrocious all season. In fact, the only games where we've looked like we've even had a midfield, are the ones Herrera has been playing in.
The only player I can understand being selected ahead of him is Blind (or Carrick), because you need someone more disciplined than Herrera in the holding role. Everyone else who's played in midfield has basically not played there, either due to being unbelievably crap, or not actually being a midfielder, or both.
Although on the plus side I reckon from that line up that Rooney might actually be up front.
The only player I can understand being selected ahead of him is Blind (or Carrick), because you need someone more disciplined than Herrera in the holding role. Everyone else who's played in midfield has basically not played there, either due to being unbelievably crap, or not actually being a midfielder, or both.
Although on the plus side I reckon from that line up that Rooney might actually be up front.
This getting beyond belief. Is this the infamous Van Gaal obduracy in action?
Increasingly getting the impression that our Dutch philosopher doesn't have a clue.
Increasingly getting the impression that our Dutch philosopher doesn't have a clue.
if it's one post by some idiot it hardly counts, you're speaking as if it's general consensus that he's as good as Fabregas or would make it into any team in the world, it's not, you know it's not. Stop trolling, simple.
You're acting as if it's the be all and end all to the English game. If that's the reason he's not getting picked and Fellaini is then I sure as hell have some big concerns about old Louis' "philosophy".
He wins a fair amount of challenges too, so he isn't just this cute-looking Spanish midfielder who doesn't want to get gritty.
van Gaal is always quick to point out if a side is direct, full of height, or strong with the long ball, don't forget...
He also mentions the importance of balance on a weekly basis.
I'm not arguing the decision to not play Herrera is right, I'm just arguing I can see why van Gaal decides to do it.
I am beginning to think that the more we and the press want Herrera in, the more he won't play him. He is the sort who will not be told who to play, even when he is getting it wrong.
And if shunting Fellaini into our team is his way of combating that, then god help us.
The current 'Not Allowed'.
Fellaini will also start against West Ham because they're big and physical (less so than previously but still...), so we better get used to this.
Fellaini will also start against West Ham because they're big and physical (less so than previously but still...), so we better get used to this.
We all make it out that this is a nonsensical decision, I just like to add some of van Gaal's much loved balance to the debate.
Does naybody else think he might not be a Van Gaal signing? He was wanted by both Fergie and Moyes, maybe the board just felt that this meant he was a good player and worth buying.
Van Gaal wouldn't know what balance is if it smashed him up the back doors.
Well here's your idiot post from this thread. You can ban me or change my slogan again or whatever. Doesn't bother me. But you can't deny the hyperbole of some of the opinions on here, which is exactly what the post I was replying to was about. If I said, or the post I was replying to said, that it was the opinion of every poster that was over the top, then you'll need to point that out to me. I even said I thought Herrera should be playing tonight!
LvG said himself ages ago that both Herrera and Shaw weren't bought by him, he just gave the go ahead, before he even took over I think.
So Mr. Bighead is saying he knows better than SAF, who does rate him highly.
I'm sure all his medals would argue otherwise.
A bit worrying he isn't getting game time in games such as this. Must be something else at play. He's a good player, don't understand his exclusion.
Well he better win something this season then, because he usually goes downhill in his 2nd season.
- Status