He's receiving no protection from the midfield which is causing him to have at times 2-3 players running at him and past him.
3
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 38
- Clean sheets
- 19
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 9
- Red cards
- 2
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
He's been poor in this half, but St. Etienne is exploiting the space left in front of our CBs by Herrera not sitting in the space and cutting it out in the first place so he's been stepping up and creating problems for us.
His passing though has been awful tonight. He needs to just give the ball to Pogba and chill.
His passing though has been awful tonight. He needs to just give the ball to Pogba and chill.
Looks slow and indecisive tonight, i would get him off!
Agreed
It's not really his fault. You play with 3 midfielders - none who are particularly defensive vs pace of St Etienne then the defense is pulled forward. Same is happening to Valencia.
Mkhitareayn at AM does weirdly more defensive work than Fellaini does. Not even hating.
Mkhitareayn at AM does weirdly more defensive work than Fellaini does. Not even hating.
Some of his passes have been absolutely poor and put us in compromising positions though, this is one of the reasons why I personally just prefer defenders to be a great defender first, and play out from the back as a bonus, but not necessary.
First time we have seen him have a proper bad game in fairness
But he has been bad
But he has been bad
I'm still waiting on a source for that "lost his player 13 times" fact...
He's not dealing with their movement well. He's fine when he sees what coming but when some sneaky little fecker is darting by you all of a sudden and the ball has already been played he's struggling.
Worst game for Utd so far
Is he not allowed to have a bad game now?
Shake rattle and roll,
the pace is taking it's toll
Boom, bang ding a ling bong
For F8cks sake Bailly just hit it long
the pace is taking it's toll
Boom, bang ding a ling bong
For F8cks sake Bailly just hit it long
My eyes are the source
Seems suspect to the long ball.
Looks quite lethargic and slow tonight. I wonder if it's too many games for him - probably his busiest season ever?
Something isn't right. Doesn't look light on his feet today and very clumsy in every facet of his game which is most unlike him. At first I thought it was nerves but physically looks a bit off.
Got a clean sheet whilst sleepwalking
Problem is Herrera being way too aggressive in MF duo, he attacks the ball high up the pitch which leaves Bailly open most of the time.
His worst performance in a United shirt. I hope that this was just a one-off and he'll be back to his imperious self from the next game. He needs to forget about this game as soon as possible.
Just an off day, although he did look far better when Tree came off.
He made more mistakes tonight than the total of the last several months since he arrived. Still showed some quality though, lets hope it was a single off-night for him.
Tried his best to let them score. A night to forget for him.
For some reason he got extremely nervous in first minutes. Apart from that it wasn't that all tragic.
Awful first, better 2nd half although he didn't have too much to do then.
Fine in the 2nd half but that first half was a good learning experience and painful to watch.
Yeah. Maybe a bit ill or something like that. Let's hope it was just a one off.
His poorest game for us, erratic at times and sloppy on the ball, but did make some athletic blocks.
All over the place, fortunate not to be punished, maybe needs a rest at the weekend.
Horrendous today. Probably the worst CB performance we've had in a while. Luckily he timed it well, against impotent opposition.
An oddly poor game but at his age it is a surprise we haven't seen a few more of them sprinkled around. He didn't seem in tune with the game for large parts of it but still made a few good tackles/blocks when it mattered.
Should dampen down some of the hyperbole being spouted in here of late. No harm reminding us he's actually human. Shocking at times tonight. He'll get over it.
He was left exposed too much in the first half. Also he'd a few brain farts.
Was decent enough, not world beating as he usually is though.
Was decent enough, not world beating as he usually is though.
Which one of you eejits said he was the best defender in the league? That was all your fault 
Which one of you eejits said he was the best defender in the league? That was all your fault
Tbf to Bailly, he made some howlers in possession but I thought defensively he was still solid.
There were moments where he looked drunk.
He was day dreaming today, totally lost at times
Worst performance in United shirt. There is no excuse of his brainfart in possession. On his defensive duty though, the tactic didn't help. First of all, our full backs probably were instructed/ allowed to push forward all the time and leave the defensive unit very light. Not just Valencia but also Blind. Normally, our full backs get involve in the build up. This game they just try to get into attacking position and leave our CBs & 2 central midfielders in the build up. At times there were just too much space for Smalling & Bailly to cover. The matter got worse with the midfield component. Pogba might have a very good game with his passing, but he left a lot of space in defensive phase. The 2 men midfield was somehow ended up as with sole defensive midfielder with Herrera in the first half. Herrera is not natural to defensive midfielder role on his own. Fellaini was simply lazy this game. Lost his physical presence edge when we need to ultilize him as an attacking option as well as disappear when we need him in the midfield for defensive purpose.
Things got better in second half, but damage already done psychotically for some players. Bailly was a suspect.
Things got better in second half, but damage already done psychotically for some players. Bailly was a suspect.
Last edited:
Looked a little out of sorts today didn't he? Still did a lot of things well but looked uncomfortable for some reason?
Hopefully he "sleepwalking" is a one-off
I thought Smalling was great again today. Really well-positioned, commanding in the air as always. Most of Bailly errors were of his own making today imo.
Exactly; he did some things really well as usual but you have to admit there were some uncharacteristic mistakes form him today. Just an off day?
True; the insertion of Fellaini disrupted the whole midfield organisation, or lack thereof. In hindsight, Carrick might have been a better replacement for Mkhi to start the game leaving Pogs & Herrara to play as a two in front?
Overreaction methinks Dogg - still made some great plays and no need to risk Rojo who is probably only just fit
Hopefully he "sleepwalking" is a one-off Maybe. Herrera's game IS aggressive though. Fellaini is no Mkhi and there were much bigger gaps than we're used to seeing. Not our best threesome in midfield today. Strangely enough, we were better when Lingard came on & replaced Felly.
- Status