So is that a yes or a no?
Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager
- Thread starter sewey89
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
His comments had nothing to do with football heritage. He just trying to say he’s still doing better than the last guy.
He's coaching them. Apparently.
So, has anyone beaten the crap out of an Erik ten Hag in today?
Doing marginally better points-wise than the season where everyone completely checked out by November. Excellent stuff.
Did Man Utd have the most injuries to defenders in the PL this season?
Do you have that information?
I'm not arguing at all.
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 15,207
- Supports
-
I don’t know which is why I’m asking. What I do know is about the top 6 clubs from late March.
As for the final sentence then you’re WUMming.
Why would you say you’ve just checked and then not share how or where you checked?
Easiest thing so we can all then agree or disagree.
The whole football heritage thing was a talking point started by Mourinho. The poster I quoted said one of their tick boxes for a United manager is not acting like Mourinho and knowing the club is bigger than them.
Ten Hag has expressed sentiments similar to the one expressed by Mourinho, when he spoke on the team of 04:
"They forget, 2004-05, they also didn’t play that great football", and now by essentially saying well, two years ago they had less than 60 points. Of course he's trying to say he's doing better than the last guy, which is disingenuous by the way, but not dissimilar from the exercise Mourinho engaged in with the whole football heritage stuff.
Neither did I, I asked VP for his source and he told me to go research it myself.
Agreed with this. If your response towards asking for a source is "do you have a source" then thats a dead giveaway that you're making shit up. Otherwise just share the source.
Maybe I misconstrued your point. Is your point that Newcastle have had worse injuries than United, or is your point that injuries have affected Newcastle worse than it has United?
The Athletic article I posted gives good analysis as to why, and it's clear to see what we've struggled with relative to every other side in the league.
There’s a plan B?Well that's exactly it. I've given a good analysis of the injury situation sliced by changes per 100mins, concentration of injuries among others. I'm still waiting for @stevoc to explain his findings.
The possibility also exists that he’s a totally unsuitable manager, who was dealt a shite hand and doesn’t have the skill set to cope with those kind of challenges
@stevoc
I'm really enjoying your comments, views, and the way you unravel part of the context they use to argue about. It gives me even greater pleasure when I see their replies, how they maximally avoid giving any reasoned answer, but immediately consider that it is an attack on them and their opinion.
Cheers mate!
I made the mistake of watching the 99 documentary on Amazon earlier. SAF was a proper manager. It makes this situation with ETH look absurd. He will never have that charisma and drive to lead us to anything
Ole had Peps number though. And was a likeable character.
31 points gap and 63 GD apart to City and somehow there is still people who wants to keep him. We should never be this bad after spending so much.
Injuries yada yada, ETH definitely didn't get any point from handling injury crisis.
Injuries yada yada, ETH definitely didn't get any point from handling injury crisis.
Do you have any examples of managers dealt a similar hand, that coped with it really well?
When he arrived he was championing how we finished second the season before.
The stats point to us being fortunate to be as high as 8th as well.
The stats point to us being fortunate to be as high as 8th as well.
Can’t say that I do, but I would bet the house that Fergie would have managed it all better.
Ah yes, that old chestnut.
People keep bringing up injuries as a way of taking some of the blame off ETH for this disastrous season but he himself might be responsible for a large chunk of them due to his training methods.
How similar does it have to be?
Real Madrid had 2 defenders + GK out with serious long-term injuries, as well as a number of shorter injuries, and nonetheless had their best league campaign in a decade and are in CL final.
Well let’s keep the man in charge who oversaw 19 defeats in a season, negative goal difference, finished 8th, cracked some ‘worst since..’ records, got badly embarrassed in the easiest CL group, and probably loads more that I’ve forgotten. Sure let’s lean into the injuries narrative and ignore all the red flags slapping us in the face. I can do that. I mean it’ll be funny to see how far we can sink.
You have an experienced manager with hair so it doesn’t count
Let's be honest, I am not sure if I can take another season of Ten Hag football like this season. We were basically dominated by almost every team that we play with occasional 1-2 good performance every 2-3 months. In NBA, coaches makes the difference between winning and losing. I see young hungry team competing against top team with stars. Even with his stars returning, I cannot see this team competing. ETH doesn't has any capability to inspire this team. Best managers has the ability to brings the best out of average players, ETH doesn't have the X factor. It's time to move on, he isn't our answer.
these were some of our stats going into today's game:
• 1.34 xG (13th)
• 1.87 xGA (18th)
• -0.53 xG difference (17th)
• 392 open play shots created (9th)
• 643 shots faced (19th)
• 49.99% possession (10th)
I just want to enjoy watching us play, and I'm doubt that ever happens with this bloke in charge.
I expected a bit more noise by this point, so I genuinely think he might be getting another season, which is astonishing really.
Does mean we're in for a mental summer of ins and outs though.
I expected a bit more noise by this point, so I genuinely think he might be getting another season, which is astonishing really.
Does mean we're in for a mental summer of ins and outs though.
Courtois, Militão and Alaba all did their ACL this season at Real. Benzema left the club and was replaced by Joselu.
Real have only lost 2 games in all competitions this season.
Liverpool took 28 points from 30 at the end of the 20/21 season with defences containing Rhys Williams, Nat Phillips, Kabak and Fabinho across those 10 games. Yet concede just 6 goals and finished 3rd.
Isak missed 7 PL games this season and Wilson missed 18 PL games this season. Newcastle still managed to score 85 PL goals without their two main sources of goals.
Thanks. Honestly it’s like the Dutch Ted Lasso took over.
Having six defenders out all at once is a bit worse, weird you are making this point.
INEOS won't fail to notice these things if they really are analytical and data driven.
Our GD is +1 across our last 52 PL games. It was -1 before today's win.
Let's see. One of the issues that was a symptom of the club rot was that we basically had no data department. We got one random OxBridge PhD after a while and he disappeared into the ether. Meanwhile City, Pool and Chelsea (surprisingly) have been on the forefront of football analytics.
I still don't see any evidence that we even started hiring in that direction.
Didn't we hire that Dominic Jordan guy for this area ? That was almost 2 years ago.
I've been tryng to ascertain which side has had the most defensive injuries this season. Your post earlier today seemed to suggest you had information that confirmed it was United.
Is that the case or did I misinterpret your post?
I'm waiting on yours too mate.
It's as simple as that. Nothing else needs to be said.
That first half of football was embarrassing for anyone associated with Manchester United so I am afraid he has to go.