How good is Timber? Reason I ask is because he was supposedly ETH's first choice and Martinez the second, but Martinez has been outstanding and I can hardly think of a CB in world football I would want over him right now. Is Timber supposed to be better?
Timber is great but nowhere near as mature, solid, and a leader as Martinez. Timber needed Martinez, Martinez doesn't need anyone.
He's had a poor season for his standards but I am not moved by that. I feel like in the previous seasons, Timber was close or on Martinez level (but because he had Martinez leading him).
What Martinez brings with his passing, Timber brings with his rushes, dribbling, agility and speed. He creates space and opportunitjes from deep by his carries, and he is an adept passer of the ball (not Martinez) level. On the ball, what he brings offensively, would be an improvement on Varane and great.
He's very strong in the tackle, also able to stop attackers by his great agility. He's agressive and also very fast for a CB, he's good in the air, maybe not as good as Martinez and also not als invincible and strong. But he is able to shut down any forward, he manhandled Lewandowski before the WC.
His partnership with Blind / Bassey / Alvarez hasnt been great this season in a very poor and unbalanced Ajax team, he's been making errors.
I feel like Varane and Martinez is a very complimentary duo, Timber would be an awesome understudy. But I'm sure he'll aim for more.
It is no disgrace if EtH prioritised to get him over Martinez, even though Martinez is a lot better. Timber is a hell of a talent, his age and speed make him a huge prodigy.