Very unfair piece from a journalist determined to be Jose's favourite.
Another game for Shaw in his recovery. So it's only a positive for me.
23
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 19
- Clean sheets
- 13
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 2
- Status
Another game for Shaw in his recovery. So it's only a positive for me.
Yeah, looked knackered. Which I guess would be fair enough as he hasnt played a lot of football, but it honestly seemed like 7 or 8 of them were the same, not sure what condition work we do but we never appear as fit as other sides.
Gosh, I hate that guy so much.
Bang average. If Jose decides to sell him I wouldn't mind, personally I think he's destined for a career at a club like Leicester or Everton, which is his true level.
However, he's better than our other options for LB (which is scary in itself) and is English. Therefore, I'd prefer us to sell Blind and Darmian and keep Shaw as backup.....if he rediscovers his old form and displaces our new LB, brilliant. If he doesn't, no harm done.
However, he's better than our other options for LB (which is scary in itself) and is English. Therefore, I'd prefer us to sell Blind and Darmian and keep Shaw as backup.....if he rediscovers his old form and displaces our new LB, brilliant. If he doesn't, no harm done.
He was good in the first half, but 2nd half he dropped which coincides with the fact that in the 2nd half he played closer to Mourinho.
His last two games opened my eyes about him. He is just solid left back. Nothing more and nothing else. Good backup player . But having young there, we should sell him and buy united level first left back. Rose or sandro. Comparing him to young and valencia he is far away from them. He is more old fashion left back who will cross the ball if he has space and will stick to his position. Was against buying left back but we need better than shaw.
Sandro is dreadful for Juve this season, I mean so bad he isn't even playing at all.
I think you are overrating Young and Valencia personally. Shaw can surpass them both if given chance.
Shaw looks more than a little short on confidence just now, a bit like more than a few other United players. I do wonder if he is going to fulfill that early potential he showed at Southampton. I hope he does, obviously.
Whether it happens at United or elsewhere is another question entirely. He certainly isn't one of Jose's favourites anyway.
Whether it happens at United or elsewhere is another question entirely. He certainly isn't one of Jose's favourites anyway.
I think people forget how good he was when he came back from injury last season before getting made a scapegoat after the Watford game, this forum was full of praise for him.
Then he didn’t quite get tight enough to his man in a game where he was in no way the worse united player and he gets hung out to dry by a manager looking for some one to blame.
Then he didn’t quite get tight enough to his man in a game where he was in no way the worse united player and he gets hung out to dry by a manager looking for some one to blame.
Luke Shaw did something yesterday that many must not have noticed, I´m talking about the inswinging low ground cross that any decent attack should have buried when it came into the box. The boy has that in his locker and he was really flying before his leg was broken in 2 places. Many do not recover at all after this and perhaps Shaw needs a little support because had we scored from this wonderful cross of his yesterday the talk would be different about him today. The problem is we are hopeless in attack at the moment, the lack of movement is staggering and there seems to be no attacking plan in hand. We are hoofing the ball up the field most of the time and Matic and Pobga are so slow in that teams are passing around us like we are not there. Leaving Martial on the bench is something I do not understand as he´s the only one that can take a man on and win 1 vs 1 postions. Bring back Roy Keane as part of the coaching staff ( I dunno that will not happen) and let him have a go at this lot, that would be a joy to see. Many of them seem to be not bothered at all. Recall Fosu-Mensah, give Tuanzebe a chance and even young Gomes as he can hardly be worse than Mikitaryan and see if they can spark some life into the team, at least they would be giving more than many of the current first team. Mourinho is so right in stating we need better players and it will be interesting to see what happens in January.
Not outstanding at the minute but sold enough and for me doing enough for a run in the side and hopefully prove he has a future here.
Everton 0:2 Man Utd
Looking better and better. 
He's lost some weight.
Breath of fresh air at left back. Creating lots of space on our left with his runs.
Good outing for him.
Another good game by him so far. Hope he keeps it up!
Really solid and getting back to his form
Aye he’s looked really good. Can’t even remember the last time any of our fullbacks picked out a ball like he did for Martial and Just attacking space, it’s great to see. He’s also been good defensively, hopefully this puts and end to the Rose rumours.
He's been great, all things considered and put in a few good crosses too.
His link up play is very good, his final pass/cross is not very good but his overall passing is very good
Best performance in a United shirt today for me. He's got the LB/LWB slot locked down barring injury.
solid 7/10 type game, not fully fit yet either imo
This is what having an actual left back looks like.
Another good showing and it's evident that Jose is beginning to trust him
Wee bit sloppy at times, but a good performance over all. I don't think he's fully fit yet and hopefully he can build on this or at least keep up this level for the rest of the season. If he does that he will save us some money in the summer.
Has all the talent to cement the spot for years. Just needs to stay fit. Very disappointed if we let him go and bring Rose in
Intensity not quite there but technically he's always been very good and am glad he's getting games now, even if it's just because everyone else is injured.
Great game it makes a change to have a full back that can attack and actually put a decent ball in.
Think he has played well again. His forward runs still aren't there, but he is playing that well defensively it doesn't even matter so much.
I thought he was shite on Saturday but fair play to him he played very well today.
We have a genuine world class LB talent in our team, great game again today.
Getting better and better
Doesn’t need to be upgraded.
Very good performance
Very good tonight.
What a difference is to to see a natural left back playing in that position, who can overlap and give us some width. I am not his biggest fan, but he is by far our best option in that position.
Talent was always there and everyone knows that. He's starting to prove that he could be a regular starter
Shaw > Rose, and has years of developemwnt ahead too.
Another good performance. He looks to have worked a lot on his passing and link up play which will be important. Never really hidden it but I'm a huge fan of his and hope we keep him.
- Status