We may be better off consolidating all players into one thread.
Thoughts ?
IMO Raoul, you can make certain buffer... say 10+ pages then it might:
1. deserve a sub forum
2. deserve a 2nd part in separate thread)
3. Be a sticky
etc
Or if there's 5 thread over Messi then you can adversely:
1. Merge them
2. Open them a mega thread with sub forum
etc
Or perhaps :
You give a new "Berbatov" thread 1 day to reach 5+ pages or merged into the mega thread, if it reaches "Your buffer" then it merits its own thread
If it reaches your buffer it deserves it, if it doesn't then it doesn't
I can see the argument from both sides, and yes I prefer 1 thread for 1 occasion, and not the mega thread which takes up time and effort to really dwell into it, but you can't always please everyone. SOme leniency and we'll be cluttered with messi x, messi y, berbatov x, berbatov y, and too strict will make us rawkish, i can see that 1 year old thread still looming there everyday.
To be honest, I like it the way it is now,