Man Utd 2:1 Swansea
After getting a lot of shit on here recently I thought he did a solid job today, loved his hoof clearance late on, sometimes the simple ways are the best.
33
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 9
- Clean sheets
- 2
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 0
- Status
I think the opposite, thought he was shaky as he has been all season. Got away with a howler when Swansea got the shot away late on. Definetly not a long term defender at United IMO.
Hard to judge him when hes played LB at times, CB at times, RB at times, and its minutes here and there. I think his best position will be CB but maybe he could be a OShea type player for us (which sometimes the team needs even if its not great for the player at all).
Depends what he wants as well.
Depends what he wants as well.
He looked shaky again yesterday, I think he could do with a loan move where he's guaranteed to play every week so the club can judge him better.
Man Utd 0:1 Southampton
Useless defender. Shouldn't even be playing for the club.
Mcmare is a bit shit
Someone said in the match day thread that he would go on a marauding run and you start to think he is player until he makes a terrible defensive mistake. And so it proved to be true.
Marking players doesn't seem to be his strong point. Was at fault for Southampton's late goal earlier in the season too.
Solid on the ball today but at fault for the goal which is his main job.
He can't defend. It's just so brutally obvious, and at this age you can't teach such a fundamental skill enough to bring it up from absolute nothing to being good enough for a title contender.
Martinez would take him at Everton though.
Martinez would take him at Everton though.
That....kinda sums it up.
Costs us a goal almost every time he plays it seems. Have to think he will be sold soon.
Surprised he wasn't our lowest rated player. His mistake essentially cost us the game.
Stuck in no mans land. Not good enough
no we'd have to score - "cost the game" maybe a point.
What does LvG see in this chap?
I think LVG should be playing FB and stop hooking him after every bad display. It's doing him more harm than good the way he is being managed. He is developing that Jones habit of trying to do more instead of just concentrate on getting the job done first, this leads to a lot of silly mistakes.
He's far too slow to play fullback.
He shouldn't be in the squad let alone playing out of position. He just can't defend.
What's his purpose in the team exactly? One of those young players like Chris Eagles a few years back who randomly gets a run in the team even though it is blatantly obvious he isn't good enough for us.
I don't really understand the attitude of some of the posters on here towards Mcnair. Here we have a young player, thrown in to a side bereft of confidence, to cover a rather large injury list.
I remember some of the praise he was getting on the forum for some of his early games.
As things stand defensively (the way LVG sets us up!) we have
Shaw-injured
Rojo-injured
Jones-injured
Young injured
Valencia-injured
M.Keane-sold
Thorpe-sold
Darmain-injured
So, Mcnair represents what little depth we have left in a threadbare squad because that's the way LVG operates.
We have a forward line, and a midfield that cost a tonne of money, that can't create a chance between them, and yet posters turn on a young inexperienced defender who cost us nothing?
Give the guy a break, there are bigger problems than him at the moment
I remember some of the praise he was getting on the forum for some of his early games.
As things stand defensively (the way LVG sets us up!) we have
Shaw-injured
Rojo-injured
Jones-injured
Young injured
Valencia-injured
M.Keane-sold
Thorpe-sold
Darmain-injured
So, Mcnair represents what little depth we have left in a threadbare squad because that's the way LVG operates.
We have a forward line, and a midfield that cost a tonne of money, that can't create a chance between them, and yet posters turn on a young inexperienced defender who cost us nothing?
Give the guy a break, there are bigger problems than him at the moment
typical of this place - the team is pretty crap but the standard of poster might well be worse.
whatever! Tell me @RedPhil1957 what exactly are you trying to say in your reply to my post?
Haha.. Nah.. Playing him at fullback is the best way to blood in young defenders and helps to teach them about defensive structures.
In contrast to CBJ he tries too hard to impress lately instead of just concentrating on doing the job at hand.
Majority of the cafe want Blind at fullback, huh my nan can beat him for pace.
He's a box to box midfielder and not a defender. The sad thing is that he has loads of talent if utilized properly. None of that excuses losing your marker like he did today though.
Yourself included
I'm pretty sure he is agreeing with you.
Somehow,I don't think so!
I think so.
Typical of this place means its typical of everyone to shit all over young players like you are saying. Then the standard of posters is just shit posts bitching about everything.
Hey, maybe I'm wrong though.
I picked up on the bolded bit, and as that was all he said, I read it as him having a pop at me!
Lololol....and sigh.
That was me. As soon as I saw his name I knew something like that would happen and posted it before he even got on the pitch.
Until he gets a run in the middle of the park in a functioning team, I won't criticise him too much but it's depressing seeing the same inevitable the mistakes happen.
edit: here it is
True.
I thought he was going to become the next OShit but the boy show much more promise. Its still early days of course but I think that this guy could well become the next Prunier
I feel sorry for the lad because he has been thrown in at the deep end at times but in truth he is utter garbage. I can't see him being at the club beyond the summer.
Thing is though, if he starts in the middle or not, his duty on corners remains essentially the same, don't leave your man.Lololol....and sigh.
That was me. As soon as I saw his name I knew something like that would happen and posted it before he even got on the pitch.
Until he gets a run in the middle of the park in a functioning team, I won't criticise him too much but it's depressing seeing the same inevitable the mistakes happen.
edit: here it is
Midtjylland 2:1 Man Utd
I was hoping to see some views on him tonight, I genuinely can barely remember him doing anything right or wrong, I was distracted by the river of shit flowing through midfield..
He was poor if you ask me. What happened when they got that insane break from one of our corners? Blind took the corner? Smalling would have been in the box looking to get a header at goal so where were Mcnair and Love?
That was bad but I have to wonder where our leaders on the pitch are to organize these young lads in those situations.
I didn't see the replay so I don't know what happened but I have never seen anything like that in all my years watching United.
He's absolutely dire.
Use the excuses of injuries etc all you want, but I'd far rather of seen Carrick at CB, or Blind at CB and Lingard at fullback than play McNair.
League one level at best.
Use the excuses of injuries etc all you want, but I'd far rather of seen Carrick at CB, or Blind at CB and Lingard at fullback than play McNair.
League one level at best.
- Status