Said previously he can be molded to become Matic successor. He looks very close to him, looks a younger Matic.
39
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 23
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 4
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
Including this oneKid is special. Playing like a man.
Btw for the many doubters here (including me) he did a lot of forward passes.
Not so average in passing after all.
Forward passes, forward passes.
Jose said he is the epitome of a modern CM. Was really happy with McTominay, even went as far as to say he can do everything, even score goals, but his current instructions are stifling that part of his game. Huge praise and we might be seeing him becoming a proper mainstay in our squad. I'm really happy for him, another youth prospect who is United through and through.
This. It is mentality that defines which players make it in my opinion.
Fixed. Fletcher is the energetic combative type that can carry the ball forward, McTominay is more of the physical combative type that relies more on pass and move.
YESSS! Thanks. Yeap, good job, so hopefully this evidence will helps make this thread 'brighter'.
It would be difficult to fail to be impressed by him. He's played relatively little football at any sort of level, much less CL and PL level in tough midfield battles and he doesn't look out of place. He needs time and there'll be bad days to come, as happens to almost every young player, but he's making breaking into United's midfield look a lot easier than it actually is.
His progress will tell Jose that he doesn't need to hang onto Fellani to be back-up to Milinkovic-Savic or Seri next season or whoever we get.
Agree with this. I like the lad.
His biggest test so far against CHELSEA, scored A+.
Bit shaken in the first half vs Sevilla then really came into the game.
Today he did very well, looks so confident.
admittedly I doubted him before the game, to be honest I still do a bit because he is so inexperienced and has a major part to play in this team at the moment. But as long as he carries on how he is at the moment he should get everyone in his side, which I hope he does.
Really happy for him.
Today he did very well, looks so confident.
admittedly I doubted him before the game, to be honest I still do a bit because he is so inexperienced and has a major part to play in this team at the moment. But as long as he carries on how he is at the moment he should get everyone in his side, which I hope he does.
Really happy for him.
dare I say captain McTominay..... Another impressive display and another good post match interview from the young lad, showing him praising his team mates at 21 years old
If his job was to exclusively man mark Hazard why was he tracking Willian’s run?
Totally surprised me today. Worked really hard, his control and touch were great, his positioning was great and he passed it well. Enjoyed watching him ordering and people around too.
Still not sure if he's actually any good - I suspect he's quite a limited footballer - but there's no doubting he did well today.
Still not sure if he's actually any good - I suspect he's quite a limited footballer - but there's no doubting he did well today.
When someone makes a run like that you have to track it.
Has already graduated from 'emergency stop-gap' to viable option. Fair play to the lad. Just looking at Arsenal now, he would immediately improve that midfield.
Initially, he tracked Willian on the counter, then when he saw Hazard he stopped.
Probably thought someone else would drop or shuffle across.
Well, exactly. That was a bad mistake. Schoolboy error. No big deal in the grand scheme of things. He’ll learn from it.
You sure as shit don’t start tracking it then suddenly stop.
He played pretty well aside from that huge error for the goal. Hazard did absolutely nothing all day long.
Yeah that was baffling.
Bad mistake for the goal but I think he did very well out there given his comparative lack of experience.
Excellent again
I was really disappointed in the poor tracking for the goal but this can happen. He has the skillsets required to be a top player according to Jose so I'm behind him.
He was good second half. No need for people to excuse his mistake to be a proper top fan. It was a stupid mistake, he'll learn. Thought he grew into the game second half and he's continuing to prove people wrong.
As many have already said, his only big mistake was failing to track Willian for the goal. Other than that he was given a massive job today. Defensively he was more or less marking Hazard, who didn't produce much at all. That was the same as Matic, who had main responsibility for Willian. Since McTominay is younger and has better capacity, he also had more offensive movement than Matic. If not for the mistake at the goal he'd be 2nd only to Lukaku for the MoM today in my book.
Watching live in the ground it felt like the biggest error was from Valencia playing him onside when he did not need to break the defensive line. Replays only confirmed that. I suppose McTominay could have tracked without any downside, but the goal comes about because of Valencia’s positioning primarily. It’s his error.
Mou on him post match was very positive. Even highlighted his lack of goals and assists, but said not to worry because he knows he can do that, that we saw it in pre season, and that he has wanted him to focus on the basics so far.
Yeah.
If Jose is putting this much trust in a 21 year old midfielder, then I'm more than inclined to believe his judgement.
McTominay has been impressive so far and showed again today that stepping up to this level doesn't phase him. He has a good temperament and that bodes well. Playing central midfield is probably one of the hardest positions to step into as you can't hide. I think he is quite conservative in his approach but I think he is doing exactly what the manager is asking of him and in time we'll see him become more adventurous in his passing, especially as he gets more game time against lesser teams. I think what really plays in his favour is that as a young player progressing through the ranks, he was small and so had to learn his trade through good positioning movement and passing but because of course he grew so rapidly he now has physicality on his side. Think we have a decent homegrown squad player here.
Big mistake for the goal but his was one of three big individual errors in this goal. Otherwise very impressive, has the most fantastic tempo to his passing. It is hard to define but every pass is hit with real intent and timed to reach the recipient in their perfect stride. I'm probably getting carried away but I am very happy that we have unearthed such a quality midfield player in our academy ranks.
He has a better temperament than Pogba for CM. Paul needs to be a little further upfront. Scott also doesn't bring a circus with him.
Not sure if Scott can be in our first XI for the next decade, but he has a chance to prove himself now.
Not sure if Scott can be in our first XI for the next decade, but he has a chance to prove himself now.
This
His best performance in a united shirt to date. He was also the one with the long ball forward to Lukaku for the second goal. Starting to really like this kid hope he can keep it up and have many more chances in the first team.
He looks like the real deal to me.
Some people keep blaming Scott for that goal and they have a valid point. He should have tracked Willian rather than ball watch. But rewind a bit. The first problem was Valencia's average cross to the box. Tony could have done a lot better with the cross.
The second problem was Pogba who failed to leap and intercept the Chelsea player who headed the ball out (can't remember who now). For some reasons, Pogba simply didn't bother to jump and considering the danger of a counter attack, that created a massive problem for United. The third problem was Scott failing to track Willian as it has been highlighted.
The fifth problem was Lindelof, a much more experienced defender than Scott. I thought he failed to organise that defensive position well. Like Scott, he ball watched otherwise Willian could have been tracked and stopped.
The second problem was Pogba who failed to leap and intercept the Chelsea player who headed the ball out (can't remember who now). For some reasons, Pogba simply didn't bother to jump and considering the danger of a counter attack, that created a massive problem for United. The third problem was Scott failing to track Willian as it has been highlighted.
The fifth problem was Lindelof, a much more experienced defender than Scott. I thought he failed to organise that defensive position well. Like Scott, he ball watched otherwise Willian could have been tracked and stopped.
That goal was full of mistakes, even De Gea had his share, too.
Regardless of this goal, this lad is growing more and more into the team. Getting full confidence and truth from the manager to play in CL KO game then against Chelsea. The kid must be day dreaming.
I think if you keep rewinding we can attribute the fault of the goal to the big bang
Truth be told, at this stage - he doesn't really offer something Ander wouldn't for the most part as regards following specific instructions, so it's quite puzzling that the latter was noticeably sidelined by José ever since we signed Matić, despite being one of our better performers last season, revisionism aside. That being said, it's pretty neat that Lingard and him have played crucial roles over the season (to varying degrees of course), and McTominay's progression has come as a pleasant surprise. Kinda reminds me of Marchisio when he was emerging at Juventus or on loan at Empoli in terms of having solid fundamentals and a calm head on his shoulders, though I dunno if he possesses Marchisio's eclectic skillset - that allowed him to play at pretty much every midfield position and interpret different roles at a 7/10 or 8/10 level. Not much of a consistent creative or goalscoring threat right now either and somehow seems like a limited player, but if he isn't supplanted by better midfielders, that aspect of his game might become more prominent in due time, especially considering he's very green right now and probably em-burdened by jobs that limit him - so we aren't seeing the full extent of what he has to offer. At the very least, he could be a decent squad option and tactical piece over the coming years given Mourinho's apparent fondness for him.
Thought he did well today. Except for their goal.
Did he get any goals/assists in pre-season?
- Status