If I take of my red tinted glasses of a few seconds, it is clear to see that Tuchel over both leg won the tactical battle in terms of being the dominant team and players putting in the better performance.
However, when you look at that amount of arrogance that was in the psg team last night, Tuchel deserved to get eliminated based on that. A 2-0 lead in the first leg is not a difficult lead to hold, especially when you have excellent technical players like Verratti, Draxler, and a destroyer in Marquinhos in your midfield. Moreover, the opposition managers allowing you all the possession in the world. When I saw Dani Alves doing this in the game:
I knew we were going to go through. I am not sure what Tuchel said to his players, but I doubt a manager like Simione would have allowed that or for their team to get so complacent. Whereas, other top managers would have showed confidence in a different manner that doesn’t border on arrogance. Either way, Tuchel is still a good manager, but very naive to underated this United team.