OFFICIAL: Jose Mourinho is Manchester United manager | Megathread closed, start new Mourinho threads

How do feel about José Mourinho's appointment as Man Utd manager?


  • Total voters
    1,939
Status
Not open for further replies.

Rado_N

Yaaas Broncos!
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
111,373
Location
Manchester
A lot of people saying he looks uncomfortable and at unease, others speculating last season has knocked his confidence some. I hope Ed asked a lot of questions when they met up.
Thankfully we can comfortably ignore internet body-language 'experts'.
 

SteveJ

all-round nice guy, aka Uncle Joe Kardashian
Scout
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
62,851
I'm not one to go out on a limb with conspiracy theories but I reckon he's worried that the brown suit was the wrong choice.
 

Riz

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2014
Messages
4,245
Location
UK
Love seeing videos like that showing behind the scenes stuff.
Me too. I wish we got more insight. Like I'd love to see a Mourinho team meeting, be fascinating to see what he talks about, how in depth he goes etc.
 

TheNewEra

Knows Kroos' mentality
Joined
Jan 20, 2014
Messages
8,329
Me too. I wish we got more insight. Like I'd love to see a Mourinho team meeting, be fascinating to see what he talks about, how in depth he goes etc.
You can see them in his Inter documentaries and some of his older stuff I believe.

I hate this bit of the runnings though, it felt all of this was done with David Moyes all the photos the build up and it amounted to nothing.

I'm not comparing the two but those awkward photos of him carrying the shopping could be a strange thing to look bac on in a years time, Ed probably wants the United branding everywhere on the bag, in the background, he'll be forced to get a tattoo soon.
 

JB08

Searches for nude pics of Marcos Rojo
Joined
Mar 16, 2013
Messages
8,483
Love seeing videos like that showing behind the scenes stuff.
Me too. I wish we got more insight. Like I'd love to see a Mourinho team meeting, be fascinating to see what he talks about, how in depth he goes etc.
Completely agree. Wish we'd start our own Youtube channel, similar to Citeh's. Unfortunately theirs is too good for me not to subscribe to.
 

prateik

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
42,226
Did he do this when he was at Chelsea as well? His wife posting pictures of him with United bag and a scarf and the jersey on his office chair ...
 

prateik

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
42,226
Nah, it seems like United made him make an Instagram account! Good decision really...would love to see what Jose is up too!
It's not just his instagram account.
His wife has been posting stuff on twitter. His office, him holding a bag from the United store. His son has been posting on twitter too.
 

Bugshot

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
825
Keane is a lot of things but, the whole "decent career" thing...He's a very humble and self critical man. Read his book, it's like he's talking to his therapist.

As for him and Fergie. Both of them are pig ignorant shits, as much as I love them. Fergie continued to employee a secretary he hated, at St. Mirren, purely so he could make a point of not talking to her and that's not a joke :D Keane is just as bad

EDIT: He's a season ticket holder ffs, him and his children. How bitter does one have to be to buy season ticket to something they hate? :D Keane loves United. He hates Fergie. That's it!
You see that tree? Thats the one scholes always hits in every footballers story about him.

I want to look like Jose when I'm old. :(
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,253
Ah fair enough.

Still though with Moyes i'm sure something similar could have been worked out with Everton to allow Moyes to start work earlier if he had actually wanted to, instead of having a 6 week holiday.

He was after all pictured at Carrington with Ferguson and Albert Morgan the day after the season ended, so Everton didn't seem too concerned about it all.
 

Bugshot

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
825
I don't get this, "he'll have to change himself now he's at United, he needs to be humble". Bollox, he's not a teenager with raging hormones ffs. He's a mature and successful man everyone aspires to be like.

If he's here for short term, let him be the Mourinho he is. If he's here to build a dynasty, let him be himself as well. He's been successful in whatever he has done all his life and a lot of it can be attributed to his madness for the game. We've wanted him all along and have admired him for what he is. Why should he change?

That video was seriously odd at some parts with Sir Bobby. Mourinho putting his hand on his shoulder was almost a Gareth moment from the office. Let him be Mourinho. He isn't as evil after all as some believe.

I hope he isn't asked to " behave" by the club, that's simply putting unnecessary pressure on a guy that already has a big job on his hands.
 

JTW95

Gullible sausage
Joined
Jun 21, 2013
Messages
9,119
Just go on the SSN app and the top story is Mourinho and Charlton meeting.

Skys Mourinho bum fest is brilliant. I bet it is really pissing off rival fans :lol:
 

royboy16

Full Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
8,204
Location
The moon gave me flowers for funerals to come.
Ah fair enough.

Still though with Moyes i'm sure something similar could have been worked out with Everton to allow Moyes to start work earlier if he had actually wanted to, instead of having a 6 week holiday.

He was after all pictured at Carrington with Ferguson and Albert Morgan the day after the season ended, so Everton didn't seem too concerned about it all.
The last thing you want to do is quit one job and immediately start another. I know people that take a month off before starting their new job and they don't earn huge money like these lads.
 

Werder Herzog

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
5,710
Location
Butter My Arse
Glad to see he has started early. Obviously give the nod for the contract extensions of CBJ and Rashford you would think- now let's get a couple in before the Euros.
 

GBBQ

Full Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2012
Messages
4,822
Location
Ireland
The last thing you want to do is quit one job and immediately start another. I know people that take a month off before starting their new job and they don't earn huge money like these lads.
In general I agree with what you're saying but given the size of the job and the importance of the transfer window, Football might be the exception to the rule there. If he transferred job mid-season he would have been expected to step right into the role.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,253
The last thing you want to do is quit one job and immediately start another. I know people that take a month off before starting their new job and they don't earn huge money like these lads.
And yet thats what most of us have to do out of necessity. Very few people can afford to take a month off before starting a new job.

And anyway being a football manager is not a normal job, some aspects of it are time sensitive like scouting, identifying and buying players.

It seems to me given Moyes crippling reluctance to spend money and his insistence on only signing players he has personally scouted or seen play 400 times. His time in May/June 2013 might have been better spent preparing for the biggest job of his career instead of sunning himself on a french beach.

At the time some people on here suggested he could be working on transfers behind the scenes but nope turns out he wasn't. He waited until July 1st turned up at Carrington and asked Woodward to sign Ronaldo/Bale/Fabregas/Fellaini. United didn't even make any bids for players until mid July, why wasn't Woodward given a list of targets before this so he could have been working on transfers all through June.
 

SirAF

Ageist
Joined
Sep 28, 2003
Messages
37,763
Location
And yet thats what most of us have to do out of necessity. Very few people can afford to take a month off before starting a new job.

And anyway being a football manager is not a normal job, some aspects of it are time sensitive like scouting, identifying and buying players.

It seems to me given Moyes crippling reluctance to spend money and his insistence on only signing players he has personally scouted or seen play 400 times. His time in May/June 2013 might have been better spent preparing for the biggest job of his career instead of sunning himself on a french beach.

At the time some people on here suggested he could be working on transfers behind the scenes but nope turns out he wasn't. He waited until July 1st turned up at Carrington and asked Woodward to sign Ronaldo/Bale/Fabregas/Fellaini. United didn't even make any bids for players until mid July, why wasn't Woodward given a list of targets before this so he could have been working on transfers all through June.
Definitely. Even if he was, formally, not done with his Everton contract he should still have started to work on United targets the next day after Ferguson gave him the job. Some people are born with 12 cylinders, and Moyes is not one of them.
 

Perrick Dubois

New Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2015
Messages
1,522
I genuinely don't believe our league is set up particularly well to create Champions League winners.

The money domestically means the league is hugely competitive from the lower middle up. This means fewer games to roll over opposition and ease off or rest players.

The competition for the top four and champions league qualification that earns so much means that from February onwards every single point counts and that means difficult decisions are made for the weekend/midweek team selections.

Stylistically, producing a team that is successful in the league does not produce a team that is set up to do well in the champions league. The league is about forcing the 3 points whereas the champions league is more of a chess match with patience a key attribute.

The Christmas period and January in our league is a time for exhaustion, burnout and muscle injuries as fatigue and cold temperatures take their victims with a flurry of league matches and domestic cup fixtures build up. On the continent it's time for rejuvenation and warm weather breaks to Dubai as players prepare themselevs for the run in.
Better late than never, excellent post Pexbo.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,280
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
Ive been thinking a lot about the similarities between Mourinho and SAF in the last few days, especially after Mockney's excellent post in the other (now closed) Mourinho thread last week.

The starting off point is complete agreement (the thesis in a nutshell being, for anyone that missed it, that Mourinho is the closest thing there is in football today to SAF, in terms of mind games, pragmaticism and the determination to win superseding all other considerations - among other things.)

But I have been thinking about what the key differences are. I think in a way they are more interesting, because, to be honest, the similarities are more obvious. And I have decided what it comes down to more than anything else is their respective attitudes to risk. SAF "learned" pragmaticism, I think. No, I think he was always pragmatic to a certain extent but I think he learned over time, and especially in certain situations (like the CL), that he needed to curb his instincts in order to be successful - to be more pragmatic than he had been in the past. I think his instinct was to attack. I dont think it is necessarily about entertainment per se, tho Im sure he wanted to entertain. I think it is more what I said previously - the attitude to risk.

I think when SAF was faced with a challenge his instinct was to attack it. He understood in certain situations you needed to stay your hand, and I think the older he got the more his head ruled his heart, if you want to put it that way: he understood on a logical or intellectual level the merits of a more cagey, pragmatic approach, and he defaulted to it more and more. As you get older it is easier, I think, for your head to rule your heart, you become less impulsive and more measured. I think this is what happened with SAF. And I think actually the younger man, Mourinho, played a role in teaching him that lesson - as did many years of disappointment in the CL. I am thinking of the FA Cup final we lost against Chelsea as a particular example, as well as basically Mourinho getting the better of him for a sustained period when he arrived in England. I think that was a game changer for SAF. In the cup final, I mean, I think it was probably an eye opener, the extent to which Mourinho was willing to shut that game down in order to win it. SAF's instincts would not lead him to make that decision, but I think he learned the lesson, or adapted / evolved with the changing times, learning this was something he may need to do now, to win.

I think Mourinho is different, in that I think his instinctive response to risk is caution. He has probably learned over the years the merits of attacking with abandon, of throwing caution to the wind - though I dont think he will necessarily feel the benefits of that approach justify a complete change of approach for him. His default setting is to play it safe, wait and see, give nothing away and wait for opportunities. He can throw caution to the wind when he perceives the risk to be small, for example when he is confident of his team's superiority on the pitch, liberating him from the need to nullify his opponents, or mitigate the perceived risks.

That for me is the essence - or at least part of the essence of the difference between the two managers. They share that pragmaticism as I said, the use of mindgames as one of the key weapons in their managerial arsenal, an ability to bond with their players in a way that resembles a family connection and many other traits that have often been discussed. I think there are some differences in terms of ability to be humble and to be generous with praise for opponents, which SAF seemed to have more than Mourinho, but I dont know how fundamental that is to who they are as managers. I think the key difference is their instincts, which are arguably diametrically opposed. I think that is why, despite them sharing aspects of their approach (counter attacking etc) and Mourinho having excellent, free scoring attacking teams, and SAF presiding over some very pedestrian championship-winning teams, they are still associated with different types of team: Mourinho with "parking the bus" and SAF with "playing football the right / the United way." It wasnt always true, but perhaps it is consistent with their instinctive approach to the game. Both have learned to approach the game in a more sophisticated way than to merely follow their instincts. In a way they have started in different places and moved towards each other, so the actual end product is far more similar than they look "under the hood" so to speak.

I dont know how right any of this is, it all made a lot of sense when I was stoned.
 
Last edited:

clarkydaz

Full Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2013
Messages
13,498
Location
manchester
Just go on the SSN app and the top story is Mourinho and Charlton meeting.

Skys Mourinho bum fest is brilliant. I bet it is really pissing off rival fans :lol:
last week Alan Brazil on talksport, was saying the eye gouge was blown way out of proportion and people need to get over it, it wasn't that bad. Nearly crashed the car!
 

#07

makes new threads with tweets in the OP
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
23,421

0161_UNITED

Full Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2010
Messages
1,771
Ive been thinking a lot about the similarities between Mourinho and SAF in the last few days, especially after Mockney's excellent post in the other (now closed) Mourinho thread last week.

The starting off point is complete agreement (the thesis in a nutshell being, for anyone that missed it, that Mourinho is the closest thing there is in football today to SAF, in terms of mind games, pragmaticism and the determination to win superseding all other considerations - among other things.)

But I have been thinking about what the key differences are. I think in a way they are more interesting, because, to be honest, the similarities are more obvious. And I have decided what it comes down to more than anything else is their respective attitudes to risk. SAF "learned" pragmaticism, I think. No, I think he was always pragmatic to a certain extent but I think he learned over time, and especially in certain situations (like the CL), that he needed to curb his instincts in order to be successful - to be more pragmatic than he had been in the past. I think his instinct was to attack. I dont think it is necessarily about entertainment per se, tho Im sure he wanted to entertain. I think it is more what I said previously - the attitude to risk.

I think when SAF was faced with a challenge his instinct was to attack it. He understood in certain situations you needed to stay your hand, and I think the older he got the more his head ruled his heart, if you want to put it that way: he understood on a logical or intellectual level the merits of a more cagey, pragmatic approach, and he defaulted to it more and more. As you get older it is easier, I think, for your head to rule your heart, you become less impulsive and more measured. I think this is what happened with SAF. And I think actually the younger man, Mourinho, played a role in teaching him that lesson - as did many years of disappointment in the CL. I am thinking of the FA Cup final we lost against Chelsea as a particular example, as well as basically Mourinho getting the better of him for a sustained period when he arrived in England. I think that was a game changer for SAF. In the cup final, I mean, I think it was probably an eye opener, the extent to which Mourinho was willing to shut that game down in order to win it. SAF's instincts would not lead him to make that decision, but I think he learned the lesson, or adapted / evolved with the changing times, learning this was something he may need to do now, to win.

I think Mourinho is different, in that I think his instinctive response to risk is caution. He has probably learned over the years the merits of attacking with abandon, of throwing caution to the wind - though I dont think he will necessarily feel the benefits of that approach justify a complete change of approach for him. His default setting is to play it safe, wait and see, give nothing away and wait for opportunities. He can throw caution to the wind when he perceives the risk to be small, for example when he is confident of his team's superiority on the pitch, liberating him from the need to nullify his opponents, or mitigate the perceived risks.

That for me is the essence - or at least part of the essence of the difference between the two managers. They share that pragmaticism as I said, the use of mindgames as one of the key weapons in their managerial arsenal, an ability to bond with their players in a way that resembles a family connection and many other traits that have often been discussed. I think there are some differences in terms of ability to be humble and to be generous with praise for opponents, which SAF seemed to have more than Mourinho, but I dont know how fundamental that is to who they are as managers. I think the key difference is their instincts, which are arguably diametrically opposed. I think that is why, despite them sharing aspects of their approach (counter attacking etc) and Mourinho having excellent, free scoring attacking teams, and SAF presiding over some very pedestrian championship-winning teams, they are still associated with different types of team: Mourinho with "parking the bus" and SAF with "playing football the right / the United way." It wasnt always true, but perhaps it is consistent with their instinctive approach to the game. Both have learned to approach the game in a more sophisticated way than to merely follow their instincts. In a way they have started in different places and moved towards each other, so the actual end product is far more similar than they look "under the hood" so to speak.

I dont know how right any of this is, it all made a lot of sense when I was stoned.
An interesting and well thought out post, I wish @Mockney post was still available to reply to as well.

Overall, I agree, in terms of similarities. There is so much revisionist history as well involved. People want to trace the heritage of the club from Busby to Ferguson framed in a tradition of "attacking football". Some don't have the slightest inkling about Busby's football. I certainly don't, besides a few old videos of Georgie Best. What I do remember is the very end of Big Ron and the beginning of SAF from there on. I do remember Nicky Butt (Legend) shutting people down in '99 and playing what purists would call the purest of anti-football. And loving every minute of it. He was inspired in '99.

Yes, I want attractive, attacking football. But I also remember some of our most attractive, attacking football falling a bit short too (Leverkeusen in the CL, Cantona's final season IIRC) when Christ I wished we'd just learned to shut matches down and advance at all costs.

It's all relative, but I can see the similarities, and the differences, in SAF and Mourinho. It has nothing to do with the history we've had. It's to do with the history we'll make.
 
Last edited:

K2K

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
18,367
Location
"Can Manchester United score? They always score"
Yep, he gave a lecture in Portugal's most important Sports related University. He also had in the end, an improvised interview with some members of the portuguese media and the most interesting soundbyte is that he isn't going to buy any player from the portuguese league. That should "kill" the rumours from portuguese league based players.
Aren't they any good talents from the Portuguese league that would be a good signing for United?

Perhaps not right away,but over time.
 

DenisIrwin

New Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
2,337
I have my doubts about Jose's sanity. Rumours that we have offered Carrick an extension and plan to let Blind and Mata go increase those doubts.
 

Bojan11

Full Member
Joined
May 16, 2010
Messages
33,115
I have my doubts about Jose's sanity. Rumours that we have offered Carrick an extension and plan to let Blind and Mata go increase those doubts.
Yes, like Blind and Mata are world class players who can't be replaced.

We'd have no problems replacing the above two.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.