Brexited | the worst threads live the longest

Do you think there will be a Deal or No Deal?


  • Total voters
    194
  • Poll closed .

That'sHernandez

Ominously close to getting banned
Joined
Oct 30, 2010
Messages
24,571
Ah, The agonies of a local Labour MP in a leave constituency. But also a marginal constituency.

MP claims he is not against Brexit, but votes against it every single time because his primary concern is jobs.

His local Labour council want to build another 20k houses, 8k on green belt. Also lots more new warehouses on green belt for additional jobs needed due to expansion.

He seems to be against that, which is also my own position.

Talk about wanting it both ways.

:lol:
In many ways Harold Shipman was acting out of civic duty.
 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,386
Location
Birmingham
Brexiteers have found another scapegoat...the queen.
 

Damien

Self-Aware RedCafe Database (and Admin)
Staff
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
97,229
Location
Also won Best Gif/Photoshop 2021
Because the scouts promote posters they like and will generally like posters with similar views to their own. Because they're human.
Political alignment doesn't really come into it on the promotion side. Most of the time we don't even know if someone is left/right wing because they only comment on football related stuff and we generally don't go trawling through their post histories before giving a like. If we were against anyone right wing, Colin and Erica wouldn't be here today.

A lot of forums don't have a newbie system but they do have a 'swing' one way or the other

RedCafe
Poll
Remain: 73.8% (482 votes)
Leave: 26.2% (171 votes)

The Liverpool Way (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 80.7% (222 votes)
Leave: 19.3% (53 votes)

Red and White Kop (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 66.5% (574 votes)
Leave: 16% (138 votes)
Don't know: 7.9% (68 votes)
Not voting: 9.6% (83 votes)

Grand Old Team (Everton fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 64.6% (512 votes)
Leave: 35.4% (280 votes)

Wearside Online (Sunderland fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 11% (4 votes)
Leave: 74% (26 votes)
Don't know: 14% (5 votes)

Onefootball (UK football forum)
Poll
Remain: 64% (112 votes)
Leave: 36% (63 votes)

Digital Spy (Entertainment forum)
Pre-vote
Remain: 36% (431 votes)
Leave: 63% (761 votes)

Exit poll
Remain: 26% (85 votes)
Leave: 73% (241 votes)

These are the closest:

Bluemoon (Man City fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 47.9% (503 votes)
Leave: 52.1% (547 votes)

Football Forums
Poll
Remain: 47% (55 votes)
Leave: 53% (62 votes)
 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,386
Location
Birmingham
I'm interested to see what reason she's going to give to warrant an extension. I have this image of the other 27 leaders in chorus singing "We don't believe you!"
Brexiteers already making it clear any agreement is toast once they knife her.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,228
I don't think the EU should keep giving extensions. What is agreed for once should be followed through. Otherwise this could keep going on ad infinitum.
 

Massive Spanner

Give Mason Mount a chance!
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,180
Location
Tool shed
Political alignment doesn't really come into it on the promotion side. Most of the time we don't even know if someone is left/right wing because they only comment on football related stuff and we generally don't go trawling through their post histories before giving a like. If we were against anyone right wing, Colin and Erica wouldn't be here today.

A lot of forums don't have a newbie system but they do have a 'swing' one way or the other

RedCafe
Poll
Remain: 73.8% (482 votes)
Leave: 26.2% (171 votes)

The Liverpool Way (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 80.7% (222 votes)
Leave: 19.3% (53 votes)

Red and White Kop (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 66.5% (574 votes)
Leave: 16% (138 votes)
Don't know: 7.9% (68 votes)
Not voting: 9.6% (83 votes)

Grand Old Team (Everton fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 64.6% (512 votes)
Leave: 35.4% (280 votes)

Wearside Online (Sunderland fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 11% (4 votes)
Leave: 74% (26 votes)
Don't know: 14% (5 votes)

Onefootball (UK football forum)
Poll
Remain: 64% (112 votes)
Leave: 36% (63 votes)

Digital Spy (Entertainment forum)
Pre-vote
Remain: 36% (431 votes)
Leave: 63% (761 votes)

Exit poll
Remain: 26% (85 votes)
Leave: 73% (241 votes)

These are the closest:

Bluemoon (Man City fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 47.9% (503 votes)
Leave: 52.1% (547 votes)

Football Forums
Poll
Remain: 47% (55 votes)
Leave: 53% (62 votes)
Jesus Christ, the Sunderland one :lol:
 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,386
Location
Birmingham
I don't think the EU should keep giving extensions. What is agreed for once should be followed through. Otherwise this could keep going on ad infinitum.
For me, I think the key are the elections. If we participate in those, the chances of brexit happening diminish significantly. Personally think May is trying to delay as much as possible until it's really her deal or no deal.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,228
For me, I think the key are the elections. If we participate in those, the chances of brexit happening diminish significantly. Personally think May is trying to delay as much as possible until it's really her deal or no deal.
I am not sure what type of botched elections will transpire if we reach that point. Attempts for Tory sabotage of those elections seem likely.
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,422
Location
left wing
I don't think the EU should keep giving extensions. What is agreed for once should be followed through. Otherwise this could keep going on ad infinitum.
Ireland, Netherlands, Belgium, Denmark and Germany are expected to be the worst effected economically by a no deal Brexit (after the UK, of course). The German economy looks to be going into recession (and German manufacturing is already in recession) - I imagine they might all be quite keen on a long extension to A50 to prevent serious damage.

France, Italy and Spain, perhaps less so, as they are less exposed, and might therefore require some real persuasion to continue with this farce any longer.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
Brexiteers already making it clear any agreement is toast once they knife her.
I think they're overplaying their hand... again.

Firstly if the WA agreement gets signed by the UK and EU it's not a national law, but an international one. Which means future parliaments are bound by it. The political declaration is not, but it means little if they are already bound by the constraints of the WA.

But more importantly, by loudly proclaiming they will not abide by the political declaration all they are really saying to Labour and Corbyn is "you better push for a 2nd ref because all you agree in is pointless anyway". Which suits me, if we get our second vote.

Labour just need to pull their finger out and coalesce around that. They can't change the WA agreement anyway and that's the only binding legal document.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
I don't think the EU should keep giving extensions. What is agreed for once should be followed through. Otherwise this could keep going on ad infinitum.
They (EU) don't want a Brexit, obviously. And the longer this gets delayed the more likely it is to head for a 2nd ref or revocation. Why would they not, bedgrudingly, grant them so long as the UK is requesting them?

There is indeed a massive hassle in keeping this charade going, but putting the breaks on extensions and forcing a no-deal brexit would be political suicide for a lot of those EU27 leaders. Any crisis, political or economical, that ensues from no deal Brexit within their borders they'll be held responsible for by their electorate.

Macron is acting tough, but France GDP growth is like 0.2% per quarter, it has near 100% debt and the country's budget is running on a widening deficit above the EU's accepted 3%. If France takes a financial hit from this, he starts imposing taxes in response, the yellow vests are out on the streets again.... he will be as weak as. It's not in his interest either. He's acting a bit like a populist atm, but he'll back down when the chips are down.
 

Sassy Colin

Death or the gladioli!
Joined
Jan 29, 2010
Messages
71,081
Location
Aliens are in control of my tagline & location
Political alignment doesn't really come into it on the promotion side. Most of the time we don't even know if someone is left/right wing because they only comment on football related stuff and we generally don't go trawling through their post histories before giving a like. If we were against anyone right wing, Colin and Erica wouldn't be here today.

A lot of forums don't have a newbie system but they do have a 'swing' one way or the other

RedCafe
Poll
Remain: 73.8% (482 votes)
Leave: 26.2% (171 votes)

The Liverpool Way (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 80.7% (222 votes)
Leave: 19.3% (53 votes)

Red and White Kop (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 66.5% (574 votes)
Leave: 16% (138 votes)
Don't know: 7.9% (68 votes)
Not voting: 9.6% (83 votes)

Grand Old Team (Everton fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 64.6% (512 votes)
Leave: 35.4% (280 votes)

Wearside Online (Sunderland fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 11% (4 votes)
Leave: 74% (26 votes)
Don't know: 14% (5 votes)

Onefootball (UK football forum)
Poll
Remain: 64% (112 votes)
Leave: 36% (63 votes)

Digital Spy (Entertainment forum)
Pre-vote
Remain: 36% (431 votes)
Leave: 63% (761 votes)

Exit poll
Remain: 26% (85 votes)
Leave: 73% (241 votes)

These are the closest:

Bluemoon (Man City fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 47.9% (503 votes)
Leave: 52.1% (547 votes)

Football Forums
Poll
Remain: 47% (55 votes)
Leave: 53% (62 votes)
I'm not even that right wing, I just can't stand Socialism. :)
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,228
That's the idea.
To
They (EU) don't want a Brexit, obviously. And the longer this gets delayed the more likely it is to head for a 2nd ref or revocation. Why would they not, bedgrudingly, grant them so long as the UK is requesting them?

There is indeed a massive hassle in keeping this charade going, but putting the breaks on extensions and forcing a no-deal brexit would be political suicide for a lot of those EU27 leaders. Any crisis, political or economical, that ensues from no deal Brexit within their borders they'll be held responsible for by their electorate.

Macron is acting tough, but France GDP growth is like 0.2% per quarter, it has near 100% debt and the country's budget is running on a widening deficit above the EU's accepted 3%. If France takes a financial hit from this, he starts imposing taxes in response, the yellow vests are out on the streets again.... he will be as weak as. It's not in his interest either. He's acting a bit like a populist atm, but he'll back down when the chips are down.
Nobody sane wants Brexit. But this issue needs to be closed at some point. Far too much time spend on both sides doing pointless discussions. Unpleasant certainty is better than uncertainty.
 

Josep Dowling

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
7,659
Hypocrisy isn't involved here. He basically said that he has the right to tell you something politely, he didn't say that he doesn't have the right to not be polite.
Doesn't that go against the CAF rules of respecting other members? I will remember that one next time I want to insult someone on here. Provided I put:

PS Fecking moron, at the end of my post I can mitigate myself of being banned.
 

Zlatattack

New Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Messages
7,374
So - it seems like instead of diving head first into oblivion we're stumbling into it, hitting every ledge on the way down.
 

afrocentricity

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
27,080
Doesn't that go against the CAF rules of respecting other members? I will remember that one next time I want to insult someone on here.
Could you imagine how different this place would be if we were all polite to each other? How long have you been here? :confused:

Sounds like you're looking for a safe space....
 

RK

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2008
Messages
16,103
Location
Attacking Midfield
Political alignment doesn't really come into it on the promotion side. Most of the time we don't even know if someone is left/right wing because they only comment on football related stuff and we generally don't go trawling through their post histories before giving a like. If we were against anyone right wing, Colin and Erica wouldn't be here today.

A lot of forums don't have a newbie system but they do have a 'swing' one way or the other

RedCafe
Poll
Remain: 73.8% (482 votes)
Leave: 26.2% (171 votes)

The Liverpool Way (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 80.7% (222 votes)
Leave: 19.3% (53 votes)

Red and White Kop (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 66.5% (574 votes)
Leave: 16% (138 votes)
Don't know: 7.9% (68 votes)
Not voting: 9.6% (83 votes)

Grand Old Team (Everton fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 64.6% (512 votes)
Leave: 35.4% (280 votes)

Wearside Online (Sunderland fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 11% (4 votes)
Leave: 74% (26 votes)
Don't know: 14% (5 votes)

Onefootball (UK football forum)
Poll
Remain: 64% (112 votes)
Leave: 36% (63 votes)

Digital Spy (Entertainment forum)
Pre-vote
Remain: 36% (431 votes)
Leave: 63% (761 votes)

Exit poll
Remain: 26% (85 votes)
Leave: 73% (241 votes)

These are the closest:

Bluemoon (Man City fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 47.9% (503 votes)
Leave: 52.1% (547 votes)

Football Forums
Poll
Remain: 47% (55 votes)
Leave: 53% (62 votes)
Cheers Damo, interesting figures.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,228
I don’t know where you read that, but there’s a near infinite number of scenarios where this isn’t true. I believe Brexit is one of them.
I was referring strictly to Brexit. I am not sure your sentiment is shared by the CEOs of various multinationals that have operations in the UK or conduct business with companies within the UK . Brexit has rendered long term planning useless.
 

Minimalist

New Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
15,091
We’ve decided to keep this Brexit process going, for another FIFTY cycles!

With endless options for renewal...
...endless options for renewal...
...endless options for renewal...
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,928
Location
France
Doesn't that go against the CAF rules of respecting other members? I will remember that one next time I want to insult someone on here. Provided I put:

PS Fecking moron, at the end of my post I can mitigate myself of being banned.
You do what you want but the post that you quoted had nothing hypocrite about it, he didn't ask you to be polite. He simply pointed to the fact that you are not going to prevent people from politely discussing your posts.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
I was referring strictly to Brexit. I am not sure your sentiment is shared by the CEOs of various multinationals that have operations in the UK or conduct business with companies within the UK . Brexit has rendered long term planning useless.
Multinationals will adapt anyway. But for other, national and smaller businesses who's model is not viable without a deal and access to the single market.... any delay is stay of execution.

It's not as clear cut as you make it sound. Uncertainty is nerve wracking, but there's no relief in knowing you're doomed either.
 

Maticmaker

Full Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2018
Messages
4,695
If the UK wants to stop no-deal, it can, by revoking article 50.
Barnier has been saying this almost from day one, he knows that the binary choice option posed in the referendum never goes away, you either remain (revoke A50) or you leave with no deal, its simples. The EU cannot and will not give the UK a 'good deal' (in UK's terminology), until it leaves the EU. No matter how many extensions are given and how many times we go round the mulberry bush, the answer is always the same!

The only point at which Barnier is IMO being naïve, is if he thinks in the context of a 'no deal' situation the UK is going to stomp up the £39B before the trade deal is done, "nothings agreed until everything is agreed" also remains a truism!
 

Shinjch

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
1,333
Barnier has been saying this almost from day one, he knows that the binary choice option posed in the referendum never goes away, you either remain (revoke A50) or you leave with no deal, its simples. The EU cannot and will not give the UK a 'good deal' (in UK's terminology), until it leaves the EU. No matter how many extensions are given and how many times we go round the mulberry bush, the answer is always the same!

The only point at which Barnier is IMO being naïve, is if he thinks in the context of a 'no deal' situation the UK is going to stomp up the £39B before the trade deal is done, "nothings agreed until everything is agreed" also remains a truism!
The UK are hardly going to be in any position of strength when negotiating a future trade deal after crashing out though. Quite the opposite.
 

RochaRoja

Full Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
1,567
Political alignment doesn't really come into it on the promotion side. Most of the time we don't even know if someone is left/right wing because they only comment on football related stuff and we generally don't go trawling through their post histories before giving a like. If we were against anyone right wing, Colin and Erica wouldn't be here today.

A lot of forums don't have a newbie system but they do have a 'swing' one way or the other

RedCafe
Poll
Remain: 73.8% (482 votes)
Leave: 26.2% (171 votes)

The Liverpool Way (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 80.7% (222 votes)
Leave: 19.3% (53 votes)

Red and White Kop (Liverpool FC fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 66.5% (574 votes)
Leave: 16% (138 votes)
Don't know: 7.9% (68 votes)
Not voting: 9.6% (83 votes)

Grand Old Team (Everton fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 64.6% (512 votes)
Leave: 35.4% (280 votes)

Wearside Online (Sunderland fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 11% (4 votes)
Leave: 74% (26 votes)
Don't know: 14% (5 votes)

Onefootball (UK football forum)
Poll
Remain: 64% (112 votes)
Leave: 36% (63 votes)

Digital Spy (Entertainment forum)
Pre-vote
Remain: 36% (431 votes)
Leave: 63% (761 votes)

Exit poll
Remain: 26% (85 votes)
Leave: 73% (241 votes)

These are the closest:

Bluemoon (Man City fan forum)
Poll
Remain: 47.9% (503 votes)
Leave: 52.1% (547 votes)

Football Forums
Poll
Remain: 47% (55 votes)
Leave: 53% (62 votes)
Nuke Sunderland imo.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,228
Multinationals will adapt anyway. But for other, national and smaller businesses who's model is not viable without a deal and access to the single market.... any delay is stay of execution.

It's not as clear cut as you make it sound. Uncertainty is nerve wracking, but there's no relief in knowing you're doomed either.
I don't see how this can help even smaller businesses . If you have to pivot or altogether shutdown your company and look for a job, you still need time . Same for your employees.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
I don't see how this can help even smaller businesses . If you have to pivot or altogether shutdown your company and look for a job, you still need time . Same for your employees.
Because you might not have to shut down if a deal is ultimately agreed. Hence uncertainty, while highly undesireable, is better than certain catastrophy.
 

Maticmaker

Full Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2018
Messages
4,695
he UK are hardly going to be in any position of strength when negotiating a future trade deal after crashing out though. Quite the opposite.
And they are in a position of strength now, are they??

That's why the revocation of A50 is the most likely outcome, and always has been. The Will of the people never stood a chance and never has done in the history of the UK, we are after all legally subjects of the Crown, not citizens. Revoking A50 means there will be no further referendums, no more extensions and no more continuing uncertainty, except of course in the internal Politics of the UK and within the EU itself. In the UK almost every MP will be in danger of being, deselected, losing their majority, or being sent to the Tower at the next GE.
 

Shinjch

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
1,333
And they are in a position of strength now, are they??

That's why the revocation of A50 is the most likely outcome, and always has been. The Will of the people never stood a chance and never has done in the history of the UK, we are after all legally subjects of the Crown, not citizens. Revoking A50 means there will be no further referendums, no more extensions and no more continuing uncertainty, except of course in the internal Politics of the UK and within the EU itself. In the UK almost every MP will be in danger of being, deselected, losing their majority, or being sent to the Tower at the next GE.
I was talking relatively to accepting the Withdrawal Agreement.

Revocation is the least likely outcome in my opinion, unless it is due to a people's vote. Which I also consider unlikely at the moment.
 

Paul the Wolf

Full Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
17,820
Location
France - can't win anything with Swedish turnips
Barnier has been saying this almost from day one, he knows that the binary choice option posed in the referendum never goes away, you either remain (revoke A50) or you leave with no deal, its simples. The EU cannot and will not give the UK a 'good deal' (in UK's terminology), until it leaves the EU. No matter how many extensions are given and how many times we go round the mulberry bush, the answer is always the same!

The only point at which Barnier is IMO being naïve, is if he thinks in the context of a 'no deal' situation the UK is going to stomp up the £39B before the trade deal is done, "nothings agreed until everything is agreed" also remains a truism!
I'm not sure what a good deal is supposed to be in the UK's eyes. If it is what Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn have been wanting which is picking off a menu and not adhering to the fundamentals of the EU or paying for it, it's ridiculous

The £39bn is another red herring. The Uk have to pay for what they owe which will be less if they leave with no deal because they wouldn't have to pay for the transition period.
The withdrawal agreement is mainly about paying what they owe, respecting people's rights and not breaking the GFA.
Unless people are determined to stop Brexit there's no reason not to vote for it.

I don't believe May has got the guts to revoke A50.

Where I think the EU is being naïve is that they somehow still have faith that the UK will ever come to an agreement between themselves.
 

Smores

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
25,532
Doesn't that go against the CAF rules of respecting other members? I will remember that one next time I want to insult someone on here. Provided I put:

PS Fecking moron, at the end of my post I can mitigate myself of being banned.
Feck in hell it was a tongue in cheek bolt on because of how triggered you were being :lol:

If you're offended by being called a snowflake then god help ya, can't say i care either way