Had the Nazis won, the 2-3 million killed in the Bengal famine would be a rounding error.
Protests following the killing of George Floyd
- Thread starter Abizzz
- Start date
Had the Nazis won, the 2-3 million killed in the Bengal famine would be a rounding error.
Who pretending? If you read about him, you know what he is about. If people want to dislike him thats fine.
But again if you read what I quoting it was questioning whether people should actually take a negative opinion of him and I was pointing out the trade off.
I was specifically thinking of Farage's tweet there. Though in fairness his response was entirely on brand.
The vast majority of people have enough cop on not to be bothered alright.
the legacy of Colston and his name continuing to be used in Bristol has been contested for a long time now. I don’t know anyone in Bristol who would not want to get rid of that statue. They have been consulting on a name change for Colston Hall for a few years - this will undoubtedly speed up that process.
In January 2019, I went to Liverpool specifically to visit the Transatlantic Slave Trade Museum. They showed at least 10 roads named after slave traders that exist in Liverpool till this very day.
One of those being 'Penny Lane' which was named after James Penny who went on eleven voyages as a captain in the slave trade, a vocal advocate for the slave trade at the Parliamentary Enquiry. There was even a trophy/cup which was given to him as a reward for his efforts.
I spoke with a guest at the museum. Naturally, I asked if I could offer any assistance in getting them off. They told me that they have had countless petitions signed over the years, and were told that the views of those who don't live on the road were of no importance.
I can definitely see those street names being damaged in the upcoming days
Yeah I'd have thought he'd have something to say about it.
Does it matter?
And it's exactly why Drew Brees got backlash. No one cares if he doesn't kneel for the anthem for whatever reason. Don't deflect a question about BLM to that. He was just showing that he completely misunderstood the entire point of BLM and Colin Kaepernick's protest.
not to me. But it does to some of the posters on this thread.
I don’t get this argument. No one is disputing what he did for the freedoms we currently enjoy. But why is this being used to stopping just short of half justifying the deaths of millions?
Why is it a game of absolutes, one or the other: a hero for freedom or vile racist drunk murderer of millions.
Every nation should own their own history.
Winston Churchill was fundamentally racist and revelled in his power to exert white supremacy over people of colour.
This should be pointed out every time other contributions he made are talked about.
Nobody said it. I said what do you suggest we do. Pull down his statue, regarding a poster saying Churchill was a racist, and killed millions.
Well it’s quite a jump to make considering the original conversation was about education. Educating people of the facts.
What's with this Anthony Joshua video doing the rounds? Is it real or dubbed over?
Again, tell it to the Russians and change their hearts and minds, he's their hero.
There is no leader in history that is squeaky clean. This generation might be wanting to have statues of Obama put up, but you tell that to the people of Iraq and Afghanistan whos land and lives became a experiment for drone technology bombs
That'll give her a great funding boost
The original post was suggesting Churchill should be viewed negatively overall in the UK.
He did some bad things (and unlike the Nazis, his level of blame in them is debatable) but we rightly view him as a hero because of the good he did.
That's only because Churchills racist acts have been whitewashed out of officially taught British history. They are arguably as heinous as Hitler's.
Also the way history is taught evolves over time. I can foresee a time when Churchill's racist acts are front and centre and he will be vilified.
Good reminder that decolonization is a long overdue but eventual process. It is sad that it takes a protest of this level to even recognize it. Let alone address it on a fundamental level.
Last edited:
That’s fair enough, but just like 99% of other historical figures, people are complex multi-faceted people and simply acknowledging that he literally let people die of starvations cos brown lives didn’t matter as much as white (not debatable btw) - doesn’t need to challenge the great things he actually achieved. Nuance and that, right?
You are only looking at this purely through an English and Rule Britannia point of view. Again, assuming your lived experience is superior to the majority on this planet.That's amongst the most ridiculous things I have ever read
How many people did Churchills decisions kill? How many people in the world utterly despise his acts vs the Brits/Euro's that think he is great?
Definitely. If anyone wants a definition of white privilege, it’s all the people arguing that it was out of order. Just imagine having to walk past that every day as a black person, knowing that it was put there as a celebration of a slave trader. History can be learnt in museums and booksand maybe if the council had listened earlier, it wouldn’t have come to this.
The rhetoric being taken by the right at the moment is really dangerous. I can fully understand people’s frustrations at the social distancing, however bar London, the vast majority of protests were observed with masks and some kind of distancing (maybe not 2m, but this rule has been ignored by so in parks and beaches). Yet they are all being made out to be some kind of aggressive act, even in London it was a very small part of the overall protest.
Candace Owens is a liar and a grifter. Her opinions are worthless.
I hope the Bristol acts inspires people all around the world to remove or vandalise any symbols that glorify people involved in slavery.
Would be a good first step forward.
Yeah, I'm not. I'm looking at them through a rational and sensible point of view.
Hitler literally loaded people into gas chambers and exterminated them, and you think Churchill was on par with that.
She's also a rent-a-mouth. She will advocate any position as long as you pay her.
Grifters gotta grift.
Figuratively. And I'm defending Hitler.
Churchill's actions were for a large part despicable even though he didn't reach Hitler or Stalin level.
So you own what is rational and sensible? Can I see your certification and qualifications for that? Keep digging that hole.
Yeah I think dying over a period of weeks of starvation, watching all those you love go through the same is perhaps the most tortous and horrific way to die. Millions and millions. A sentence imposed upon you after a few minutes of thinking from Churchill. That’s all those lives were worth.
And that’s just the Bengal famine. There are many other slightly less obvious examples. And just because you are not white.
feck me it's hard to keep track of all the racists now. Luckily we have plenty of self-righteous experts to point them out.
Was that what the statue was celebrating? Wasn't it for the other stuff he had done for the city of Bristol?
Yeah its not ideal he was a slave trader, but those were different times so kinda understandable why he had a statue.
Obviously it could have been taken down much sooner (same way they remove honours from pedos and criminals), they could easily remove statues and put into museums, they shouldn't be destroyed tbh. I barely even notice statues when I'm walking about, there's a couple in my town, feck knows who they are, well I know who Andy Capp is.
People are going on like the statue was there with a big sign on saying "best slave trader ever! What a guy!"
There’s long been talk of that Statue being removed. In that area you also have the Colston Hall, Colton Tower and a bit further up you also have Colston Arms Pub, all of which there has been a campaign to rename. It’s very fitting that the stature came down in such a symbolic way though with echoes of Saddam.
'He did some bad things' is quite the understatement. Also, how do you suggest his level of blame is debatable in those acts, while also giving him full credit for beatings the Nazis?
How the hell does a thread about BLM protests become an argument of whether Churchill was as bad as Hitler and Stalin?!? 
Time to log off for the night...
Time to log off for the night...
Candace is to normal, intelligent black people what Trump is to normal, intelligent Americans. An affront.
How the hell does a thread about BLM protests become an argument of whether Churchill was as bad as Hitler and Stalin?!?
Time to log off for the night...
Redcafe gonna redcafe.