10
You take him out the team now and we suffer as a team.Needs to be taken out the team. No player should play without consequence.
How can you be sure? Pretty sure everyone was saying that about Kane.You take him out the team now and we suffer as a team.
Because whenhe decides to actually start playing he's still the only one who makes things happen.How can you be sure? Pretty sure everyone was saying that about Kane.
I've heard this before, it's an actual meme "where will the goals come from", such a silly way at looking at things.Because whenhe decides to actually start playing he's still the only one who makes things happen.
And his potential replacement isn't ready and unfortunately has the same problems.
How had football moved on? Not every team has to play the same way.Great pace, can shoot, good at running at opposition. But when the game slows, he is not a good enough footballer to play the right pass like Sane did tonight.
Would have been a great player if he could go back 10 years, but football has moved on. Defensively, he is useless.
Could actually see him perform well in a 442 system with a suitable strike partner to link withIn the era of 4-4-2 what would Rashford be because he’s not good enough to be a striker, a winger or a wide midfielder. I wish his role at United was same as England as an impact sub but unfortunately he’s our main goal threat
Worry about yes. Also target his wing.Truth is, I bet he is the player every team that plays us worries about the most. Lazy or not..
Every good team defends from the front. Show me one that doesn't do it well that has won a major trophy in recent years.How had football moved on? Not every team has to play the same way.
Rashford is like someone who's spent years memorizing how to play Master of Puppets but doesn't know what a scale or chord progression are.I'm not sure it's any one thing in particular but when you see him against truly top class players the gulf in self-evident. There's just so much missing from his game. A depth, perhaps. The difference between someone who can play an instrument beautifully and someone who can hit some of the notes occasionally.
It's hard to explain but there's just so much of Rashford's game that simply isn't.... there.
I think so. He can do his one thing if he has a favouring wind on the day. But as an overall player, I'm sorry I think he's by far the weakest in the side. Even if we want to avoid talking about workrate and pressing. He's made redundant via a simply tactical instruction to slow the pace of the game down. Because he can't do it. And so much else.Rashford is like someone who's spent years memorizing how to play Master of Puppets but doesn't know what a scale or chord progression are.
The puzzling thing about Rashford to me is that he doesn't seem to have progressed his game since he broke through under LVG. He's still rapid, got a good shot, and is decent at dribbling but he's still poor in the air, one footed, poor off the ball, and he still makes bad decisions too regularly!I think so. He can do his one thing if he has a favouring wind on the day. But as an overall player, I'm sorry I think he's by far the weakest in the side. Even if we want to avoid talking about workrate and pressing. He's made redundant via a simply tactical instruction to slow the pace of the game down. Because he can't do it. And so much else.
I disagree, Garnacho did more in his 20 minutes.You take him out the team now and we suffer as a team.
He did and gassed himself out doing soI thought he tracked back far better last night. Worked harder than he has done all season.
Yep. His stamina is awful.He did and gassed himself out doing so
People mistake that with laziness but I honestly believe our players have poor staminaHe did and gassed himself out doing so
Scored some very good headers and left footed goals last season. Which were factors in him scoring more goals than he ever scored before. So weird timing to be talking about him having not progressed.The puzzling thing about Rashford to me is that he doesn't seem to have progressed his game since he broke through under LVG. He's still rapid, got a good shot, and is decent at dribbling but he's still poor in the air, one footed, poor off the ball, and he still makes bad decisions too regularly!
He's 25 now so this is probably the player he'll be for the rest of his career until he loses pace.
I could be wrong. I'll watch last seasons highlights.Scored some very good headers and left footed goals last season. Which were factors in him scoring more goals than he ever scored before. So weird timing to be talking about him having not progressed.
Scoring with his head and left foot. He’s also a lot stronger and harder to knock off the ball (which you’ll see helps him score a few of those goals when you watch the season highlights!)I could be wrong. I'll watch last seasons highlights.
What areas would you say Rashford has progressed in since his debut season?
I'm halfway through the official Man Utd youtube video of Rashford's 30 goals. So far he's scored 15. Two of those goals were from his head. One was from his weak foot. That's not good enough.Scoring with his head and left foot. He’s also a lot stronger and harder to knock off the ball (which you’ll see helps him score a few of those goals when you watch the season highlights!)
I don’t care what you do or don’t consider good enough. You’re arguing he hasn’t progressed or improved. All that matters is in that context is whether or not it’s an improvement on previous seasons.I'm halfway throught the official Man Utd youtube video of Rashford's 30 goals. So far he's scored 15. Two of those goals were from his head. One was from his weak foot. That's not good enough.
Edit: the weak foot goal was a tap in under no pressure.
OK, fair arguments. I'll admit I could be wrong but show me the evidence.I don’t care what you do or don’t consider good enough. You’re arguing he hasn’t progressed or improved. All that matters is in that context is whether or not it’s an improvement on previous seasons.
You may also want to consider the total number of goals you’re about to watch when deciding if he’s a better player now than he was in the past…
This is the Rashford issue.He was definitely better with his head last season. Just like pressing and tracking back it's one of those things he only really does if his mercurial temperament allows.
Arguably this is the most frustrating thing, as even if you subscribe to the theory he's technically limited as a player - as I obviously do - he could still press, run and track back. Yet he only does so on occasion when he feels like it.
Something I've criticised him for, I just don't think he's that "fire in the belly" type of player. Which is what I think separates him from the likes of Vini and Mbappe, those 2 seem to have a fire and desire to impact a game whereas Rashford just seems to wait for the game to come to him.I'd like to see more fire from him.
Playing too cool for my liking, but no one is playing well at the moment unfortunately.
I think its more how hes being asked to track. Hes basically covering the ball in the middle and also tracking the fullback at the same time. Which means hes usually full sprint to get back to the fullback. Its just not effcient at all. Of course better stamina also helpsPeople mistake that with laziness but I honestly believe our players have poor stamina
Just not true though is it? And the one decent chance Garnacho had where he fluffed it(albeit a hard one so no hard feelings there) was created by Rashford.I disagree, Garnacho did more in his 20 minutes.
Because they've been coasting for far too long and don't have the years of hard work and conditioning built up to be able to work their ass off every game.People mistake that with laziness but I honestly believe our players have poor stamina
