I question why Sir Alex signed him in the first place and he's not showed me that's he's good enough in the 8 years that he's been here.
18
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 41
- Clean sheets
- 6
- Goals
- 3
- Assists
- 4
- Yellow cards
- 14
- Red cards
- 1
- Status
A constant reminder of our mediocrity.
Captain...ffs!
Captain...ffs!
I agree, or at the very least he should have been given a reduced role. Such as cup ties, home games against the bottom six, and not being the captain.
The fact he's the skipper and a concrete starter is bonkers.
The set pieces and hoofing were killing my eyes.
We don't really expect much though. We just have to keep slating him because he continues getting contract extensions and continues getting played as a starter. It's frustrating.
The fact that woody give him a new contract does not fill me with much hope for are next transfer window.
I dont know why he keeps trying that pass, won't even say he losses possession 9/10 times as it means he will complete 10 out of 100. It's more like he will complete 1 or 2 in 100 attempts.
Awful performance, hard to think of a performance worse than this, this season. Hopefully he has played his last game for us.
Awful performance, hard to think of a performance worse than this, this season. Hopefully he has played his last game for us.
I thought he was playing fine earlier in the season and could see why he got an extension.
However his performances since signing have been an utter joke. He's become a massive liability in defence and it's amazing the stick that Smalling gets for his passing when the guy immediately to his right hoofs the ball back to the opposition like his life depends on it.
However his performances since signing have been an utter joke. He's become a massive liability in defence and it's amazing the stick that Smalling gets for his passing when the guy immediately to his right hoofs the ball back to the opposition like his life depends on it.
Garbage tonight. Longballs found no one, set pieces underhit. Works hard but can’t defend. Liability when under pressure like tonight.
All maximum effort, commitment and playing up to the badge with substandard quality. Welcome to the Manchester United way.
Another overpromoted squad player.
Time to get rid, or just have him around the squad. Shouldn't be playing the amount of games he is. We need to replace with top quality. If he is in our starting line up next season, then it says a lot about our aspirations as a club.
This should be his Gary Neville moment really.
Last season I was losing my mind seeing him and Darmian play at RB/LB and I couldn't wait till summer so that we could improve the wingback positions. I was in for a massive shock when the season started and the transfer window ended. One year on I still can't believe how a massive club like Manchester United has to rely on the likes of Ashley Young at right back. It's an absolute disgrace and a slap to the clubs face. If we start next season with him or his other fullback colleagues (except for Shaw and Dalot) in our starting lineup than it's a clear sign of this clubs aspirations and a confirmation from the owners/board that they couldn't care less.
Just shows how much of a joke we are as a club when Young our captain, our starting RB at 33 and to top it off, we handed him a new deal! It's a joke really. Played under 3 failed managers too, how this guy is still here is well beyond me, it defies logic. It's not just game either, he has been crap for ages, but gets away with it for some reason, something I can't explain. But "he's a leader" or something so he gets away with it. Such an annoying player
Doesn't hurt to bring Valencia back till end of the season.
If he's starting for us next season then I give up with football.
Or even Darmian
He's been a liability far too many times, needs to go to his level of mid or bottom table club.
Yeah, totally.
There was no need of that challenge. He knows he is on a yellow ffs
I completely missed his first booking... So I was shocked as feck when the card came out.
Feck is he doing sliding in like that when he's on a booking. Madness
Feck is he doing sliding in like that when he's on a booking. Madness
Won't say that, but not that wrecklessly.
Fecking embarrassing to even discuss it. Next week this chap will line up against Messi, as our captain. It makes me wanna vomit.
Some of the shit he does is absolutely baffling. Just like that hoof up to Lukaku that never achieves anything. But he'll persist over and over again.
He's so limited it's astonishing that not only does he get picked, but he's captain for goodness sake. That tackle was beyond stupid in a crucial game for our season.
He's so limited it's astonishing that not only does he get picked, but he's captain for goodness sake. That tackle was beyond stupid in a crucial game for our season.
I dont understand how some people can tell that he is good and consistent. Consistent in mediocrity maybe. He cant pass, he cant tackle, he always argue with the ref, he makes stupid decisions and cheats at times.
Honestly he's been the worst of our starters this season. I think the only reason Ole starts him is because of his leadership. We need to sell him. That will left us with one RB as Dalot, so we might need to buy a new one. I hate Ashley Young but I'm being objective on the lads performances. I hate Smalling too but I admit that overall he's been good and reliable this season.
Honestly he's been the worst of our starters this season. I think the only reason Ole starts him is because of his leadership. We need to sell him. That will left us with one RB as Dalot, so we might need to buy a new one. I hate Ashley Young but I'm being objective on the lads performances. I hate Smalling too but I admit that overall he's been good and reliable this season.
Darmien to the rescue? Valencia?
Good guy, decent player but times up.
Displaced Di Maria and broke back into England squad to go to Moscow where he was good.
Very good career.
Displaced Di Maria and broke back into England squad to go to Moscow where he was good.
Very good career.
It pains the soul.
This would be just as crazy as starting and having Young as captain is. If not crazier.
How worse can it get.
To think Sir Alex signed him in order to help compete with Barcelona at the time too, what a joke 
. Absolute joke of a player and has always been bang average, the ability to whip in a decent cross every now and again or score a banger every now and again does make you a great player.
. Absolute joke of a player and has always been bang average, the ability to whip in a decent cross every now and again or score a banger every now and again does make you a great player.Woah, what's with the posts criticizing Sir Alex?
He's an anomaly, magic works with even average players. His successors are not.
He's an anomaly, magic works with even average players. His successors are not.
On a yellow, might as well continue making stupid risky challenges.
*Sent off*
Beautiful leadership.
Exps meant jackass nothing if he's not using it.
*Sent off*
Beautiful leadership.
Exps meant jackass nothing if he's not using it.
(Snip - no .gifs)
Last edited by a moderator:
Like watching Gary Neville away at West Brom.
Truly atrocious. The end of a career. The club should think about moving him on in the summer.
Truly atrocious. The end of a career. The club should think about moving him on in the summer.
He can't even cross like he used to. Sick of the sight of this guy losing ball after ball cheaply for nothing. Wouldn't play for the Wolves and Everton teams.
Hoooooooooooooof!!
We extended this guy's contract
- Status