always_hoping
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2013
- Messages
- 7,758
He is getting slaughtered by his fans tooHe will be slaughtered if his name is Maguire.
He's always been cumbersome and maybe even more so now. Just as slow as Maguire and not great aerially.Wonder if United were right about those 'fat genes' because I'm sure he was a lot more athletic only a year ago. He looks to have filled out a fair bit and become really cumbersome.
Some achievement. Granted he’s looked a bit shaky at times since the restart but there’s no doubt he’s improved us at the back. When you think what we’ve had there in recent years he’s much better just have to find him a partner with pace that’s the area where he’s found lacking. Not to sound to Brendan like but he’s showed great character stepping up to Utd and taking on the captains armband after just walking in the door. Hope he finally fires a bullet header past Leicester on Sunday, preferably the winner.
An excellent point.At least he stays fit which is an anomaly trait for our centre backs in recent times.
And very interesting. He’s never looked tired either. Unfocused perhaps at times, but not physically tired.
Wow!!!!! Thank you for being a reliable fit CB <--- our highest risk department.
Maguire actually played through injury for us. Just goes to show how much Ole trusts him
Considering he's played every minute I'd say he undoubtedly excels at staying fit, being in shape and not getting injured.Is it just me or does Harry not excel at pretty much anything. I don't think I could say what his best attribute is.
It’s obviously silly that he’s included in any such team, but it also shows the shocking level of defenders in the Premier League this season.Norwegian football experts and pundits put him in their PL team of the season.
He's the only United player that made it, although Bruno was close.
Why? We only conceded 3 more goals than Liverpool, the best defensive team. And that's despite DDG having played his arguably worst season yet.It’s obviously silly that he’s included in any such team
Remove DDGs errors that directly lead to goals and we'd we level.Why? We only conceded 3 more goals than Liverpool, the best defensive team. And that's despite DDG having played his arguably worst season yet.
Has Maguire even been our best defender? I certainly don't think so.Why? We only conceded 3 more goals than Liverpool, the best defensive team. And that's despite DDG having played his arguably worst season yet.
I think so.Has Maguire even been our best defender? I certainly don't think so.
I think Lindelof has been more consistent and overall better than him, though Maguire has had better one off performances.I think so.
He's definitely been our best CB, though. That's what matters the most in this case.
Not a chance.I think Lindelof has been more consistent and overall better than him
Brilliant in the air defensivley, but could have had 3 goals in the past few games and has missed many headers throughout the season on the attacking front, which I think has been a big let down.Considering he's played every minute I'd say he undoubtedly excels at staying fit, being in shape and not getting injured.
And obviously he's fecking brilliant in the air.
No offence.I think Lindelof has been more consistent and overall better than him, though Maguire has had better one off performances.
I never mentioned 1 on 1 defending and I never said he hasn't made a difference, I just don't think he has clearly been our best defender.No offence.
But, there are more to football than 1 vs 1 situations.
I find it almost disturbing how people who have seen this team with and without him, can't tell the difference.
Anyways get used to him. He's here to stay. And that's awesome!
I actually think it's the exact opposite.. when Maguire makes a rare mistake it's usually magnified because of his price tag. When Lindelof does it people are like typical lindelof. If we go by recency bias then I can see how people could say Lindelof had a better seasonI think Lindelof has been more consistent and overall better than him, though Maguire has had better one off performances.
And this is very unfortunate - we could do very well with the like of Beckenbauer, to be frankHe must realise that he is not Beckenbauer.