Hephaestus
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2018
- Messages
- 5,187
Good start to the second half though.
I will say what everyone thinks, Italy should be ditched in favor of Georgia, they have been given enough rope.Good win by the French. In some ways I thought they should have been braver in high ball situations but they managed to hold on. Some pivotal decisions/moments decided it such as Ntamacks interception for his try and the no call on the penalty try for Wales.
France though answered the question on their last 20 minutes intensity.
The less said about Italy/Scotland the better.
Scotland were very, very poor too though.I will say what everyone thinks, Italy should be ditched in favor of Georgia, they have been given enough rope.
I agree but Italy have only won one game in the last 6 tournaments and they are currently below Georgia in the IRB ranking. Scotland are poor but Italy is just something else.Scotland were very, very poor too though.
It at the very least needs a promotion-relegation play off in the summer before they go off touringI will say what everyone thinks, Italy should be ditched in favor of Georgia, they have been given enough rope.
100%I will say what everyone thinks, Italy should be ditched in favor of Georgia, they have been given enough rope.
100%
At least give Georgia a playoff to prove their worth. The annoying thing is these arguments about protecting the game in Italy are given because it's Georgia knocking on the door, but in a few years if it's a bigger country like Russia, Spain or Germany they'll drop Italy like a shitty stick.
The big problem with Italy is that after 20 years they have no player development system, it's a big country yet they mainly rely on poaching bad players from other countries. Their all time best players, Parisse and Dominguez, are argentine both were among the very best in their positions and yet a "small" rugby country like Argentina that mainly, if not exclusively, relied on amateur and college rugby managed to become a very competitive nation that no one wants to play in the knock out stages of the RWC, Japan who have followed the foreign routes are also developing very exciting technically and tactically skilled that are Japan born and/or bred.It ‘s the 20th year Italy havBig been in 6N and no progress. Time has it be up.
Him and murray are done. They were the biggest decisons coming into the 6 nations and i think farrell got both wrongWhat's up with Sexton?
I have no idea, he plays like someone concussed.What's up with Sexton?
You concentrate 8 opposing players in a relatively small area, which gives lots of space to the backs when you have good predetermined pass combinations.As someone who doesn't watch a massive amount of rugby - what's the point of the scrum, aside from allowing the team that's winning to waste a load of time?
Now if you asked that question in a league thread.....As someone who doesn't watch a massive amount of rugby - what's the point of the scrum, aside from allowing the team that's winning to waste a load of time?
Excellent post. This makes so much sense.Six Nations must definitely change the tournament rules because
1) Georgia deserves a fair chance.
2) The current system is now unfair (It was fine 10-20 years ago).....a relegation system would also improve the level of all games on Matchday 5.
3) A new team would make the Six Nations much more interesting too.
Six Nations
England
Wales
Ireland
France
Scotland
Italy
Promotion League (Best team goes up)
Georgia
Spain
Romania
Portugal
Netherlands
Russia
The Southern Hemisphere should have their "Six Nations" tournament too!!!
"Six Nations"
New Zealand
Australia
South Africa
Argentina
Japan
Fiji
Promotion League
Tonga
Samoa
USA
Uruguay
Canada
Namibia
Talk of South Africa joining the six nations. Instead of joining they should replace Italy.It ‘s the 20th year Italy havBig been in 6N and no progress. Time has it be up.