Well no wonder newbies with very few posts make it up these days. Don't think opening newbs to mains members is a good idea but like I said if you people need any help, count me in.
We're trialling a new newbie system
- Thread starter Niall
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
Now there's an idea...
It's not that no one's being promoted, you can see in the newbie intro thread in the general that promotions are happening. It's just that a lot of the people we're promoting now joined in previous years and when you look at their posting history, it looks like a lot of those gave up posting for months or years before deciding to restart posting and get promoted.
So we know that some good posters get put off for a while, but we think that probably means that we lose some other potentially good posters completely.
Last edited:
Explains why most of the newer posters sound like 10 year old girls.
Oh yeah I just went there. #burn
Does that means all the good posters have already been promoted to the mains...
Might be time to close the newbs down completely.
Great decision, lot of people I know never post here because the promotion system seems very tough. I actually realized after posting in the newbs that it's not that hard to be honest but it definitely scares a lot of people away.
It's really not easy to post in the newbies, the results of that survey are spot *on. When registering most probably don't even realise there is a newbie system. I think the filtering aspect of it is essential, but it's probably about striking a balance between allowing only sensible people to post and not deterring sensible people from leaving due to lack of involvement with the mains, which is what they signed up for.
Last edited:
Good times.
Imagine being trapped in the FF after a loss. Now that's abusing newbies.
Question: Has the amount of people signing up been affected by making the general private?
Question: Has the amount of people signing up been affected by making the general private?
Can we have a rating or score system for the idiots who ruin the game day threads? like 5 thumbs down and they are out of the thread?
Seems strange that after 8 likes they can't go in newbie forums....they might be stuck on 8 for a while.
How does one become a scout? Can i be one
How does one become a scout? Can i be one
How about 5 thumbs down and they loose a like?
Sounds great. Seems fair that they get a chance to prove themselves in the big leagues rather than being stuck in the newbs for months or years. I was pretty lucky and made a couple of posts a mod liked and got fast-tracked, but I can imagine it being very frustrating to good posters who don't get noticed for whatever reason.
This is a positive change, the old system when i signed up in 2007 was so frustrating, i remember i needed like 150 points and i gave up around 132 and stopped posting altogether, few years later i get a message i'm being promoted, and yes back then it certainly felt like you needed to write an essay to get points.
But i'm afraid only 5 posts will deter people from posting, it's like worrying about your low internet quota, specially when they feel they're being judged by everyone else.
I can imagine their line of thinking, do i post in the rafael thread? no feck it it's not worth it, do i post in the we're worried threads? they'll probably think i'm a muppet, do i post in the unpopular opinion thread? now isn't the time to be unpopular. Just make it 10 or 20 posts, it'll even help weed out the bad posters faster.
But i'm afraid only 5 posts will deter people from posting, it's like worrying about your low internet quota, specially when they feel they're being judged by everyone else.
I can imagine their line of thinking, do i post in the rafael thread? no feck it it's not worth it, do i post in the we're worried threads? they'll probably think i'm a muppet, do i post in the unpopular opinion thread? now isn't the time to be unpopular. Just make it 10 or 20 posts, it'll even help weed out the bad posters faster.
People will be afraid to speak their mind then though,How about 5 thumbs down and they loose a like?
In the match day thread if we are playing really bad or one player in particular is not performing nobody will dare criticise the team for fear of a thumb down. That's not how it should be.
Anyway on the 5 posts in the mains I dont think that's enough, 10 would be much better to gain judgement on a member. Generally though the new system is good idea.
Great idea. It'll probably reduce the essay writing and allow for some quick, flowing debate. I remember the newbs could quickly turn into a dick swinging contest over who could fit the most syllables into a sentence.
I've had a bit of 'time off' from the forum during the summer since my promotion in preparation for the hard and gruelling season ahead but feel it's easy enough to get likes in the newbs if you are posting regularly and engaging in conversation with the other posters. I feel we might be seeing some strange posts coming up soon as the main problem with the newbies is its lack of conversation and abundance of posts that are far more complex than needed just trying to grab attention like a series of threads in the newbs not long before I made it to the big time about how to restructure every football competition ever played - about 10 threads of ridiculous theories each as peculiar as the last just in an attempt to gain attention.
I think this will be really fun being honest.
To throw in my two cents...I always thought 10 likes was a bit extreme, maybe after 4 likes I'd say you've pretty much determined they are genuine and not a WUM and maybe should be promoted and further moderated to generate more interest in the newbs. When you first sign up and see newbie posters with over 1000 posts or someone who joined ages ago when you have 0 posts I can understand why people don't bother...I nearly didn't because it can seem you may be there for years and years. Some other people just don't like the fact that their opinions and personality needs to be verified by others which is also understandable.
I think this will be really fun being honest.
To throw in my two cents...I always thought 10 likes was a bit extreme, maybe after 4 likes I'd say you've pretty much determined they are genuine and not a WUM and maybe should be promoted and further moderated to generate more interest in the newbs. When you first sign up and see newbie posters with over 1000 posts or someone who joined ages ago when you have 0 posts I can understand why people don't bother...I nearly didn't because it can seem you may be there for years and years. Some other people just don't like the fact that their opinions and personality needs to be verified by others which is also understandable.
I think 5 likes should be enough for promotion. Good enough evidence that the poster is not a complete idiot/spammer/whatever.
That is not how I remember the newbies at all.
Some people shouldnt speak at all. Go read the PSG game thread and that was a pre season game. It has to be a consensus and other posters can only vote once.
Probably just how I approached it! Lots of shite in there, but you could spot the ones 'trying' to get promoted a mile off.
I remember 90% of threads being what you could term textbook knee-jerk hysteria... but enough about the mains.
It's usually not what they say (certainly in terms of their views about football), as we always acknowledge different opinions. I give likes to loads of posts which I don't personally agree with and it would be dull if we were all saying the same thing.
The important thing is how they say it and whether they can debate with someone else without getting too worked-up.
I just like the fact that you are moving towards a system which allows more people to get in and I think you can always control them in the mains with bans etc. The idea of the newbies should be more about preventing unwanted spam rather than almost an exam that you have to clear.
Real hell would be an eternal state of limbo at RAWK. They'd write poetry about the lost souls of their loved ones.
Come to think of it, they're already all stuck between two worlds as it is: their past glory and their "never gonna happen init" future glory. That's Red And White Limbo alright.
This threads reminds me that I need to get more active in the football discussion.
I remember it exactly the same. Fortunately I wasn't there long (cus I'm class at posting and stuff) but there were soooo many essays by newbies trying to impress. Long is not always best (innuendo lol).
P.s. This means the general is still only visible at 10 likes right?
I agree totally with this and I'm pleased it is that way but I just feel at the initial sign up stage where you then realise there is a newbie process to go through some people by nature would never post in a forum where they feel what they have to say needs to be liked by someone else. It was just a point made to try and explain some of the unused accounts tbh.
On the other hand...Thanks very much for the likes in the newbs, they were much appreciated at the time and got me through the dark days but I didn't know if thanking for likes would go down that well - whilst on the subject I would like to extend these thanks to the other like-givers who have thrust this glory upon me.
Haven't read this thread (which I probably should do) but will the newbs be able to get likes for the posts in the mains? I don't think they should, I reckon it'll encourage a load of essay-writing as opposed to posting naturally and interacting with mains posters.
Yes they will if they make a good post, but we don't give many likes to over-long posts. They should know that, the modmins have told them often enough in the newbies.
Will this also increase the odds of me finally getting my 11th like?
How is it possible that someone stayed in the newbs for nine years? Were there fewer scouts and such back in the day, or did they just rarely post?
Not from any of the scouts, we only give likes to newbies!Will this also increase the odds of me finally getting my 11th like?
This.
It's incredibly hard to get likes as a newbie. When you're at 8 and only need 2 more likes, it'll seem even harder.
Who are the scouts anyway?
Nominations?
The majority of the forum survive on 5 posts per day so it's hardly that restrictive. It just means people need to be more considered about what they posts when they first join...and that can only be a good thing in the long run.
Eboue is one. I'm another. There are quite a few others.
dxadel is dead