He was good in his first season here, then very-very good in his 2nd and the EUROs...when you're a constant scapegoat even 1 bad game is enough for people to come at you, let alone a whole bad season. People are just so pathetic. The noise will die down after we get going under ten Hag and everyone is performing well, including Maguire. That will last until he makes 1 single mistake resulting in a goal when everyone will again act like he's been bad all these years.
He was inconsistent in his first season. Some very good, some good, some average, some bad, some very bad. An absolutely textbook example of inconsistency.
Second season he started absolutely terribly, just as bad as he's been this season. Thankfully it only lasted for about two months that time though, and he followed that up with another 2-3 months of being fairly inconsistent. However he was very good in the second half of that season, and took that form into the Euro's as well. At that time we all hoped that he'd stepped up and become the defender that we'd all been hoping he could. It had taken him 18 months to take that step up, but at least he'd gotten there...
Then of course we've all seen how he's played this season, where he was dreadful for the first half of the season and back to inconsistent and average (at best) in the second half.
I've quite liked Maguire since he was at Hull, and although we obviously overpaid I was hopeful of him when we did sign him (although I did think we would have to have the right partner). But he's been here three seasons now and he's only been consistently good for half of a season. It's simply not good enough.