- Joined
- Apr 13, 2022
- Messages
- 994
jesus are we now letting all of our young players go? Watch us having an injury crisis again an then we're fcked
A good move for who? He’s arguably our best right winger, and has already proven himself in the championship.
Amad's more suited to what I thought ETH was trying to build - a possession based team -- than say a garnacho. I guess we are sticking to our counter-attacking philosophy.I hope it's not true.
Garnacho's taken over on the right, but I'd still rather we have Amad taking Antony's minutes.
for any 21 year old that needs playing time.A good move for who?
He’d get plenty of it here if given half a chance.for any 21 year old that needs playing time.
That's the operative phrase. It's clear he fancies Antony over Amad -- a stackable offence if there was ever one.He’d get plenty of it here if given half a chance.
Sod that. I'd rather have him reducing Rashford's minutes.....I hope it's not true.
Garnacho's taken over on the right, but I'd still rather we have Amad taking Antony's minutes.
Come on now. Have you really run out of reasons to criticise the manager? Why make things up?That's the operative phrase. It's clear he fancies Antony over Amad -- a stackable offence if there was ever one.
Hard to give him a chance when he keeps picking up quite big injuries at the start of a season. He missed a loan to Feyenoord because of one and now he missed the first half of the season where he would have gotten a chance to prove himself.He’d get plenty of it here if given half a chance.
Yet he didn’t have a problem at Sunderland for an entire season, or at Rangers. I don’t think it’s anything too concerning, just bad luck. It’s probably best he’s kept at the club so it can be properly monitored.Hard to give him a chance when he keeps picking up quite big injuries at the start of a season. He missed a loan to Feyenoord because of one and now he missed the first half of the season where he would have gotten a chance to prove himself.
You must have been sleeping the last weeks. ETH is clearly delusional when it comes to Antony.WTF?
Yes, I understand Garnacho has embraced the RW as a proper footballer, but what if he goes down? Amad would be our only realistic option, unless ETH truly is deluded enough to believe that Antony -- who to the best of my knowledge has zero goal contributions this season -- can make an impact in the PL.
Someone’s been sleeping anyway because the last few weeks featured Antony being dropped for Garnacho and ETH giving an interview saying he hasn’t been good enough this season and needs to improve.You must have been sleeping the last weeks. ETH is clearly delusional when it comes to Antony.
Agree!If this happens ETH should be binned immediately
I do believe Timo Werner has more assists?WTF?
Yes, I understand Garnacho has embraced the RW as a proper footballer, but what if he goes down? Amad would be our only realistic option, unless ETH truly is deluded enough to believe that Antony -- who to the best of my knowledge has zero goal contributions this season -- can make an impact in the PL.
Nominative determinism in action.I doubt it’s true.
The only argument I can make in favor of this is that having missed half a season through injury he really needs to be starting for the next few months and he is clearly going to be behind Garnacho. Whilst he has proven he deserves the chance at this level after the Sunderland loan I don't know that getting 15 minutes as a sub in a dozen or so games is going to do much for him whereas at Boro he will undoubtedly be a nailed on starter and be able to get fully fit and ready to hit the ground running for next season. Antony is not really developing and it won't hurt him to be an occasional sub.What is going back to the Championship going to do for him? He already proved himself in that league last season.
Another young talent woefully misamanaged.
If he wants to develop in to a top player he needs to play in the top league. He’s been injured, now he’s not. He can get minutes for us until he’s fully match fit and we can better assess his potential.This is a good move. Season is half done and he has been injured for a long time. Regular game time under a manager like Carrick is exactly what he needs now. He needs to play, and thats not guaranteed after a injury like he had. He will get a new chance next season, he doesnt need bench time here or for a struggling side in the lower prem. This is a very reasonable loan
Good point.We’re going to see next to no rotation now so it makes sense, especially coming off an injury. We only have two midweek games for the rest of the season, baring FA cup replays.
It would make very little sense imho. Now is the perfect time to assess his ability in the PL before considering buying another right winger in the summer, as rumoured. The same mistake the club made before buying Sancho and Antony.We’re going to see next to no rotation now so it makes sense, especially coming off an injury. We only have two midweek games for the rest of the season, baring FA cup replays.
A good move for all, he needs match fitness, can play in the EFL Cup against Chelsea and potentially a final, we are short on games between now and the end of the year. If a Premier League club/European side isn't willing to guarantee minutes then it's about as good a move as we can get for him.A good move for who? He’s arguably our best right winger, and has already proven himself in the championship.
The club needs him, it’s a shower of shite at the moment. It’s like considering loaning Mainoo out because he needs minutes too.A good move for all, he needs match fitness, can play in the EFL Cup against Chelsea and potentially a final, we are short on games between now and the end of the year. If a Premier League club/European side isn't willing to guarantee minutes then it's about as good a move as we can get for him.
Mainoo is already match fit, so no,.nothing like that at all.The club needs him, it’s a shower of shite at the moment. It’s like considering loaning Mainoo out because he needs minutes too.