How exactly is he better than Kovar? What an incredibly shit goalkeeper. He is supposed to ooze confidence, but I feel like he's going to concede every time he gets a shot at him.
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 50
- Clean sheets
- 13
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 6
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Right decision to get rid of De Gea. Woeful decision to bring in this guy as his replacement.
How can you from excelling at two big clubs to that. Looks so bad at the technical aspects of goalkeeping
Should be sold as soon as possible, no messing around.
We can still scrape 20 million if we do it quick
We can still scrape 20 million if we do it quick
Guy is just a waste of money, real calamity. He does nothing right, purely a sack of shite signing he has turned out to be. We have to correct this signing as soon as possible because he causes us too many games. Has not made any genuine save.
Poor decision maker, stuck to his line, passing terrible and can barely remember him making a save… what a buy!
I think he's still mostly good on the ball, but his shot stopping has generally been poor, and his concentration seems to dip, it's happened twice now in the CL and cost us 2 games.
I also expected him to play a lot further forward, but he barely gets out more than DDG did.
I also expected him to play a lot further forward, but he barely gets out more than DDG did.
Just move him on, he’s not cut out for this.
Absolute clown.
Disgraceful performance. The only positive (if it may be called a positive) was that penalty was not scored
He's been a disaster
I defended him on the Palace goal because of a deflection, but tonight he was a joke.
Pressed all night, hit long balls all night, and can't save anything.
If de Gea put in this performance he would have been crucified.
Unfortunately it's not his first, and I don't think it will be his last.
Strong rumours that Bayindir was going to start, how I wish they had been true!
Pressed all night, hit long balls all night, and can't save anything.
If de Gea put in this performance he would have been crucified.
Unfortunately it's not his first, and I don't think it will be his last.
Strong rumours that Bayindir was going to start, how I wish they had been true!
That was De Gea-esque and I don't mean it as a compliment. I was a huge fan of this signing but he doesn't make it easy for his fans, does he!
Definitely willing to give him a chance still but that was shocking today. Cost us the match.
What I don't get is, he was playing it long more or less most of the game. We go a goal ahead, quite comfortable, then decides to play a risky pass into Casemiro, which results in a penalty and sending off. Couldn't make it up!
Transformational.
The worse #1 in United history?
The worst #1 in the league currently?
A keeper who cant keep.. we really are a special club.
The worst #1 in the league currently?
A keeper who cant keep.. we really are a special club.
Seems to lack agility or spring, gets planted in a position.
Nightmare start.
Nightmare start.
Ok..
I am in the camp that says he is shit.
Until further notice I will remain in the aforementioned camp
I am in the camp that says he is shit.
Until further notice I will remain in the aforementioned camp
And to think Raya was available on loan for £3m. Jesus wept.
Really disappointed with what I saw tonight. A very poor performance and cost us the game.
An absolute embarrassment tonight. I really hope he can find some way to turn things around because I was so happy with this signing but so far he's been an utter donkey for us.
Even regardless of the mistakes, he's just a useless keeper to have in the goal. You can't count on him to pull a save from a difficult position to save the team like De Gea used to in his prime. He'll save the easiest shots but won't be reliable to carry the team in off days.
He doesn't even command the box or give any sort of confidence to the defense in front of him. He's not a leader from the back.
He's not a bad keeper but he's not worth the money. Henderson himself wouldn't have done any worse than this.
If you're going to spend money, get someone who will be the difference like what Liverpool did with Alisson.
He doesn't even command the box or give any sort of confidence to the defense in front of him. He's not a leader from the back.
He's not a bad keeper but he's not worth the money. Henderson himself wouldn't have done any worse than this.
If you're going to spend money, get someone who will be the difference like what Liverpool did with Alisson.
Seems to switch off and will cost us points.
De Gea was poor and had to go, he can't find a club till now ffs. Signing Onana as a replacement was a terrible mistake. Admittedly I was excited by his CL final performance, but didn't know much about him. I'm 100% convinced that he was signed based on that performance. Whatever scouting we've been doing for the past year has gone out of the window for a player that ETH wanted.
Showing me why I never wanted him. I remember a lot of fans asking how his shot stopping was when we were linked to him when he has been playing in Europe for a while tells you all need to know.
We have to replace him soon, wasted money.
We have to replace him soon, wasted money.
My worst fears about him have been confirmed. Extremely poor at the basics. He also seems scared to do all the fancy stuff we signed him for. Well done, Erik. Another expensive dud.
He's a bit shit really.
And even if isn't, his long range kicking definitely is.
And even if isn't, his long range kicking definitely is.
Seems like he just doesn’t concentrate ever, so he can distribute like a top keeper but he can let in this shittest goals ever.
He’s the equivalent of that clip of the dad pushing his son onto the pitch.
He’s the equivalent of that clip of the dad pushing his son onto the pitch.
He needs to be dropped quickly before he gets ETH fired. I feel for ETH but this is the worst keeper I’ve seen at OT
It's so disappointing. I bought in to the idea he'd be "transformational". In reality he's another Barthez
Fair play to the ones that called it early, and apologies for not believing them, he’s absolutely shit.
Another £50 million down the drain on a former ETH player.
Another £50 million down the drain on a former ETH player.
He has transformed the team. He's made us far worse.
His positioning was infuriating. The moment Dalot let the ball bounce, was expecting him to charge out and claim it. Instead he gets rooted on the spot in no mans land and gets done. Ironically ddg would've stayed rooted to his line and be in position for that loopingb all.
Putting aside whether he is actually any good or not, has any keeper ever recovered from such a poor start at a club before? I remember DDG had a few shaky moments but his shot stopping was unreal.
Fergie signed some duds in his time. Onana is a Barthez level signing which means we should actively be monitoring goalkeepers that are available.
Palace's starting keeper the other day looked decent unti he got injured. Cheeky bid in the transfer window? 
Fecking hell man I'm still waiting for this generational passing display. He's just a worse De Gea!
Yeah I agree with this. This signing is the worst in a long list of shit signings post Sir Alex.