MyOnlySolskjaer
Creator of Player Performance threads
Wonderkid.
Err, he's 17.Not sold. Darmien looked like a future star during his first few games at United.
My bad, I got fooled by his haircut.Darmian is 26.
I'll get my coat.
Erm, given that he is naturally a CB, who has played for the U21s at CM, you would think he will be positionally suspect as a full back. The fact he made interceptions from the middle of the ground is probably the best indicator that he's yet to fully understand the role. But I don't think he's being overrated. He has a very high ceiling, but more importantly, he has the right attitude and mentality.He's got potential, but I think he's being a bit overrated at the moment. He's positionally suspect quite a few times. But he has all the abilities to become a top CM/CB and I really hope he fulfills his potential.
Depends on what role he is given though. Coz his passing is not great and needs working. And in the 4-2-3-1 we play, we don't really have a CDM ala The Makelele role.I'd love to see him in CM. Think he'd be pretty good in that role.
And Makelele could pass the ball, he started as a winger for Nantes.Depends on what role he is given though. Coz his passing is not great and needs working. And in the 4-2-3-1 we play, we don't really have a CDM ala The Makelele role.
Yeah, but I meant what the role personified. We don't really have a proper CDM in our system. Our ball winner is expected to create chances as well.And Makelele could pass the ball, he started as a winger for Nantes.
You need to be a good and accurate passer to play that role at a high level, you need to be a confident passer even when you are a water carrier. Now I don't think that Fosu Mensah has a particularly deficiency, the game is just a little bit too fast for him at the moment.Yeah, but I meant what the role personified. We don't really have a proper CDM in our system. Our ball winner is expected to create chances as well.
No, I disagree. He's more than easily adapted to more strenous facets of the game. How can he struggle in this ? I wouldn't actually say he struggles. just feel that he's usually not very aware of his teammates positions or the runs players make. There was this one moment in the second half where he was a little tight to the CB and Carrick was wide of him, deep in our own half. With Carrick being closed down, TFM unknowingly moved into a position that made Carrick's pass back to him much more safer and efective. I use the word unknowingly, coz up until that point, TFM was was just strolling looking around at options to whom Carrick could pass it too.You need to be a good and accurate passer to play that role at the high level you need to be a confident passer even when you are a water carrier. Now I don't think that Fosu Mensah has a particularly deficiency, the game is just a little bit too fast for him at the moment.
yeah clearly he's box to box player, capable to smash anyone from the ball in the middle and bring the ball forward, the reading of the game looked much better in the second half, was in beast mode how rio would say..Thought there were a couple of interceptions in the middle that showed what he can bring centrally.
Find it funny that despite clearly being in pain he still physically smashes everyone.
I'm talking about his mental clock when he is on the ball, I think that his problems of inconsistency are due to timing issues more than anything else. With experience the game is going to slow down in his head.No, I disagree. He's more than easily adapted to more strenous facets of the game. How can he struggle in this ? I wouldn't actually say he struggles. just feel that he's usually not very aware of his teammates positions or the runs players make. There was this one moment in the second half where he was a little tight to the CB and Carrick was wide of him, deep in our own half. With Carrick being closed down, TFM unknowingly moved into a position that made Carrick's pass back to him much more safer and efective. I use the word unknowingly, coz up until that point, TFM was was just strolling looking around at options to whom Carrick could pass it too.
Even from the few games I remember seeing him in U21s, his passing was a little inconsistent. But he can work on those things. The awareness will naturally come with more experience and game time. But I hope they develop him into one role though. I hate the idea of him becoming yet another Versatile player in our midst.
His best position is not a full back, I know, but the majority of people - such as me - are judging him on the games he has played for the first team, of which the majority of those have been at full back, where, he is being overrated.Erm, given that he is naturally a CB, who has played for the U21s at CM, you would think he will be positionally suspect as a full back. The fact he made interceptions from the middle of the ground is probably the best indicator that he's yet to fully understand the role. But I don't think he's being overrated. He has a very high ceiling, but more importantly, he has the right attitude and mentality.
His tackling ability and recovery pace is phenomenal.is it me or does he not committ a lot of fouls? clean tackler of the ball
It's good to have some strength and power at full back. I know Mourinho likes that. Would mean less games thinking, Smalling/Fellaini, who else is dominant in the air.He looks a huge prospect for sure. Sometimes dives in to tackles so needs to learn in that respect, but he looks good on the ball along with being a tank physically. Not sure if his passing is good enough to play as a center mid, but he seems like a future center back IMO. You need those who are pretty comfortable on the ball at the back too.
is it me or does he not committ a lot of fouls? clean tackler of the ball
I think he's a better tackler too. It's not just based on style either. His tackling success at youth level is really impressive. If it was just based on style then he would pick up a lot of fouls only and that would stand out, however anyone that watches him can see he is gifted at tackling.He is more like Phil Jones IMO only with more quality on the ball.
Yeah possibly. Still needs to be specialized into one role though.I'm talking about his mental clock when he is on the ball, I think that his problems of inconsistency are due to timing issues more than anything else. With experience the game is going to slow down in his head.
Aah, yeah then you are right. But most of our full backs have been woeful anyways. Even Borthwick-Jackson has been positionally very suspect and been beaten a few times in 1 v 1s.His best position is not a full back, I know, but the majority of people - such as me - are judging him on the games he has played for the first team, of which the majority of those have been at full back, where, he is being overrated.