I wanted Mourinho when SAF retired. Not because I am a massive fan of his, purely for the fact that he is a proven manager in the premier league and post Fergie, it was obvious the next manager coming in had a massive job on his hands following in the footsteps of a legendary manager.
I think Mourinho was the best manager suited to the transition at that time because he would have commanded the respect of the squad he inherited and would have in all probability continued to keep us challenging for honours while he evolved the team to his own.
I still think that Mourinho is the best available manager to come in and sort out the mess we have become. However much the nostalgic part of me would love to see Giggs get the job, I firmly believe that he should earn his managerial stripes elsewhere, and if successful, he would be welcome back at some point in the future.
We are in no position to experiment with an inexperienced manager with little or no managerial CV. We need a proven winner, with the credentials Mourinho has, and as Pep is committed to City, and Ancelotti to Bayern, He is our best bet at this time.