Zlatan Ibrahimovic |United Player | See the thread in the United Forum

Should we sign Ibra on a free this summer ?


  • Total voters
    1,389
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Jacob

Full Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2005
Messages
25,592
Zlatan said in a recent US interview that it would be hard to join with LvG in charge.
 

Adam-Utd

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
39,954
Zlatan said in a recent US interview that it would be hard to join with LvG in charge.
Newsflash fella, don't think that is going to be a problem..
 

RedStarUnited

Full Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2008
Messages
8,196
Yes, it's appealing - big name, still playing well (in a poor league), iconic figure in the game - but it also stinks of us signing someone who's 'doing us a favour'. Our most successful signings, not just in recent years (Martial, Blind, Shaw) but also historically (Cantona, Ronaldo, Rooney, Keane, Vidic...) have always had something to prove. They were either players hungry to take their game up to the next level or, players who needed the right platform (Eric again).

The prominent failures have been the big-money players who never really seemed to get the club or have the desire to prove their worth.

There are lots of talented players out there who have something to prove - we should be aiming for them instead.
Thing with Zlatan is, he has a huge ego. He basically needs to win to maintain the bullish attitude that he has.
 

Eckers99

Michael Corleone says hello
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Messages
6,117
Thing with Zlatan is, he has a huge ego. He basically needs to win to maintain the bullish attitude that he has.
I'm not convinced that rocking up thinking, 'I'm Zlatan!' would be enough of an assurance!
 

RedorDead21

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
9,219
If we still have Rooney...no thanks. If we sell Rooney....only yes thanks if we cannot bring in a Kane or similar.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,444
To finish, are some serious to think MUFC is a poor club that can't pay his wages?
United could afford to pay his wages a few times over if they wanted to, but that isn't the the concern some have. Some (myself included) are wondering if it makes good business sense to pay a player of his age massive wages. As sooner or later he will decline and possibly like Van Persie very sharply.

United make a shit load of money despite not being the best team right now, that won't last forever if we keep making bad deals and throwing money down the drain. Falcao, Di Maria and Valdes being 3 recent examples of mercenaries looking a pay day we wasted money on.

Let's look at Zlatan against ManCity to have a greater idea of his ability to succeed in the EPL.
City's defence aren't exactly a great measuring stick to judge a player against. Their defence isn't great.
 

Offside

Euro 2016 sweepstake winner
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
26,904
Location
London
Would probably bring back some serious fear factor and is clearly still a top player. I'd have him for a year.
 

Van Piorsing

Lost his light sabre
Joined
Feb 10, 2006
Messages
22,583
Location
Polska
Nobody worried about Zlatans reputation about being a cnut?
Absolutely yes, he may slap few of our youngsters for fun in training but then they may learn how to be an arrogant type of winners.

He's not a Costa type but my personal fear will be how much Mourinho will go far in letting him provoking everyone around. Opponents won't like that for sure.
 

dellboyy

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2013
Messages
927
Location
Manchester
Considering the number of young, inexperienced, not quite ready players we have in our squad, i'd sign him just for the experience and confidence he'd bring for them!

Plus i think he would actually be a star for us... he's not like the usual player of his age, so that argument is irrelevant. He's fit, in top form, and ready for a challenge.
 

fcbforever

New Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Messages
4,077
Location
Merkellandia, the land of silent horrors
Supports
FC Bayern München
Sure, he has lost a part of his pace but against Chelsea he has proved he is still strong to manage the EPL defenders. We are talking of player whose contract expires next summer...

He has shined against all the greatest clubs and nations.

- 62 goals in 112 games with Sweden (a weak country). 2015/16: 6 goals in 7 games with Sweden
- 51 goals in 126 games in Champions League. He scored against any clubs including Barcelona with PSG/Milan and delivered assists
- Best scorer many times of the Serie A and French Ligue 1
- Good stats with Barcelona.
- More than 25 trophies

The Brazilian Ronaldo has never won the Champions League.

For instance, let's look at his performances against Bayern Munich

Juventus 1-0 Bayern - October 2004




Bayern 0-1 Juventus- November 2004



Bayern 2-1 Juventus- Zlatan scored - October 2005



Juventus 2-1 Bayern - November 2005

You are trying to make it look like I said he's a bad player or something. Someone said he is a "big game player" these days, I denied that claim, that's it. I don't think he's a choker, or was, (as it was claimed) ever as well.
Yes, I think he is overhyped these days and would be a massive flop at United, different matter. What some games 12 years ago against a Bayern Munich which was pretty weak shall prove, I don't understand. Irrelevant.
And I know his CV, great one of course, but nothing all that glamourus if you take into consideration he played for the best clubs in the respective leagues all the time, other players have archieved similiar things by doing that.

He could be viewed as an arrogant player but he will make everyone - including the youth - stronger. He hasn't a whining mentality.

Moreover, he is slower and he likes to create opportunities for fast wingers.

To finish, are some serious to think MUFC is a poor club that can't pay his wages?
Nobody is saying United couldn't pay it, most wonder if United should.
 

MoskvaRed

Full Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2013
Messages
5,253
Location
Not Moskva
While he is still a very good player, I think United signing him at his age sends a worrying signal after Schweinsteiger and Falcao. Like we're a highly rewarding staging post between the elite clubs and the MLS.
 

Ecstatic

Cutie patootie!
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
13,787
Supports
PsG
United could afford to pay his wages a few times over if they wanted to, but that isn't the the concern some have. Some (myself included) are wondering if it makes good business sense to pay a player of his age massive wages. As sooner or later he will decline and possibly like Van Persie very sharply.

United make a shit load of money despite not being the best team right now, that won't last forever if we keep making bad deals and throwing money down the drain. Falcao, Di Maria and Valdes being 3 recent examples of mercenaries looking a pay day we wasted money on.
The career of Falcao is unfortunately finished since the 22nd January 2014: a harsh injury during a French Cup game against an amateur team (if you look at the tackle on YouTube, you will understand my point). So, everyone knew it was a big gamble and that is why, we had a £6m season-long loan move. Of course, his wages were high (£10m) so it was a pure loss of £16m. A predictable loss imho. Because, he didn't play since that injury before joining MUFC.

Regarding ADM, he was acquired £60m and then sold £44m: he didn't succeed for many reasons (injuries, tactical instability, traumatising burglary for his family and maybe the weather).

I am not a fan of the concept of mercenary that doesn't make sense in the football world today.

Regarding Ibra, massive wages for a contract whose length would be 1 year (with possible extension of 1 year) indeed but:

- no transactions costs. What is the market value of Aubamayang, Keane, Benzema or Higuain ?
- proven ability to excel in any circumstances and leagues
- an excellent scorer is always expensive
- a real leader on the pitch and the team needs experience and thus confirmed players

What I consider as a wast of money is the acquisition of average players overpaid like Schneiderlin, Fellaini or Mata (already in a large decline in his last months with Chelsea: completely ignored by Mourinho).

City's defence aren't exactly a great measuring stick to judge a player against. Their defence isn't great.
Agreed. However, if Ibra is able to shine against Chelsea and City, why won't he able to score against Southamption, Hull and Everton next year?

My modest opinion is to say he is still capable to score 30 goals - all competitions - next season.

With or without Ibra, imho, there is an urgent need to recruit a winger able to play on the right and ideally versatile like Griezmann.
 

Ecstatic

Cutie patootie!
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
13,787
Supports
PsG
You are trying to make it look like I said he's a bad player or something. Someone said he is a "big game player" these days, I denied that claim, that's it. I don't think he's a choker, or was, (as it was claimed) ever as well.
Sorry if I misunderstood one of your previous posts

Nobody is saying United couldn't pay it, most wonder if United should.
It simply depends on the availability of the greatest players.

- La Liga: Benzema and Griezmann would be excellent choices. I am sure you know other great opportunities/gambles there
- Bundesliga: Aubamayang is likely to join Real Madrid. Lewa will stay at Munchen.
- French league: Cavani & Dembélé deserve consideration. Mbappé & Lemar are interesting very young prospects.
- Calcio: Higuain is top
- EPL: Lukaku seems to have a good potential. Hard to acquire Kane. Are Mahrez & Vardy able to duplicate this season?

It is very great to rely on young promising players coming from the academy or outside.

However, I am those who think we need 1 confirmed offensive player given the disappointing performances of Rooney.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,444
Regarding Ibra, massive wages for a contract whose length would be 1 year (with possible extension of 1 year) indeed but:

- no transactions costs. What is the market value of Aubamayang, Keane, Benzema or Higuain ?
- proven ability to excel in any circumstances and leagues
- an excellent scorer is always expensive
- a real leader on the pitch and the team needs experience and thus confirmed players

What I consider as a wast of money is the acquisition of average players overpaid like Schneiderlin, Fellaini or Mata (already in a large decline in his last months with Chelsea: completely ignored by Mourinho).
Fellaini was certainly a waste of money (thanks Moyes) and never worth what we paid. Schneiderlin is a young player with potential, too early to say that money has been wasted.

But anyway back on Ibrahimovic lets not act like United signing a 35 year old striker for massive wages isn't a risk. It is theres no guarantee any big money signing will be a success. But when you sign one in the twilight of his career the risk increases in my opinion.

Agreed. However, if Ibra is able to shine against Chelsea and City, why won't he able to score against Southamption, Hull and Everton next year?

My modest opinion is to say he is still capable to score 30 goals - all competitions - next season.
He could well score against those teams, but i think people are completely underestimating how physically demanding the PL is as a league. It's harder than the French league certainly many players struggle and take time to adapt lots never do. It won't be easy for Zlatan to do so, and even if he does how long for.

Every match in england is a battle, there are very few easy games. Given his age i could easily see a scenario where his form dips mid season even if he is doing well.

He would have to be managed in his game time and personally 30 goals seems a bit optimistic to me.

With or without Ibra, imho, there is an urgent need to recruit a winger able to play on the right and ideally versatile like Griezmann.
Doubt you'll find a United fan who disagrees with you there mate.
 

Crossie

Full Member
Joined
May 28, 2015
Messages
4,929
Supports
vibrant attacking football
@Downcast
I'm sorry for my nit-picking but the myth that free agents come without transaction costs is untrue. Every player on a free demands a signing fee for him and his agent. Zlatan being Zlatan and Raiola being Raiola you can bet they'll demand plenty.
These signing fees will usally be lower than transfer fees, no doubt about it. But how much lower needs to be looked at on a case by case basis.
 

finneh

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
7,318
@Downcast
I'm sorry for my nit-picking but the myth that free agents come without transaction costs is untrue. Every player on a free demands a signing fee for him and his agent. Zlatan being Zlatan and Raiola being Raiola you can bet they'll demand plenty.
These signing fees will usally be lower than transfer fees, no doubt about it. But how much lower needs to be looked at on a case by case basis.
Agreed. He'll be looking for at least £20m in wages and signing on fees next season, given the fact that he's always been a mercenary, hes currently on a huge contract paid net of tax and he'll have offers from China, the Middle East and the US.

In terms of a medium term investment I'm not sure there's a more costly and risky investment in Europe.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,104
Location
Moscow
After tax? could get Messi and Neymar for that money :lol:
No, daily mail is just clickbaiting. The reports say that he wants 300k after tax (318,200 in case of this particular DM article)

What's funny that they talk about pre-tax salary with Zlatan, and yet, in the same article, they have a table of EPL highest-earners with after-tax salaries
 

Zoo

Full Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2010
Messages
29,979

Ibra will reject China. Wants to go to United.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.