Liam Rosenior - Easily the most under-rated pundit. Smooth as silk, insightful as feck, sensible, calm and intelligent. Just a wonderful pundit.
Jamie Carragher - The best of the big guns. Has risen above any Liverpool bias he used to have and weirdly often comes across like he kind of cares about Utd as a club.
Rio Ferdinand - Insightful, very honest as a pundit, talks in a way that takes you into the role and mindset of the player.
Craig Bellamy - Dry, blunt, honest, seems to care about getting to the crux of the subject.
Jermaine Jenas (recently has improved) - offers good detail these days when breaking down a game, and can at times be pretty insightful.
Frank Lampard - Bit like Rosenior - intelligent, calm, seems unbiased.