[amolbhatia50k]

Such a daft challenge.

 

[Lawman]

Never United quality a time bomb of a player.

 

[ZDwyr]

Had a poor game. Looked off the pace all match I thought. Has impressed me more as a LB.

 

[Irrational.]

A poor game, but he's better as a LB than a CB. He's far too rash at CB, he can get away with it at LB with players like Smalling there to bail him out.

 

[MAME DIOUF 32]

Brain dead challenge. He's constantly an accident waiting to happen.

 

[goin4glory]

People are over overreacting. He's a very good CB even if he's prone to making mistakes.

 

[Cheesy]

Never United quality a time bomb of a player.

He's been quite good lately to be fair, but yeah, ridiculous challenge. Hopefully it's a one-off, although it's a shame to see him relapsing into daft errors.

 

[devilish]

He reminds me alot of Silvestre. He's got all the skills to succeed but lacks the brain. Hence why he's a disaster waiting to happen. In my opinion he's nothing more than Shaw's cover. We should add a CB and RB and the defense will be sorted

 

[izec]

Better Lb than CB.

 

[Cheesy]

People are over overreacting. He's a very good CB even if he's prone to making mistakes.

Mostly agree with what you're saying, but very good CB's just shouldn't be error prone. Despite his recent improvement, errors stop a good CB from being a top class one.

 

[ManUArfa]

The attacker was backing in to him as he was making the challenge which meant he was never going to get any of the ball. He didn't need to make it though, just staying tight and stopping a shot was all that was needed....

 

[Eugenius]

He'd done well at LB in recent games, but that penalty was just typical Rojo. Getting too tight, making challenges that don't need to be made. Might work when you're a LB on the halfway line but not in your fecking penalty box in the 85th minute. No one with half a brain thinks to make a nick the ball there.

 

[goin4glory]

Mostly agree with what you're saying, but very good CB's just shouldn't be error prone. Despite his recent improvement, errors stop a good CB from being a top class one.

How many errors have we seen Ramos/Koscielny/Hummels etc make over the past few years? It's the nature of the game when you play as a front foot CB.

 

[Jev]

Bit of an overreaction. He's proved himself to be a useful player lately. He's just not good enough to be a United starter, that doesn't mean he's a completely useless player.

 

[togg]

It was a mistake..the player had his back to goal and wasn't threatening, but I'm sure he was trying to make sure he couldn't pass to a player in a better position. He's a great squad player and has played really well recently and generally had a good game. People like to get on his back on here.

 

[Sunny Jim]

Imo soft peno

 

[Lawman]

Imo soft peno

You mean stupid peno? So rash and just downright brainless!

 

[Halftrack]

People are over overreacting. He's a very good CB even if he's prone to making mistakes.

Yeah, he's one of those players who'll usually do well, but then the moment he makes a mistake people will come crawling out to label him as shite and wish him sold.

 

[Lentwood]

Never understood why some people have it out for Rojo, apparently he is error prone but don't remember too many howlers. In fact can't think of any. Made a mistake today but doesn't warrant the criticism he has had

 

[BarstoolProphet]

You certainly are.

I agree. Stupid reaction from me. Just pissed because it was so damn stupid.

 

[JPRouve]

I remember my reaction when Smalling got sent off against City last season, so I will only say, shit happens.

 

[Will Absolute]

I remember my reaction when Smalling got sent off against City last season, so I will only say, shit happens.

Well, he had a reputation for rashness when he came and he's somewhat lived up to it. Done a lot of good things as well of course.

 

[2mufc0]

Jeez some people have really bad memories, give the guy a break.

 

[RonaldoVII]

There's a reason he wasn't considered ready to start today, be it fitness or travel etc. He got out of jail with our late winner but so did our attack who failed to create/convert however many chances.

 

[2 man midfield]

Would much rather see him at left back and Blind at centre back. But we seem to like switching them at will.

 

[Eric'sCollar]

Thought he had a decent game. Really poor decision to try and win the ball but I think he will learn from that, just glad that it hasn't cost us.

 

[Acole9]

Stupid challenge to give away the penalty, could've cost us the match.

 

[DarkXaero]

Never understood why some people have it out for Rojo, apparently he is error prone but don't remember too many howlers. In fact can't think of any. Made a mistake today but doesn't warrant the criticism he has had

I don't understand it myself. People have this pre-conceived notion of him as a rash, brainless player who can't defend, when in truth, he has been mostly solid for us. I guess it's because he's tatted up, looks like a thug, and the rash reputation is coming from his days as a Sporting player. There are CBs who are worshipped on here, that make stupid mistakes time to time, but you won't see this kind of reaction.

 

[K2K]

I don't understand it myself. People have this pre-conceived notion of him as a rash, brainless player who can't defend, when in truth, he has been mostly solid for us. I guess it's because he's tatted up, looks like a thug, and the rash reputation is coming from his days as a Sporting player. There are CBs who are worshipped on here, that make stupid mistakes time to time, but you won't see this kind of reaction.

Pre-concieved ideas play a huge role on here...once people label a player as something, then they will ignore everything else except what confirms whatever bias that they have.

He made a mistake, but he's had a very strong run of form recently, and the comments are over the top.

 

[Green_Red]

He doesn't seem to have the most focused head on his shoulders, he is slow, makes rash challenges and needs to shed a few pounds.. typical United full back! lol

 

[RedPnutz]

I wonder if the overreacting posters here get fired from their jobs the first mistake they make, expelled from school which seems more reflective of the age goven the quality of posts and opinions.

 

[NotQuiteManc]

Silvestre, very good at LB especially his crossings. Had a good season with Rio at CB.

 

[RedTiger]

I like him. he made a big feck up for the penalty but otherwise he was ok.

 

[Annahnomoss]

Jones is still fighting injuries, but with Blind settled in there and Rojo as the back up we're not suffering from it really. Every time he plays he does well and just need to stay injury free and we also have a 25 year old Rojo who can certainly improve as well.

 

[surf]

In 9 seasons Silvestre played over 360 games for us. I'll be surprised if Rojo gets to that level.

 

[amolbhatia50k]

To be fair to Rojo he's been very good defensively this season. Rarely has he been beaten one on one or been found out of position. So far he's been impressive when he's played. But he is a rash and aggressive defender and he's always on the edge between dominant and careless. In the copa America he was foolishly rushing into tackles repeatedly. So either we play him at left back always where we can afford the odd foul, and/or he learns that in the box you have to be extra cautious. But he's done well this season despite the very poor mistake.

 

[GledTheRed]

In 9 seasons Silvestre played over 360 games for us. I'll be surprised if Rojo gets to that level.

He was a mistake waiting to happen in 350, Rojo is a superior player.

 

[Bobcat]

Jeez some people have really bad memories, give the guy a break.

This.
1. Hes still young
2. He just came here for Sporting, needs time to adjust
3. He has had quite a few injuries and has not played that much
4. He was immense at LB for a couple of games (City and Wolfsbusrg?) and delivered genuine MOTM performances.

Give the guy a break

 

[Loublaze]

He was a mistake waiting to happen in 350, Rojo is a superior player.

Last united defender to score twice against Liverpool in one game. He's a legend by default. Silvestre> Rojo

 

[Erebus]

In 9 seasons Silvestre played over 360 games for us. I'll be surprised if Rojo gets to that level.

I still feel more confident with Rojo than I ever did with Silvestre