I’m exaggerating. He did score a hat trick in the reserves game before his two match winners. But the point was more that his main quality seemed to be the ability to be ATRPATRT, as it seemed with Rashford, re the post I answered. Which I think doesn’t look like a talent of Rashford, or James Wilson, or Welbeck, or many other young players who score on their debut not because they are great poaching talents, but because they are dead eager and the opposition is lax in marking them.
The truth is that developing 95% of talented 18-20 year olds is normally a slow process, where fans normally go more critical at all the while weaknesses are gradually ironed out and the strengths come in increasingly frustrating spurts.
If we’re to believe the fans in the Rashford/Martial threads, one of them is a talentless parasite on the club and the other would be world class in days if just LVG came back. Truth is, at their age, it’s not hard to find great faults in both of them, and they both have big strengths, neither of which are consistent enough to build a top team around so as to mask their weaknesses.
At Everton, Martial would look like Richarlison. At Liverpool, neither of them would look like Mané, and hence more like Solange. (Not in playing styles, but in impact). In the Mourinho threads, Rash and Martial are both thwarted geniouses, in the Woodward thread, they’re both duds and why didn’t he splash for Dembele.
They are both young and promising that might have a future at Utd long term, but far from finished product, and I wish polemics could be left aside to just let them develop in a normal pace without all the large words bandied about all the time.